Watch CBS News

As Xi Jinping tightens his grip on China, fear chills free speech in Hong Kong

Hong Kong crackdown on freedom of speech
Chinese President Xi Jinping has cracked down on dissent within Hong Kong and other regions 03:01

Hong Kong — President Xi Jinping further tightened his grip on power in China this week. After a decade in power, he is expected to be anointed by the Communist Party he leads for another term. His assertive approach at home and abroad has led to increasingly tense relations with neighboring island Taiwan, and a dramatic tightening of control over Hong Kong.

Hong Kong was a British territory for more than a century, allowing it to develop an open civil society and vibrant free press. But China assumed control of the territory in 1997 and under Xi Jinping the Communist Party has cracked down hard on dissent. A key element of that crackdown has been a slow but concerted stifling of freedom of speech.

One high profile case has highlighted China's intolerance of criticism.

In the summer of 2021, Hong Kong national security police arrested five young speech therapists for their part in an alleged "conspiracy to distribute seditious materials." 

Hong Kong Free Speech
A hooded suspect is accompanied by police officers in Hong Kong, July 22, 2021. A Hong Kong court sentenced five speech therapists to nearly two years in prison on September 10, 2022 for their role in the publication of children's books that the judge ruled were seditious. Vincent Yu/AP

Their crime: Publishing three children's books about a village full of sheep. The books were thinly disguised political allegories about China's takeover of Hong Kong.

District Court Judge Kwok Wai-Kin ruled that some of the material in the books had "a seditious intent," and brought "hatred against the government." 

Hongkongers used to enjoy some of the liveliest, freest speech in the world, until China took over in 1997. In 2020, in reaction to a strong pro-democracy movement, China's central government imposed a vague new national security law, which, in effect, can be used to silence any criticism of Beijing's governance and policies.

It's working.

Under intense pressure from Beijing, Hong Kong's government has shut down independent news outlets. The respected Apple Daily newspaper was not only forced to close but its senior staff were sent to jail. This summer, when Hong Kong's huge, internationally renowned book fair opened, there were no books on display with any kind of political edge.

Hong Kong's lone pro-democracy newspaper shuts down after pressure from China 02:01

"They don't want journalism to be a check on government," Keith Richburg, head of journalism at Hong Kong University, told CBS News. "They don't want anyone to be a check on government."

For anyone who dares to cross the new red lines, "the penalties can range up to life in prison," said Richburg, who spent decades writing for the Washington Post. "No possibility of parole — you can't really defend yourself against these things."

The publishers of the children's books did try to defend themselves. Their lawyers argued the books would help kids understand systemic injustice.

Hong Kong
Li Kwai-wah, left, senior superintendent of Police National Security Department speaks in front of a screen showing evidence including the contents of three children's books on stories that revolve around a village of sheep which has to deal with wolves from a different village, before a press conference in Hong Kong, July 22, 2021. Vincent Yu/AP

Authorities, however, determined that the sheep characters were not-so-thinly-disguised pro-democracy Hongkongers, and the predatory wolves — Chinese authorities. That crossed the red line. Each of five the publishers was sentenced to just over a year and a half in jail.

"I wouldn't say press freedom is dead entirely" in Hong Kong, Richburg said, noting that there are a couple major newspapers operating in the region "that are still trying to show some balance."

Veteran Hong Kong pro-democracy politician Emily Lau told CBS News she believed freedom of speech in Hong Kong, "may be in intensive care or something, and it's very sad. But we still have journalists operating. We have TV stations, newspapers and so on. But some journalists, as you probably know, are in prison and many have gone abroad, and many of the news organizations are very careful about the stories that they're allowed to be published."

Xi Jinping expected to affirm grip on power at 20th China Communist Party congress 05:51

Richburg also noted "a lot more self-censorship, because people don't know where the new red lines are under this national security law."

He sees that as a tactic by Beijing, not an oversight.

"I think they deliberately like it vague," Richburg said. "Every time the media has asked for clarification on some of these things, they won't tell you. They basically say, you know, 'We will know you've crossed it once you've crossed it.' And I think that keeps everybody on their toes."

"The boundaries are very vague," agreed Lau. "You just don't know when you step on the red line, and then you could be arrested and could be put in jail, maybe for a year or two years, with no trial. So, it is very, very distressing."

The image, widely published, of the speech therapists, hooded and handcuffed is a warning. And it's working.  

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.