Has Amazon left money on the table?

In cash-strapped California, sales tax on Amazon orders is expected to bring in $83 million in the next year. CBS News

(MoneyWatch) After fighting against requirements to collect sales tax for years, Amazon (AMZN) finally seems to have given in. The world's largest retailer is now adding sales tax on purchases by shoppers in California, which joined other states where the company is now collecting taxes.

Amazon had long sought to avoid collecting taxes -- after all, that helped the e-commerce giant offer lower prices than local retailers. Yet the company may have nothing to worry about, because early results suggest no loss of business because of its adding state sales taxes. That raises an important question for Amazon and its investors: Has Amazon been needlessly undercutting price... and profit?

How does Amazon's Kindle Fire "sell out"?
Why Amazon may have killed the golden gooseAmazon is now collecting California sales tax

According to Wells Fargo analyst Matt Nemer, consumers in Texas haven't changed their purchasing behavior with Amazon since the retailer began collecting sales tax there in July. A survey of 1,000 Texans showed that 27 percent were regular Amazon customers. That was down from 30 percent before the company started charging sales tax, but the difference was so small that there may be no actual difference.

People were more motivated by convenience than by sales tax. And as Nemer also pointed out, people who say that they'll shop less online if there is sales tax probably overestimate their willingness to abstain out of principle.

So, say for a moment that the Texas numbers aren't an anomaly and that Amazon won't feel any impact from collecting sales tax. That indirectly suggests that Amazon may have been setting prices on goods lower than necessary. If the extra percentage points that tax represents isn't off-putting, it suggests that Amazon has been overly worried about customer price sensitivity. And if the company is wrong about that impact, it suggests that consumers might be less worried about product prices, as well.

Not that people don't want low prices. It's just that, in one study after another, people typically indicate that while what they spend is important, other factors are of equal or even more concern. In short, the ease of selecting and ordering a product online appears to be the more important factor.

In business, there's a phrase called leaving money on the table. As you might expect, it means that an individual or a company has failed to collect all of the money possible in a deal. Although sometimes the money is left for a strategic reason, like ensuring a longer business relationship and the greater total profits it can provide, leaving money on the table connotes a mistake, miscalculation or poor negotiation.

Out of fear that its customers are cheapskates, Amazon may have been leaving money on the table since it launched during the dot-com boom. And while the amounts are small per order, they could be very large when all taken together.

  • Erik Sherman On Twitter»

    Erik Sherman is a widely published writer and editor who also does select ghosting and corporate work. The views expressed in this column belong to Sherman and do not represent the views of CBS Interactive. Follow him on Twitter at @ErikSherman or on Facebook.

Comments