Watch CBS News

Tale Of The Peterson Tapes

Only days after Laci Peterson disappeared, Scott Peterson told his girlfriend "We could be wonderful together... for the rest of our lives," according to the transcript of a phone conversation played in court Wednesday.

Amber Frey, resuming her testimony at Peterson's murder trial, confirmed that she helped police record calls beginning on New Year's Eve 2002 - the day she discovered that her lover was married and a suspect in the disappearance of his pregnant wife, Laci, on Christmas Eve.

In a New Year's Eve call played on Tuesday and again on a Jan. 1 call played Wednesday, Peterson pretended to be phoning from Paris.

Calling her "sweetie," Peterson lied that he was standing near the Eiffel Tower and hearing fireworks in the middle of a huge New Year's crowd. In their next call, on Jan. 1, she asked if he had any New Year's resolutions, and he said he couldn't come up with any.

"So what, do you want to be together with me?," Frey asked him in the call.

"Well, I mean, obviously ... I think that we, you know, would be wonderful together," Peterson responds. "You know, in my mind we could be wonderful together and I could ... I could care for you in any and every way. For the rest of our lives."

Days later, still pretending to be in Paris, Peterson bantered with Frey, telling her his favorite movie is the 1980 horror thriller "The Shining," in which Jack Nicholson plays a man who tries to kill his wife.

Gloria Allred, Frey's attorney, said the exchange about "The Shining" was the "bombshell" of Wednesday's developments.

"That, frankly, gives me more chills than when I saw the movie," Allred said after the hearing.

Frey, the government's star witness, testified Tuesday that Peterson did not wear a wedding ring and she didn't know he was married when they met on Nov. 20, 2002. He poured champagne in his hotel room, putting a strawberry in her glass, and they had sex later that night. The next morning, he left her with his cell number, not his home number.

On her second date with Peterson, he carried her 22-month-old daughter as they went hiking. Later that day, he gave the girl a children's book. Then, he cooked seafood lasagna with wine before they had sex again.

"He made the comment that there would be many more corks... many more bottles to share," Frey testified.

The next day, Dec. 3, she gave Peterson a car seat and the key to her house, and asked him to pick up her daughter at day care.

"He said he would be honored," recalled Frey, who returned home to find him warming up the previous night's dinner. Then all three went out to buy a Christmas tree, and after decorating it, Frey and Peterson had sex for a third time.

"I'd give her an A-plus," Allred told CBS News. "It was a high pressure, stressful situation. I think she came across as extremely credible, very, very specific in her recollection and in the detail that she provided. She was very cautious in her answers. If she didn't know, she indicated that she didn't know. Where she did know, she was very specific."

Before Frey takes the stand again, the judge, prosecution and defense are expected to conduct a hearing about newly discovered evidence that lawyers, under a gag order, have not been able to reveal.

Prosecutors have spent much of their case trying to establish that Peterson's affair with the massage therapist, and hopes for financial gain, were his motives for killing Laci Peterson.

The testimony about the intensity of their early relationship appeared to counter one aspect of Peterson's defense - his lawyers have scoffed at the idea that a man would murder his pregnant wife to be with a single mother he had only just met.

But Frey said that from the beginning, Peterson seemed to want a future with her. While trimming the Christmas tree, she said he denied that he was ever "close to having children" with anyone else.

The next time they saw each other was Dec. 9, Frey testified, when he told her he had lied about never being married.

Then, she said, he began to cry and told her "he had lost his wife."

"He said this would be the first holidays he would be spending without her," she said.

At the time, Frey said she understood Peterson to mean that his wife was dead. "I thanked him for sharing that with me," she said, adding that she asked him if he still wanted to have a serious relationship with her. "He said absolutely," she said.

Later, about two weeks before Laci's disappearance, they had sex again, but this time it was unprotected - prompting a conversation about their future together, Frey testified.

She said Peterson said he did not want to conceive any children, but would care for her daughter. "He would consider her his own," she recalled him saying.

Peterson also suggested that he would consider getting a vasectomy - an offer she said she found "disturbing" given his relatively young age.

Prosecutors also showed jurors a series of holiday pictures showing Frey and Peterson embracing and smiling. One showed Peterson grinning in a Santa Claus hat.

Frey has not been cross-examined - an opportunity the defense likely won't get for at least another day.

Prosecutors appear to be trying to show that Peterson began hatching the murder plot a day later. Evidence shows he searched for used boats on Dec. 7-8, as well as numerous Web sites for fishing information, currents in San Francisco Bay and details on boat ramps in the area.

Prosecutors allege Peterson killed his wife in their Modesto home on or around Dec. 24, 2002, then drove to the bay and dumped her weighted body from a small boat he had purchased just weeks earlier. The badly decomposed remains of Laci Peterson and the couple's fetus washed ashore in April 2003, not far from where Peterson said he launched a solo fishing trip the day she vanished.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.