David Swain couldn't explain what happened to Shelley during the fatal dive. He admitted the two had split up underwater, forgoing the standard safety rule of using the buddy system. Did she suffer a heart attack or a stroke? Or was it panic? While Tortola authorities ruled Shelley's death an accident, her parents had their doubts, especially after David began showing a bizarre lack of remorse in the wake of her death. David's two children adamantly defend their father and say that he and they loved Shelley and that he could never have killed her.
Watch a sneak peek of this week's episode
Taking matters into their own hands, the Tyres hired an attorney and a team of underwater forensic experts to get to the bottom of what happened during the dive. The clues the team uncovered, including Shelley's damaged equipment, and David's inconsistent statements, convinced the Tyres that their daughter was murdered and that David was responsible.
In 2006, the Tyres sued David Swain for wrongful death in a Rhode Island civil court. They won and were awarded $3.5 million. As a result, Tortola authorities reopened their investigation. A year and a half later, David Swain was back on the Caribbean island, but this time, instead of a vacation, he was standing trial for murder - one that would reveal his tragic past - including incest and the murder of his mother by his own brother.
Was Shelley merely the victim of a mysterious accident and David the victim of a past trauma that left him emotionally unable to appropriately cope with her death? Or, did David's violent past ultimately lead him to commit murder?
David Swain and his children speak for the first time since he was charged with murder in Troy Roberts' report on "48 Hours Mystery: "Shelley's Last Breath," Saturday, May 8, at 10 p.m. ET/PT.