Watch CBS News

Vatican official calls assisted suicide of U.S. woman "reprehensible"

VATICAN CITY -- The Vatican's top bioethics official calls "reprehensible" the suicide of an American woman suffering terminal brain cancer who stated she wanted to die with dignity.

Monsignor Ignacio Carrasco de Paula, the head of the Pontifical Academy for Life, told the ANSA news agency on Tuesday that "dignity is something other than putting an end to one's own life."

Brittany Maynard who ignited aid in dying debate dies 03:37

Brittany Maynard's suicide in Oregon on Saturday, following a public declaration of her motives aimed at sparking political action on the issue, has stirred debate over assisted suicide for the terminally ill.

Carrasco de Paula said "Brittany Maynard's act is in itself reprehensible, but what happened in the consciousness we do not know."

He cautioned that he was not judging individuals "but the gesture in and of itself should be condemned."

Compassion & Choices president calls Maynard an "incredible force" 00:49

Maynard said in an interview with CBS News' Jan Crawford in mid-October that her decision should not be considered suicide.

"No. Cancer is ending my life," not suicide, she said. "I'm choosing to end it a little sooner and in a lot less pain and suffering."

The debate surrounding her decision -- the right to end her suffering on her own terms -- has been anything but quiet.

"As choice issues go, end of life choice -- being able to be intentional about the end of life -- is now facing most of us," said Mickey MacIntyre, chief program officer of Compassion & Choices, the end-of-life nonprofit advocacy organization that partnered with Maynard to help share her story. "It is the next civil and human right. It is here now," he told CBS News.

Brittany Maynard: "Everyone's been bending over backwards to make sure I don't suffer" 01:45

Despite surgery and other treatment, doctors said she had only months to live. Maynard and her husband moved from California to Oregon so that she would be able to use that state's Death With Dignity Act.

Maynard explained why she chose to take her own life.

"I think until anyone has walked a mile in my shoes and knows what they're facing and has felt the -- like, just bone-splitting headaches that I get sometimes, or the seizures, or the inability to speak, or the moments where I'm looking at my husband's face and I can't think of his name."

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.