Watch CBS News

Millions Of Homes Under-Insured

As many Floridians know, having good insurance for your home is very important.

Unfortunately, not many Americans are adequately protected, says The Early Show financial adviser Ray Martin. He says that if you consider your home your biggest investment, you need to set aside a few minutes to take a hard look at your current coverage, so if a terrible disaster strikes, you are prepared.

Finding out that you're not covered after a disaster has struck won't help you, warns Martin.

Many people are not adequately covered, and part of the problem has been created by the insurance industry, according to some experts. Recently, there have been dramatic changes in the way property insurance has been sold.

In America, 64 percent of homes are under-insured by an average of 27 percent, according to Marshall & Swift/Boeckh, publisher of the Residential Cost Handbook and a supplier of local building cost information programs to the property and casualty insurance industry. Robert Hartwig, chief economist for the Insurance Information Institute, agrees that the under-insurance problem exists all across the U.S.

The under-insurance problem is painfully exposed when homeowners face a total and unexpected loss, like many homeowners in California and in Florida. Of the more than 3,700 homeowners who suffered a total loss due to the California wildfires, many are finding out that the money their insurance is providing is falling far short of what they need to rebuild the homes they lost. (That's according to John Garamendi, the California Insurance Commissioner.)

In an industry that prides itself on customer service and providing security to its customers, it's difficult to believe that property insurance companies would knowingly allow their customers to under-insure their homes. After all, buying the right amount and right type of insurance means larger insurance policy premiums and profits for the insurers. Add to that the fact that among the millions of insurance claims totaling approximately $26 billion a year, fewer than two percent are for the total loss of a house.

So why is this happening? Insurance companies are quick to point out that homeowners all too often do not step up to the responsibility of buying adequate coverage for their homes. When homeowners remodel and improve their homes, they often forget to follow through with a call to their insurance agent to update their coverage.

Another contributor is the surging price of lumber, steel and other building materials, and the rising costs due to new building codes and escalating labor costs.

Consumer groups such as the Consumer Federation of America, however, paint a much different picture.

They state that homeowners depend on their insurance agents to properly assess their homes' replacement value and to sell them the right type and amount of coverage. They say that many agents today lack the training to properly assess the value of the homes they insure and often rely on over-the-phone interviews and computer program estimates to provide quick quotes to close a sale in the competitive world of selling homeowners insurance.

The result is that consumers buy cheaply priced coverage that they falsely believe will replace their home in the event of a full loss.

Consumer groups also hold that insurance companies and their agents often aim low in valuing homes. The goal, they say, is to keep premiums down in order to keep consumers from going to competitors, and sometimes even a few dollars can make a difference.

In a move to cut costs from claims, insurance companies began in the late 1990s to phase out coverage that guaranteed the replacement of a destroyed home, regardless of the expense to the insurer. Every homeowner needs to know that the good old-fashioned "guaranteed replacement coverage" that provided homeowners peace of mind that their home would be replaced regardless of the rebuilding costs is quickly becoming a thing of the past.

So now, most homeowners policies sold today are called "extended replacement coverage" or "specified additional amount of insurance" which only provides coverage up to the stated dwelling limits specified in the policy plus an additional amount of up to 20 to 30 percent - and not a penny more. This is a big difference. For example if your policy's statement says you're covered for $100,000, the new "extended replacement coverage" will pay that amount plus typically 20 to 30 percent and no more.

And if you have an existing policy with "guaranteed replacement coverage," expect a notice from your insurance company upon the policy anniversary that your current coverage will replaced with this new and more limited form of coverage. People might look at this new policy, see the word "replacement," and think that they are covered, but they won't get their home "replaced" as they would have under the old "guaranteed replacement coverage." This development places more responsibility on homeowners to ensure that they have adequate coverage for their homes replacement value.

Some insurance companies say they have been forced to limit replacement coverage because homeowners have been slow to increase their coverage limits as home values appreciated and rebuilding costs have surged. But some insurance company representatives fear that as this new coverage is rolled out to existing policy holders, homeowners will do nothing, and as a result will be underinsured and ignorant about it.

To protect against underinsuring their home, homeowners should insist on a through analysis of their homes' replacement value, including an inventory of the number of rooms and bathrooms, and specification of the quality level of the existing construction and any special features. Many insurance companies are now using Marshall & Swifts residential component technology home valuation program to calculate home replacement value, and suggesting this as the proper coverage limits to set in your policy. If this valuation is incomplete, and the homeowner does not buy enough coverage, the homeowner will bear the consequence. Ideally, the insurance agent should also visit the home to assess its replacement value and take into account the specific risks to the home, local market conditions, and current building codes that would contribute to the costs of replacing the home.

Homeowners also need to know the difference between the HO-3 and HO-5 forms of homeowner's coverage. These are the two most common policies offered. While both forms of coverage insure damages caused by all risks to a home's physical structure, the fundamental difference is that only the HO-5 policies fully cover damages and loss of the home's contents due to all risks. Having a guarantee that your personal belongings will be covered no matter what kind of disaster strikes is particularly important if you have a larger home, many furnishings, expensive jewelry, art, or a home office.

Homeowners with outdated policies may find that their current policy "dwelling limits" only insures a percentage of their homes current replacement value. It is important to note that as long as your "dwelling limits" in your policy are 80 percent of more of the replacement cost of the dwelling, you are fully covered for a partial loss. But if you have a full loss of your home, and you do not have the full amount of the dwelling replacement value covered, you will only be paid for part of the replacement costs - and chances are this gap in coverage will amount to a lot of money.

Also, many homeowners have upgraded their homes and these improvements increase the home's replacement value. Insurance limits should be increased accordingly. Finally, not only have home values gone up, the price of materials and labor has also increased. Homes lost in disaster areas typically have to be rebuilt to conform to new building codes, to protect against wind damage or earthquakes for example, adding to the costs to rebuild the home.

Many insurance companies offer a feature that automatically increases the value for which the home is insured each year. Ask your insurance company about this coverage escalator. The cost of this rider and coverage increase is then automatically built into your premium each year.

If the home is located in a flood plane, no policy will cover flood damage. The federal government provides flood insurance through the Federal Emergency Management Agency, and claims are often serviced by your insurance company. Some owners of high-risk properties may have to resort to obtaining coverage through Fair Access to Insurance Requirements, or FAIR Plans, which are state mandated insurer organizations that cover high-risk properties in 36 states.

One thing most homeowner's policies do cover is "loss of use." Many Florida residents have been forced to evacuate their homes as the recent hurricanes descended their area. What these homeowners need to know is that their costs to stay in a hotel and other related living costs are generally covered at an amount that is typically about 30 percent of the overall policy dwelling coverage. So for instance, if your home is insured for $200,000, you may be entitled for up to $60,000 in reimbursement for your expenses associated with your loss of use.

Keep in mind that if you do want to increase the amount of coverage on your home, you can't do so when the peril is upon you. Insurance companies generally place a moratorium on coverage changes in areas in the path of a storm, typically several days before the expected peril is forecast to strike.

Finally, remember to take photos or video of your belongings, whether it's the drapes or your grandmother's jewelry. This will be helpful if there has been some damage to your home. Take digital photos and send them to another family member or save them online. Taking photos and putting them in a firebox is old-fashioned, but doing this once a year is helpful. And if you've done updates to your home, don't forget to take photos of your fancy fixtures or appliances. It can be helpful in the long run.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.