Last Updated May 18, 2011 9:34 AM EDT
Recent research shows it might not be an either/or question. Working virtually can increase employee happiness and satisfaction (if it's done right) AND there's a way to quantify that satisfaction to satisfy the money folk. The key is to do it right.
Philip Ross is the CEO of Cordless Group and Unwork.com. He's an author who looks into the future of work. Bob Gaudreau's an Executive VP at Regus, the world's largest provider of flexible workspaces. They recently collaborated on a white paper called "VWork: Measuring the Benefits of Agility At Work". Not surprisingly, (Regus, does after all, make their money renting temp and flexible office space) they found all kinds of benefits to working virtually. What's more surprising is a forumla they use to show return on investment: what they call the "Agility Dividend".
It measures three things: the "Efficiency Dividend" (property costs x fixed and operating costs), the "Productivity Dividend" (downtime x salary costs), and what they call the "Happiness Dividend" (commuting costs x time and cost savings).
It might be a stretch to suggest that our happiness is inextricably tied to our commute, but the numbers are pretty interesting. Most people in cities want a 10-15 minute commute, but most of us travel over 45 minutes each way. If we didn't have to schlep to the corporate headquarters every day we could save a lot of time, stress and money.
This means that using so-called "third places" like temporary or shared office space, branch offices with "hotelling" capabilities and even the local Starbucks can give employees more choices in where and how to work. Technology makes it possible, the wide availability of choices makes it practical, what stands int he way much of the time is company policy (finance, IT and HR). That's where convincing the people with the purse strings comes in.
According to Ross and Gaudreau, this isn't a simple issue of the "soft and mushy" human side that so frequently gets discounted in company discussions. There are tangible benefits to increasing employee "happiness".
- The time saved in the commute almost always goes to productivity. Studies show that people who don't spend lots of time getting to work actually spend most of that saved time working. If you can knock a half hour off your commute each day, that's an hour we spend actually doing our jobs.
- That number doesn't include the amount of time and energy spent ducking or avoiding the commute. Quick, take a look around the conference table in any meeting at 3:30 on a Friday. How much real work is getting done even though people are present and accounted for?
- As companies rethink the amount of office space needed, they'll generally find that smaller regional or shared office space saves money over the costs of a single large headquarters.
If companies can save money by getting more out of people while spending less on infrastructure that would seem to be a pretty good deal for all concerned. The trick, of course, is to create the policy and strategy consciously instead of just letting it happen by accident.
You can download the full report, "VWork: Measuring the Benefits of Agility at Work" here. Take a look and let us know what you think.
- Telecommuting can save you money--and cost you customers
- Having a team communication plan is great--making it work is something else
- Build a (mostly) failsafe emergency plan for your team