Watch CBS News

Parking Dispute Over Tire Chalking In Saginaw Could Cover Thousands

DETROIT (AP) — Lawyers who argued that the city of Saginaw violated the U.S. Constitution by chalking tires have successfully turned the case into a class action affecting thousands of parking tickets.

A judge twice dismissed the unusual lawsuit against the city, but it was overturned both times by an appeals court.

U.S. District Judge Thomas Ludington will give Saginaw yet another opportunity to claim that tire chalking was a legal way to enforce parking limits, though he said the city's arguments after two losses don't seem "immediately compelling."

In the same order, Ludington last week approved a request to make the case a class action. It means vehicle owners who were ticketed since 2014 could be compensated unless Saginaw turns things around and wins the litigation. A trial was set for Aug. 30.

The lawsuit began in 2017 when Alison Taylor sued to challenge 14 parking tickets.

Her lawyers, Philip Ellison and Matthew Gronda, argued that Saginaw was violating the Fourth Amendment by marking tires with chalk without a search warrant and then returning to write a ticket if the vehicle was parked too long.

Saginaw said marking a tire was a "minimal intrusion" when weighed against the city's interest in managing parking.

Ludington ruled in the city's favor and dismissed the case. But the 6th U.S. Circuiit Court of Appeals twice has reversed his decisions.

"Tire chalking is not necessary to meet the ordinary needs of law enforcement, let alone the extraordinary," Judge Richard Griffin said in a 3-0 opinion last August.

Tire chalking was used in approximately 4,800 parking tickets, which cost $15 or $30, depending on whether they were paid on time, Ellison said in a court filing Monday.

He's eager to get Ludington's approval to send postcards to people who could be affected.

© 2022 Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.