Watch CBS News

CBS News poll: Americans say tax plan helps wealthy, not middle class

Tax plan impact
Impacts of the tax overhaul plan 01:33

By Jennifer De Pinto, Fred Backus, Kabir Khanna and Anthony Salvanto

Republicans expect economic boost, but not personal tax cut

The Republican tax plan faces opposition from a majority of Americans. Over half disapprove of it – including four in 10 who disapprove strongly, and only one in five Americans expect their own taxes to go down.  Though the plan finds support from Republicans who believe it will help the economy overall, only one-third of Republicans expect their own taxes to go down. Large majorities of all political stripes believe the plan will help corporations and the wealthy, but only one in three believe it will help the middle class. 


Partisanship plays more of a factor than income when assessing the Republican plan:  Democrats of all income levels tend to oppose the plan, while the plan is favored by Republicans regardless of income. 

Few Americans think the plan will lead to lower taxes for them personally, and this is true of Republicans as well, despite their strong support of the plan. One-third of Republicans think their taxes will be lowered; most Democrats expect their own taxes will go up. By almost a 2 to 1 margin, independents are more likely to think they'll go up rather than down.


Most Americans of all political persuasions believe the plan will help large corporations, the wealthy, and Wall Street investors. More think these groups will benefit than think they themselves would. 


This is the case among Republicans too. Just over half think the plan will help them and their families, a figure that drops to a quarter among Americans overall. 


Republican optimism about the plan's effect on the economy may be because Republicans agree with the idea that large corporations will use the money they save from tax cuts to create jobs.  Six in 10 Republicans think this will happen. Just over a quarter of Americans overall agree.


Republicans also see some benefits to the Republican tax plan that other Americans do not.  Seven in 10 Republicans think the new tax plan will help the economy.  This view is shared by just 6 percent of Democrats and just a third of Americans overall.


Despite low expectation of tax relief for themselves, more than three in four Republicans say the plan is fair to people like them, a sentiment that cuts across income levels, suggesting that their views are driven more by the prospects for the wider economy.  In contrast, nearly nine in 10 Democrats say the plan is unfair.

Republicans are more apt to say the tax plan favors both large campaign donors and average Americans. But most Americans overall - including eight in 10 Democrats - say the plan favors large campaign donors over average Americans.  

While most Democrats and over half of independents think it's just a few people at the top of the economy that have a chance to get ahead, three in four Republicans think the playing field is even.  

Republicans are more likely than they were last year to think everyone had a fair chance to get ahead in the U.S. 

More than half of Americans say they would be either disappointed or angry if the tax plan is signed into law.  Even among Republicans, enthusiasm is somewhat muted.  While most Republicans would be satisfied to see the Republican plan enacted, just one in five describe themselves as excited by the prospect.


Things could still change. Fewer than half of Americans feel they have a good understanding of what they plan will do.  Most – 56 percent - feel they haven't heard enough about it yet, however, of those who say they do have a good understanding, 56 percent strongly disapprove of the plan.

The Tax Plan: Impact on the deficit, social programs

Republicans are relatively more likely than Democrats or independents to say an increase in the federal budget deficit is acceptable if their own income taxes are lowered. Forty-three percent of Republicans say this would be acceptable if their income taxes are lowered, while only 25 percent of Democrats and 33 percent of independents also feel this way.

But most Republicans don't believe the new tax plan will grow the deficit. Sixty percent of Republicans think the plan will decrease the deficit over time.  This view is not shared by most Democrats and independents.

And while most Americans overall think the tax cuts will be paid for at least in part with cuts to Medicare and Social Security, most Republicans (51 percent) don't think this will happen.

Where Republicans (62 percent) agree with most Americans is that changes to the Affordable Care Act – such as the elimination of the individual mandate - should not be part of the Republican tax plan, most Republicans who would prefer that the ACA be left out of the legislation nevertheless approve of the Republican plan in large numbers.

President Trump

Republicans see the tax plan as Donald Trump keeping a campaign promise.   


Republicans may see this tax plan as the president keeping a campaign promise because they are far less likely than Democrats or independents to see his administration's policies as favoring the rich over other groups. 

President Trump's handling of both tax policy and the deficit is met with disapproval among most Americans, but large majorities of Republicans approve. Of the issues asked about in the poll, he gets his highest approval rating from Americans on his handling of the economy. 

Sixty-four percent say the nation's economy is in good shape. The public's views of the economy have been positive for the past year. 

Overall, 36 percent of Americans approve of the job Donald Trump is doing as president, while 57 percent disapprove. That's a slight dip in his approval since late October but similar to where it was in September.  Most Republicans continue to approve, while Democrats overwhelmingly disapprove. 


This poll was conducted by telephone December 3-5, 2017 among a random sample of 1,120 adults nationwide.  Data collection was conducted on behalf of CBS News by SSRS of Glen Mills, PA.  Phone numbers were dialed from samples of both standard land-line and cell phones.

The poll employed a random digit dial methodology. For the landline sample, a respondent was randomly selected from all adults in the household. For the cell sample, interviews were conducted with the person who answered the phone. 

Interviews were conducted in English and Spanish using live interviewers. The data have been weighted to reflect U.S. Census figures on demographic variables. 

The error due to sampling for results based on the entire sample could be plus or minus four percentage points. The error for subgroups may be higher and is available by request. The margin of error includes the effects of standard weighting procedures which enlarge sampling error slightly.

This poll release conforms to the Standards of Disclosure of the National Council on Public Polls.

Poll toplines

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.