Watch CBS News

Atlanta police solve girl's 1995 killing that was featured on "America's Most Wanted"

Tracing family trees to catch killers
Tracing family trees to catch killers 01:56

A homicide has been solved more than a quarter-century after 14-year-old Nacole Smith was raped and murdered while on her way to school, Atlanta police announced Tuesday. Detectives used DNA testing and genealogy tools to finally identify a suspect, who is now dead, police said at a news conference.

  Nacole Smith  WGCL-TV

In 1995, Smith was walking to school in southwest Atlanta but turned back around after forgetting a school assignment at home, CBS affiliate WGCL reported. She cut through the nearby wooded area, where police say she was beaten, raped and shot to death.

CSI Atlanta had kept Smith's case in the spotlight and worked with a forensic artist to create an updated sketch of the killer in 2019, WGCL reported.

In 2002, former Atlanta police detective Vince Velazquez dug into the case. He got a break in 2004 when evidence from an attack on a young girl in nearby East Point, Georgia, matched evidence in the Atlanta killing. But it took police years to identify a suspect.

Police worked to publicize the case, which got attention from the TV show "America's Most Wanted," Velazquez recalled Tuesday.

When Velazquez retired from the police department in 2017, Detective Scott Demeester took over much of the work. Using genealogy records, Demeester worked to develop a person of interest and obtained a sample of his DNA.

Shortly after Christmas, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation's forensic lab was able to match the suspect's DNA to evidence in the case.

The man police believe killed the teenager died in August 2021 after being in hospice care with liver and kidney failure, police said. They did not name the suspect during Tuesday's news conference, saying they wanted the focus to be on the girl and her family.

"I'll live with this pain for the rest of my life," said her mother, Acqunellia Smith. "Just taking one day at a time."

1995 Cold Case Homicide Update

APD provides an update on the 1995 Cold Case for 14-Year Nacole Smith.

Posted by City of Atlanta Police Department on Tuesday, January 4, 2022
View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.