New research suggests that children who attend Montessori schools may have an edge over other children in terms of both academic and social development.
But an early education researcher who spoke to WebMD says the study was far too small to be conclusive.
Researchers tested 30 5-year-olds and 29 12-year-olds attending a public inner-city Montessori school in Milwaukee, Wis. They also tested a similar number of 5- and 12-year-olds who attended non-Montessori Milwaukee schools.
The 5-year-old Montessori students were found to have better reading and math skills than their peers who attended traditional schools and they scored higher on tests measuring social development, researchers reported.
The 12-year-old Montessori and non-Montessori students had similar reading and math scores, but the Montessori children tended to score higher on tests measuring social and behavioral development, researcher Angeline Lillard, Ph.D., tells WebMD.
The study is published in the Sept. 29 issue of the journal Science.
Lillard is a professor of psychology at the University of Virginia at Charlottesville, who acknowledges being a proponent of the teaching method. She published the book Montessori: The Science Behind the Genius last year.
No Tests, No Grades
Roughly 300 public schools in the U.S. follow the teaching principles developed almost 100 years ago by Italian physician and educator Maria Montessori.
This method stresses small group instruction that allows children to choose their own developmentally appropriate activities and learn at their own pace. There is no testing and no grading.
Montessori is primarily used in preschool and early education settings, but there are also Montessori middle schools and high schools.
Concerns about the program tend to focus on the lack of testing and grading of school-aged children, Lillard says.
"Parents worry that their children won't be able to compete if they aren't exposed early to competitiveness in school," she says.
Lillard says she and co-researcher Nichole Else-Quest, Ph.D., conducted the study to address these concerns. And they designed their study to address another often expressed belief about the teaching method — that it is the Montessori parent and not the Montessori instruction that makes the difference.
"The thinking is that parents who want their kids to go to Montessori schools might be more motivated and more organized and orderly at home," she says. "And we know that organization and order at home leads to better child outcomes."
The researchers chose the subjects in their study from a pool of children who had entered the lottery to go to the Milwaukee Montessori schools.
All the children in the study came from families with similar income levels, averaging $20,000 to $50,000 per year.
More Information Needed
Debra Ackerman, Ph.D., of the privately funded National Institute for Early Education Research (NIEER), tells WebMD that no single teaching method or curriculum, including Montessori, has been proven to be the best approach for teaching young children.
The latest study, she says, was not only too small to allow generalization to all public school settings, but the two-page report in Science left out much of the methodology needed to assess the accuracy of the results.
"It is impossible to judge the merit of this study, based on what was published," she says.
There are many widely differing approaches to early education, Ackerman says, and the large- scale studies needed to better understand which methods work best are just starting to be done.
It is clear, she adds, that young children learn best when they are taught in smaller classrooms with student-teacher ratios of no more than one to 10. And paying enough to recruit high-quality teachers with college degrees in early education also makes a difference.
"We know that high-quality programs can't be done on the cheap," she says.
SOURCES: Lillard, A. Science, Sept. 29, 2006; vol 313: pp 1893-1894. Angeline Lillard, Ph.D., professor of psychology, University of Virginia at Charlottesville. Debra J. Ackerman, Ph.D., assistant research professor, National Institute for Early Education Research.
By Salynn Boyles
Reviewed by Louise Chang, M.D.
© 2006, WebMD Inc. All rights reserved