Watch CBS News

Fantasy Baseball Preview: Shortstop

By Tony Meale

In our Fantasy Baseball Preview, CBS Local Sports breaks down the top players at each position for your fantasy baseball draft.

1B | 2B | SS | 3B | OF | SP | C | RP | Sleepers/Busts

Position Overview

Shortstop might be the most Jekyll-and-Hyde position in all of fantasy – regardless of sport. Take a look at this list, and you’ll probably find a half dozen names that a large contingent of fantasy players love and a large contingent that fantasy players hate.

Why? Inconsistency, injury history, unfulfilled promise and differing takes on whether or not “this will finally be the year.”

Here’s a look at top fantasy shortstops heading into 2014 – in the order in which I would draft them.

The Top 12

1) Hanley Ramirez, Los Angeles Dodgers

Wanna hear something crazy? Last year, Hanley Ramirez finished third among shortstops in home runs (20), tenth in RBIs (57) and in the top 15 in runs (62) and steals (10) – despite playing just 86 games (in other words, just more than half a season). This year, Ramirez projects to hit third in the Dodgers order – just behind Yasiel Puig and Carl Crawford and just ahead of Adrian Gonzalez and Matt Kemp. This is a first-round player.

Projection: .310 average, 26 home runs, 92 RBIs, 92 runs, 15 steals

2) Troy Tulowitzki, Colorado Rockies

By now, you know the book on Tulowitzki: He’s immensely talented yet immensely injury-prone. He has 30-homer, 100-RBI potential, but he’s missed 282 games over the last six seasons. Few players in fantasy offer higher risk; even fewer offer higher reward.

Projection: .302 average, 25 home runs, 88 RBIs, 84 runs, 3 steals

3) Ian Desmond, Washington Nationals

Desmond has delivered back-to-back 20/20 seasons. What more do you need to know?

Projection: .277 average, 21 home runs, 82 RBIs, 77 runs, 21 steals

Rahman, Hobibur
Hobibur Rahman (credit: Canton Public Safety Department)

4) Ben Zobrist, Tampa Bay Rays

Ranked sixth among second basemen, Zobrist is a safe, durable option who helps in all categories. If fantasy is about minimizing risk – and it is – you could do a lot worse than the versatile Zobrist, even as he turns 33 this May.

Projection: .281 average, 17 home runs, 79 RBIs, 90 runs, 15 steals

Buy MLB tickets for your favorite team.

5) Elvis Andrus, Texas Rangers

Few shortstops offer much by way of home runs and RBIs, so ignore what Andrus doesn’t do and focus instead on what he does do – and that’s steal bases and score runs. He’ll also hit for a respectable average, especially batting between offseason acquisitions Shin-Soo Choo and Prince Fielder.

Projection: .278 average, 6 home runs, 60 RBIs, 97 runs, 40 steals

6) Starlin Castro, Chicago Cubs

Castro is coming off a disappointing season in which he hit just .245 and stole just nine bases – both career lows – but there’s still a lot to like here. Castro, 24, is a career .283 hitter with 15-homer and 25-steal potential. He’s also missed just one game in the last two years.

Projection: .284 average, 14 home runs, 65 RBIs, 90 runs, 20 steals

MINNEAPOLIS, MN - SEPTEMBER 8:  Jose Reyes #7 of the Toronto Blue Jays follows through on an RBI single in the 8th inning against the Minnesota Twins during their baseball game on September 8, 2013 at Target Field in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Jose Reyes (Photo Credit: Andy Clayton-King/Getty Images)

7) Jose Reyes, Toronto Blue Jays

Reyes, whose value is predicated on speed, turns 31 this June and is coming off an ankle injury that limited him to 93 games last season. Reyes was remarkably durable from 2005-09 – playing in 153+ games each year. But he’s missed at least 29 games in four of the last five seasons, during which he’s scored more than 90 runs just once. While many consider Reyes a top-three or top-four option at the position, that’s far too much risk for my blood – especially for a two-trick pony.

Projection: .292 average, 10 home runs, 45 RBIs, 77 runs runs, 19 steals

8) Jean Segura, Milwaukee Brewers

Which Segura are you buying? The one who hit .325 with 11 home runs before the All-Star break last year, or the one who hit .241 with one home run thereafter? Me, I’m buying the one in the middle and hoping that Segura, 23, can develop into the player we saw during the first half of last year. Oh, and there’s this: dude swiped 44 bases last year.

Projection: .281 average, 14 home runs, 55 RBIs, 82 runs, 38 steals

Buy MLB gear from your favorite team.

9) J.J. Hardy, Baltimore Orioles

If you saw my first base rankings, you know that power is on the decline. Well, Hardy hit 25 homers last year – most among shortstops – and has hit 22+ bombs in five of the last seven seasons, including each of the last three. So why isn’t he rated higher? His batting average. Sometimes it’s all right, sometimes it isn’t. But as long as Hardy hits .260 or higher (like he did in 2008, 2010-11 and 2013) and not below .240 (like he did in 2009 and 2012), he offers solid mid-round value. Just make sure you take care of average and steals elsewhere, most likely in the outfield.

Projection: .262 average, 26 home runs, 79 RBIs, 78 runs, 1 steal


10) Everth Cabrera, San Diego Padres

Cabrera, with nine career homers, might be the unlikeliest PED user in baseball history. But after serving a 50-game ban last year for his ties to the Biogenesis scandal, Cabrera projects to hit leadoff the for Padres. Luckily, PEDs – or lack thereof – shouldn’t affect Cabrera’s greatest asset, which is speed. He stole 44 bases in 115 games in 2012 and 37 bases in just 95 games in 2013. If he stays healthy – and eligible – a 50-steal campaign is within reach.

Projection: .270 average, 2 home runs, 44 RBIs, 78 runs, 52 steals

11) Alexei Ramirez, Chicago White Sox

One of the more curious players in fantasy, Ramirez has been known for both his power and his speed – but not at the same time. He averaged 17.3 home runs in his first four seasons in the bigs, but has hit just 15 in the last two years combined. Conversely, he averaged 11.8 steals in his first four seasons, but he’s swiped 50 over the last two. One aspect of Ramirez’ game is consistent: durability. He’s played in 158 games three straight years.

Projection: .282 average, 10 home runs, 65 RBIs, 75 runs, 22 steals

12) Asdrubal Cabrera, Cleveland Indians

Cabrera, like Ramirez, is another tough shortstop to figure out. He hit 18 home runs in his first four seasons in the bigs, erupted for 25 in 2011, but has hit “just” 30 in the two years since. He also batted a career-low .242 in 2013. Still, I’m confident that Cabrera, a career .273 hitter, will return to form in 2014 and flirt with 20 homers.

Projection: .270 average, 18 home runs, 79 RBIs, 74 runs, 10 steals

Bottom Line

Shortstop is a pick-your-poison position. If you’re open to taking risks early in drafts, Tulowitzki, Reyes – and even Hanley Ramirez, to a degree – are the guys for you. If not, you’re better off grabbing safer, more durable options like Desmond or Zobrist.

As for Andrus, Castro, Segura and others: It all depends whether your glass is half full or half empty. Whatever it is, sip, don’t gulp. Baseball’s a long season.

Next up: Third Base

Check out “30 Players 30 Days," profiling one young player from each Major League Baseball team.

Tony Meale is the author of The Chosen Ones: The Team That Beat LeBron. He lives in Chicago and won't be mad if you follow him on Twitter @TonyMeale.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.