Watch CBS News

Chicago police chief fired amid Laquan McDonald fallout

Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel has dismissed police superintendent Garry McCarthy from the force, as gang violence and distrust in the police have both risen
Chicago's top cop dropped 02:44

CHICAGO - Chicago Police Superintendent Garry McCarthy has been fired, the mayor of Chicago announced Tuesday.

McCarthy has come under fire after video was released of teen Laquan McDonald being shot more than a dozen times by a white police officer.

Legal Analysis of Chicago, Baltimore cop shooting trials 07:40

"Public trust in the department has been eroded," Mayor Rahm Emmanuel said in announcing the firing.

Emanuel announced the firing of McCarthy only days after the top Chicago cop insisted to reporters that the mayor had his "back."

Protesters have been calling for McCarthy's dismissal for days in response to the handling of the McDonald shooting. The black 17-year-old was shot 16 times by a white police officer in October 2014.

The city released police dashcam video of the shooting only after a judge ordered it to be made public. Its release last week set off several days of largely peaceful protests. Officer Jason Van Dyke has been charged with first-degree murder.

The audio-free video shows McDonald walking down the middle of a four-lane street. He appears to veer away from two officers as they emerge from a vehicle, drawing their guns.

Van Dyke opens fire from close range and continues firing after McDonald crumples to the ground. Police have said McDonald was carrying a knife, and an autopsy revealed that he had PCP, a hallucinogenic drug, in his system.

Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez has said the 3-inch blade recovered from the scene had been folded into the handle.

Defense attorney Dan Herbert says his client feared for his life, acted lawfully and that the video does not tell the whole story.

Van Dyke was released from jail Monday after paying the $150,000 required of his $1.5 million bail.

Some Cook County and Chicago leaders say they're not satisfied with McCarthy's disimissal.

Cook County Commissioner Richard Boykin said a federal investigation is needed and the firing is a "necessary but insufficient first step."

Alderman Carlos Ramirez-Rosa also called for an independent investigation. Service Employees International Union Healthcare Illinois Vice President Greg Kelley called for Emanuel and Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez, who brought charges against Jason Van Dyke last week, to resign.

But U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin said that police and the community need to "build a relationship based on mutual trust and respect."

The Chicago Teachers Union said it supported Emanuel's move.

Prior to his arrival in Chicago as police chief in 2011, McCarthy was police director in Newark, New Jersey, after rising through the ranks of New York City's police department.

In an interview with CBS Chicago, McCarthy said recently he was aware the whole situation -- from the shooting itself to the more than year-long delay in releasing the video of the shooting -- would be "trouble."

He said he viewed the dash-cam video of the fatal shooting within a couple of days of McDonald's death.

"It's obviously a terrible video, and obviously a terrible tragedy. When I learned the circumstances of Mr. McDonald's life -- that he was a ward of the state at the time -- and the troubles that he had had growing up, I thought that the whole thing was a tragedy," McCarthy said.

As for his officer, McCarthy said, "I knew that it was problematic for the officer because it's going to be hard to articulate why you fired so many rounds."

Two more views released of Chicago fatal police shooting 02:04

The superintendent says he immediately stripped Van Dyke of his police powers. Legally, McCarthy said, that's all he could do.

"I couldn't fire him. I couldn't put him in a 'no pay' status. I couldn't discipline him. That's the law," he said. "It was not the Chicago Police Department investigating this incident."

The Independent Police Review Authority was investigating the incident at the beginning, which is the normal protocol when an officer shoots a suspect. IPRA alerted federal and state investigators after reviewing the dash-cam video.

In addition to the criticism of the the timing of the video's released, there have been accusations of police tampering in the case. A manager for the Burger King near where McDonald was shot claims Chicago police officers erased footage of the shooting.

Mayor Emanuel on Tuesday also announced the creation of the Task Force on Police Accountability. It will review oversight and training that is currently in place for Chicago's police officers.

The family of another man fatally shot by Chicago police in 2014 is pressing city officials to release squad car video of the shooting. Chicago police have said 25-year-old Ronald Johnson of Chicago was fatally shot by an officer on Oct. 12, 2014. At the time, authorities said he was armed and pointed a gun at police.

Johnson's mother, Dorothy Holmes, said Tuesday that wasn't the case and he was running away from police.

The family of Johnson has repeated their demand that the city release dashboard camera video of the shooting, a week after authorities released video of the shooting death of McDonald.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.