Bonnaroo Had It All
Destination festivals are a universe unto their own where the real world is left in the parking lot. But at this year's Bonnaroo Music & Arts Festival, the outside world and its problems - politics, high gas prices - were always lurking just offstage, and sometimes were front and center.
"There's a time and place for this kind of talk, right?" Eddie Vedder said to the tens of thousands watching Pearl Jam perform their scintillating headlining set Saturday. "It is welded into the Constitution that people have not only the right, but the responsibility to make change. It can't get any worse. We're right here in the middle of America. We can change the whole world. Do you agree that this is the time and place for this kind of talk?"
Cheering loudly, most in the crowd agreed.
Vedder spoke repeatedly about the need for change and about the Iraq War, occasionally reprimanding himself for not staying positive. Pearl Jam's performance was undoubtedly a high point for this year's Bonnaroo, highlighted by a sing-along version of "Better Man" during which the vast audience held lighters aloft and a near-full moon shone from behind the stage.
Photos: Bonnaroo 2008
The elements can often be a major factor at Bonnaroo - held annually on a 700-acre site south of Nashville - but temperatures were bearable. Hard rain fell for a time late Friday night, making My Morning Jacket's exuberant three-hour midnight concert a memorably soaked one. Sunday, the final day of the four-day fest, was beautifully clear and was further warmed by Alison Krauss and Robert Plant, who exuded contentment in the unlikely (and hugely popular) late chapter in his career.
On the same stage Friday night, Chris Rock played to one of the largest rooms a comedian will ever work. As many as 60,000 of the estimated 80,000 in attendance watched him command the crowd with a relentless pace and sharp observations.
Rock, of course, had barbs for the presumed presidential nominees, John McCain and Barack Obama - who he said has a name so black-sounding that he could be "the bass player for the Commodores."
The comedian wondered how gas prices could be so high considering the Iraq war: "Let me tell you something. If I invade IHOP, pancakes are going to be cheaper in my house."
Rock also called himself an "antidepressant" and other acts similarly hoped to alleviate worries.
"Do you feel good?" Metallica lead singer James Hetfield asked the crowd. "Metallica is here to make you feel better."
Metallica performed a unique double bill following Rock, who introduced the heavy metal band. Metallica's testosterone-fueled set was flawless, but the band had to work to win over the crowd, which at Bonnaroo has traditionally been on the hippie side. When Hetfield asked who was attending their first Metallica concert, the crowd was a sea of raised hands.
The festival's biggest glitch was the delayed concert by Kanye West. The singer's performance came almost two hours late, beginning at 4:25 a.m. and angering the crowd who booed and pelted the empty stage with glow sticks. The delay was due to problems in setting up West's elaborate stage for his galactic concept concert.
Some at the festival saw a greater willingness to be politically involved in this election year. Disco Biscuits bassist Marc Brownstein, who co-founded the nonprofit Headcount to register votes at music festivals and concerts, said he saw a change.
"The fans are significantly more receptive to the idea of stopping and taking the time to talk about voter registration right now," said Brownstein, speaking on his band's tour bus before playing a late set Friday night. "I think it's changing and it's changing rapidly because we're able to use the platform of music to get people thinking about things outside of music."
Bonnaroo, which was created in 2002 by Superfly Productions and AC Entertainment as then a primarily jam band event, is welcoming of organizations like Headcount and the numerous environmental groups with booths on festival grounds. But it's also laid out like a whimsical Dr. Seuss playland, full of quirky sculptures and activities. In the makeshift village called "Center Roo," visitors could go for a mechanical bull ride or get a new hairdo at a salon.
The stages are named apparently by an Abbott and Costello fan. "What Stage" is the main stage, followed by "Which Stage," "This Tent," "That Tent" and "The Other Tent."
It's perhaps not an environment given to political discourse, but many acts voiced opinions either directly or in song. The acclaimed political punk band Against Me! played their angst-ridden "From Her Lips to God's Ears (The Energizer)" on which singer Tom Gabel sings, "Condoleeza, do you get the ... joke?" Comedian Zach Galifianakis concluded his otherwise absurdist performance by simply holding up a sign that said, "Obama `08."
But any narrative about a festival like Bonnaroo is sure to be incomplete. Arguably the country's biggest festival, Bonnaroo boasts over 150 acts, including many comedians. There were myriad sights and sounds to experience beginning with the Thursday night performance by the hip new Afro pop-influenced Vampire Weekend and concluding Sunday with the jamming Widespread Panic.
The 82-year-old B.B. King wowed with the vigor of his performance despite being seated throughout. Sharon Jones and the Dap-Kings upheld their reputation as a terrific live act with their funky soul revival, (said Jones: "I wear this dress so I can shake it"). Sigur Ros's famed live show lacked something without their usual light display, but the Icelandic band's new material drew great applause (and a few ecstatic tears) in the wee hours of Saturday night.
And that still leaves out excellent sets from, among many others, Rilo Kiley, the Swell Season, Death Cab for Cutie, Jack Johnson, Jose Gonzalez, the Raconteurs and M.I.A., who called it her "last show" after she recently abruptly canceled an upcoming European tour due to exhaustion.
On the whole, it was Robert Plant who said it best when he sang: "Any song that you want to sing, any song will do/ Any song that you want to sing, happy or blue."