Watch CBS News

Clinton Inks China Trade Bill

Completing a free trade push supported by business groups but opposed by environmentalists and unions, President Clinton Tuesday signed into law a bill normalizing trade relations with China.

The law, passed by the House by a 237-197 margin in May and the Senate by a vote of 83-15 in September, changes U.S. trade law to establish permanent normal trade relations with Beijing, eliminating Congress' annual review of China's trading status.

The bill allows China to move one step closer to joining the World Trade Organization and is part of a U.S.-China trade agreement that includes lower tariffs on U.S. goods sold there.

It includes so-called "anti-dumping" measures designed to prevent an influx of inexpensive Chinese goods into the United States that might hurt American industries making the same goods, and makes it American policy to encourage trade that improves human rights and environmental protection in China.

The Law and Its Makers

Read the U.S.-China Relations Act of 2000.

See how your senator voted on the bill.

Find out how your representative voted on the bill.

It also sets up a task force for enforcing a ban on importing goods made with prison labor in China and gives support to Taiwan's efforts to enter the WTO.

However, it does not make U.S.-China trade relations contingent on China improving its human rights record, which includes accusations it jails dissidents and persecutes religious groups. The lack of any "teeth" is why environmentalists, human rights and religious groups and many unions opposed the bill.

Since the 1989 crackdown on the Tiananmen democracy movement, congressional critics of China have made concerted, if unsuccessful, efforts every year to rescind normal trade status because of Beijing's human rights and weapons proliferation abuses.

Opponents questioned the wisdom of giving up trade as a policy tool for forcing China toward more responsible behavior.

"I believe that we will deply regret this stampede to pass this legislation and the way in which we have taken all the human rights, religious freedom, right to organize—all of those concerns and we just put them in parentheses, put them in brackets, as if they don't exist," said Sen. Paul Wellstone, D-Minn., during the Senate debate.

The Clinton administration's support for the China trade bill opened a rift between unions and Vice President Al Gore's campaign for president—even leading the United Auto Workers, traditionally steadfast supporters of the Democratic ticket, to consider endorsing Green Party presidential candidate Ralph Nader.

Pact Particulars
The China trade bill:

  • Normalizes trade relations with China, ending the annual congressional review of China's Most Favored Nation status.
  • Allows new duties and restrictions on Chinese imports that "threaten to cause market disruption to the U.S. producers of a like or directly competitive product."
  • Makes it U.S. policy to expand and increase trade with China in a way that improves labor and environmental conditions and encourages China to grant its workers human rights.
  • Establishes a commission to monitor China's compliance with the trade pact and a task force to monitor and enforce the ban on importing products made with prison labor.
  • States that the U.S. should ask the WTO to monitor China's performance annually as part of China's admission to the organization.
  • Authorizes funding for a training program to be set up in China on the rule of law in business transactions.
  • Directs the U.S. Trade Representative to ask the WTO to consider admitting Taiwan once it admits China.
  • (Source: Congressional Research Service)

    The Clinton White House's earlier support for the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) also irked organized labor.

    The UAW ultimately endorsed Gore, but cited continuing differences on trade.

    The legislation was backed by a powerful coalition of business and farm groups, was praised by U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky, who said it was "as important as any on China since 1972, with the opening of China" by President Nixon.

    "This historic legislation will be remembered as the key that opened the door for America to sell ts products and services to the world's largest emerging marketplace," said Robert Burt, chairman of The Business Roundtable, an association of CEOs.

    The bill is an outgrowth of a U.S.-China agreement last fall under which China, as a condition for entering the World Trade Organization, made major concessions in reducing tariffs and opening its markets.

    China is expected to join the WTO later this year or early next year, and the United States, in order to enjoy the benefits of China's commitment to WTO free market rules, must grant permanent trade status.

    With WTO entry, China's tariffs on U.S. made manufactured goods would fall from an overall average of 25 percent to 9 percent by 2005. Duties on America's primary food products would drop from 31 percent to 14 percent.

    China would be required to open its financial and service industries to American companies, allow greater outside ownership in its telecommunications industry and allow Americans full distribution rights within the country.

    Agriculture exports alone could grow by some $2 billion a year, helping reduce China's current $68 billion trade surplus with the United States.

    The House debate over the passage of the bill was contentious.

    But the only real suspense during two weeks of Senate debate was whether opponents could be prevented from attaching crippling amendments on subjects ranging from proliferation to human rights abuses. None were passed.

    © 2000 CBS Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report

    View CBS News In
    CBS News App Open
    Chrome Safari Continue
    Be the first to know
    Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.