Questions about his flight history and business dealings doomed the nomination of Daryl Jones, detractors said.
Unable to muster the votes needed to endorse the nomination, supporters moved to report the nomination to the Senate floor without a recommendation of approval or rejection. But even that motion failed, 9-9.
Jones would have been the first black to serve as Air Force secretary.
But witnesses at a nine-hour confirmation hearing last week said Jones, as an Air Force Reserve pilot, almost ran out of fuel on one occasion, flew the wrong way on another and damaged his aircraft by scraping the plane's tail on as many as four occasions, twice on the same day.
Committee Chairman Strom Thurmond of South Carolina, the only one of 10 Republicans on the panel to support Jones, said Jones had been the subject of "rumor campaigns and personal attacks."
But, Thurmond added, "I do not believe that anyone has been able to prove that Mr. Jones knowingly sought to misrepresent his credentials, to defraud the government, or to mislead this committee."
Every one of the committee's 18 members attended the session and spoke on the nomination, many of them saying it presented the toughest challenge since the panel had issued an unfavorable recommendation on the late John Tower to be defense secretary in 1989.
Sen. Carl Levin of Michigan, senior Democrat on the committee and Jones' chief defender, dismissed allegations against Jones as "smoke."
"Where there is smoke, there is sometimes fire. But sometimes when there is smoke, there is only smoke."
But others said they were troubled by Jones' history, including allegations that he was grounded as an unsafe pilot; that he accepted $88 a month in flight pay from the Air Force years after he stopped flying; and that he pressured enlisted men to buy Amway household products from him.
His detractors said he was the wrong man to lead the Air Force at a time when morale is low and the service is having an increasingly difficult time keeping pilots.
"The question is, is this man capable of inspired leadership?" asked Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz. "This is the wrong candidate at the wrong time."
The committee's refusal to even report the nomination to the Senate without a recommendation means it is dead "for all intents and purposes," McCain said.
Democrats did not even attempt to move that the nomination be approved after eight Republicans spoke out against him and two Democrats, Robert Byrd of West Virginia and Charles Robb of Virginia, expressed reservations.
After serving as a pilot in the Air Force, Jones joined the Air Force Reserve, flying out of Homestead Air Force Base nea Miami.
Jones, 43, did not dispute his bad flying record but blamed it on his devotion to public service. He insisted it would not interfere with his ability to oversee the Air Force.
©1998 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed