Couric & Co.
May 23, 2008 4:48 PM

Money Up The River?

Sharyl Attkisson is an investigative correspondent for CBS News.
(AP)
They're definitely having salmon troubles in California, Oregon and Washington State. No doubt about that.

The question many are asking, though, has to do with the massive relief plan that aims to help ... and the way it was snuck into the Farm Bill without congressional debate. The $170 million salmon bail-out was added to the Farm Bill by California's own congresswoman, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi. That's on top of $60 million provided by Congress to the Pacific salmon industry last year. Consider that the "lost catch" for the $60 million in relief was $16 million.

This year, the "lost catch" is estimated at $22 million, but they'll be getting a whopping $170 million in relief. Some digging around revealed there aren't all that many folks who fish for salmon, even in a good year. So where is all that money going? It turns out it does a lot more than just put emergency food in the mouths of fishermen who are living on the edge.

There is no means test to receive the salmon relief. In other words, somebody could own a charter boat, be making a ton of money on other catches, yet still qualify for a check from the federal government. In some cases, a very big check ... for six figures. In some cases, two years in a row. Under the salmon-relief program, fishermen and business owners are guaranteed 100 percent of their income as compared to the best recent year they've had! Even some of Pelosi's colleagues in her own party expressed outrage to me over this type of massive earmark, given out to a small number of fishermen and business owners in her home state, with no congressional debate. (They didn't want to appear on camera for fear of publicly opposing their leader). They point out that folks are hurting all over the country: home builders, auto workers, you name it. But nobody is tapping them on the shoulder and saying, "pick your best year and the federal government will write you a check to make up for what you're not earning now."

So, all things considered, the Pacific salmon industry should consider itself pretty lucky. The rest of America ... well, maybe they're not so lucky. Because they're paying the bill.
Tags:
sharyl attkisson ,
salmon ,
earmarks ,
congress
Topics:
Field Notes

Video and Galleries

Add a Comment
by jen371 May 23, 2008 7:10 PM PDT
HELLO, IM A WIFE OF AN NATIONAL GUARD WHO HAS BEEN IN IRAQ FOR THE LAST 5 MONTHS. I THINK IT''S SAD THAT OUR GOVERNMENT CAN PAY SOME FISHERMAN RELIEF MONEY WHEN MY HUSBAND IS OVER SEAS IN A WAR AND HIS FAMILY IS SUFFERING FINANCILY. WE HAVE RECEIVED AN ALMOST 5,000 A MONTH PAY CUT AND ARE BARLEY GETTING BY. WHERES OUR RELIEF FUND?
Reply to this comment
by onequeenbee May 23, 2008 7:10 PM PDT
Tonight: With salmon fishermen getting millions from Washington, is something fishy going on?

This is totally absured!!!! What about all the US citizens who have lost their income because of downsizing,companies closing, the economy or something out of their control. Allow them to pick their best salaried year and have the government pay them that amount.I
Don''t see that happening!! Are Those fishermen going to collect unemployment inadditon to this bonus that I am paying for? Then
It should be the same for every citizen- Give us our bonus- Our government is so top heavy with their own greed. As a citizen and register voter I am stunned that elected officals can get away with this.
S.A.M.
Orlando,fl
Reply to this comment
by billcolsen2 May 23, 2008 7:50 PM PDT
Taxation without representation is the same thing as earmarks when my taxes go to something that is not voted on. There should never be earmarks placed in a bill without a vote. We the people know that supplementing an industry that has no chance of recovery is not good use of our tax dollars. Our country is on the verge of one of the biggest economic crisis we have ever experienced, and there are bigger fish to fry then those in the salmon industry. If Congress doesn%u2019t listen to the people the people will respond as history has recorded in the past.

Our leaders need to step up to the plate and start building an economic infrastructure that will make us a great nation not one headed in the direction of a third world country. Leaders during the Industrial Revolution, Great Depression, ect.. made us the best in the world. Now Congress needs to listen to the people and start investing into the future and not industries that are dying. Oh By The Way has congress even thought about alternatives to an oil based economy that is affecting everyone?
Reply to this comment
by carp51 May 24, 2008 12:02 AM PDT
Please don''t believe one word of this report. What a joke. PLEASE DO YOUR OWN RESEARCH BEFORE YOU POST. People, this could be the biggest joke of factual reporting I have seen in a long time. Not one of facts presented in the report was accurate. The fishing industry on the west coast has been crippled by over regulation and the deep pockets of the agriculture lobbyist. Next she''s going to say that the fisherman are over-fishing and that''s why the fish have declined. The fishing "industry" received aid money for the 2006 season because the water flow on the Klamath river was reduced to a trickle by *** Cheney and Karl Rove. These facts are documented. The government cut off the water and ruined the lives of countless people. Don''t think for one second that salmon fisherman are getting rich from salmon subsidies. No wonder her ratings are so bad. The economic impact of a complete salmon closure in 2008 has been estimated as high as $300 million for three states. This doesn''t just affect fisherman. We are talking every small business that makes up the fishing infrastructure. Businesses effected range from: restaurants, markets, bait shops, ice plants, marina''s, party boats, fisherman, processors, packaging companies, trucking companies, fish brokers, distributors, etc etc etc... This list goes on and on. This isn''t just about fisherman people.
Reply to this comment
by tomato-patch May 24, 2008 1:39 AM PDT
This earmark (aka PORK) is a national disgrace. The potential exists for a lot of double-dipping. Fishermen, boat owners and other business people can collect an amount equal to their "highest" annual earnings from salmon fishing from 2002-2005, yet many are earning incomes by using their boats, facilities and labor in activities other than salmon fishing. In other words, they are not sitting idle... and many surely are not close to being destitute. Federal assistance payments should be based upon demonstrated need, no exceptions.
Reply to this comment
by raphaelgrn67 May 24, 2008 2:06 AM PDT
I agree 100 % with Billcolsen2''s comment, the only think he needed to add at the end go Hillary! Thanks.
Reply to this comment
by thy1138 May 25, 2008 3:42 PM PDT
"There was one particular sin which was thought to have had a great concern in bringing about the earthquake - namely, the salmon-fishing practised on the Dee on Sunday. Accordingly, the proprietors of the salmon-fishings were called before the session, and rebuked. ''Some,'' says the session record ''promist absolutely to forbear, both by himselfs and their servands in time coming; other promised to forbear, upon the condition of subseryvant; and some plainly refusit anyway to forbear.''" -Nov 8, 1608 "Domestic Annals of Scotland from the Reformation to the Revolution" by Robert Chambers. 1874. In the footnote: "The fishing of salmon in the river Dee on Sunday was a custom of some antiquity, as it had been expressly warranted by a bull of Pope Nicholas V. in 1451. The privledge was limited to the Sundays of those five months of the year in which the salmon most abound; and the first salmon taken each Sunday was to belong to the parish church. The bull recites that both by canon and common law, the right of prosecuting the herring-fishing on Sunday was conceded to all the faithful." ? p. 416

On Dec. 1, 1608, shortly thereafter it''s cited women were seized as witches and burnt alive, "...albeit they perservered constant in their denial to the end..." in Broughton.
Reply to this comment

About Couric & Co.

Go for a look behind the scenes at The CBS Evening News with Katie Couric for stuff we like and for surprises. It's also a place for you to post comments and join our conversation about the news.

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
  • Viewed
  • Commented