Political Hotsheet
June 30, 2009 2:15 PM

Minnesota Court Rules for Franken

(AP)
UPDATED 4:18 p.m. ET

NOTE: Coleman has now conceded and congratulated Franken on his victory. Read more here.

Former Senator Norm Coleman has lost his appeal to the Minnesota Supreme Court, paving the way for Democrat Al Franken to join the Senate and give his party a filibuster-proof majority – though Coleman's could still appeal the decision in U.S. federal court.

"We affirm the decision of the trial court that Al Franken received the highest number of votes legally cast" in the election, the decision states. The justices also explicitly ruled that Franken is "entitled" under Minnesota law to receive the certificate of election as senator.

The judges stated that Coleman has "not shown that the trial court's findings of fact are clearly erroneous or that the court committed an error of law or abused its discretion." They ruled unanimously for Franken, 5-0.

"Coleman has exhausted all of his state legal options at this point," said CBS News political director Steve Chaggaris. "His choice now is to either appeal to federal courts or concede."

Coleman was initially declared the winner in the Minnesota Senate race after Nov. 4th voting, but Franken came out ahead after a recount. His slim victory held up amid a series of court battles lasting more than seven months that have prompted the longest Senate vacancy in 34 years.

In his appeal to the state Supreme Court, Coleman had sought to overturn a lower court decision and have a number of absentee ballots that had been rejected and not counted under state law opened and possibly counted. The Supreme Court ruled that the lower court decision should not be overturned.

(AP Photo/Jim Mone)
"Coleman had hoped to show that in this election and recount process, there had been differences in the standards and stringency of application used in accepting some ballots, or rejecting others," said CBS News Director of Elections Anthony Salvanto. "The Supreme Court did not find that he’d made that case, and noted that Minnesota’s absentee voters did need to meet the standards laid out by the law."

Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, a Republican, has indicated that he would sign an election certificate if state courts instructed him to do so. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid will most likely seat Franken as soon as the certificate is delivered to the Senate. That could happen next week.

Reid released a statement following the decision encouraging Pawlenty "should put politics aside, follow his state’s laws and finally sign the certificate that will bring this episode to an end." Minnesota Secretary of State Mark Ritchie, who must also sign the certificate, has released a statement saying he will do so.

Wary of another Democrat being seated in the Senate, national Republicans have raised money for Coleman's legal battle and repeatedly encouraged him to fight on. With Congress considering President Obama's ambitious agenda on energy, health care and other issues, Franken's addition to the Senate would give Democrats an important advantage in fighting GOP filibusters.

It is not yet known whether Coleman will now seek an appeal to federal and possibly the U.S. Supreme Court.

Franken will be able to take the seat in the U.S. Senate even if Coleman appeals, however, if and when Pawlenty signs the election certificate.

Both Coleman and Franken plan to hold news conferences this afternoon.

"This doesn't mean that legally this is all over," said Chaggaris. "This could last. The question for Coleman is does he want to keep on fighting at this point."

If the decision holds up, Franken will have defeated Coleman by 312 votes in a contest in which 2.9 million ballots were cast.
Tags:
Norm Coleman ,
Al Franken ,
Minnesota ,
Appeal
Topics:
Election 2008
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 113 Comments
by jamesguy July 1, 2009 12:25 AM EDT
Doggone it, I like him.
Reply to this comment
by cranialnerves June 30, 2009 11:55 PM EDT
No fear. There is nothing more for Republicans to lose for a whole year and a half, except pride.
Reply to this comment
by wdh3007 June 30, 2009 11:30 PM EDT
I think Coleman won by stepping down he's the bigger man for it in the end and will pay off later in the long run. Minnesota will need all the help it can get when Al Frankenstein is done with it.
Reply to this comment
by bptdude June 30, 2009 11:06 PM EDT
Minn is a funny state.

Electing a pro wrestler wasnt't enough?
They had to actually elect a comedian?

What next?

Professional entertainers at least know how to ******** the public better than the mere jokers! :)
Reply to this comment
by cranialnerves June 30, 2009 11:59 PM EDT
Ronald Reagan?
by abbe91 July 1, 2009 8:37 AM EDT
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm690593536/tt0043325
by ridinguzzis June 30, 2009 6:24 PM EDT
Lets see, the wealthy vote leftist out of contrition, the poor vote leftist out of greed, those of us raising families, working every day, and trying to make ends meet(the much hated neocons),did'nt even have a candidate in the presidential election.
Reply to this comment
by cs4466 June 30, 2009 6:05 PM EDT
Go Al Franken WOOHOO!! Time to stomp the neocons into dust. *achoo!*
Reply to this comment
by NegatoryInhale June 30, 2009 5:57 PM EDT
Franken is a TOOL!!!!!
Reply to this comment
by John_Merritt June 30, 2009 5:41 PM EDT
Thats just what the Senate needs right now, another clown. Only kidding. I like Al, his wit, and the view of life through his eyes.

I just wonder how many apologies to other Senators he is going to have to make before he sits down for real business. Why you ask? Because he has skewered many of the same people he will now call 'friend'. This should be interesting.

But I like Al in the sense he brings conviction (don't you Al). He is not partisan (aren't you Al), he says what he means (don't you Al), and he votes his beliefs (won't you Al).

The rubber meets the road and so we should see alot of filibustering because Al will keep everyone at odds because he likes the floor and now he gets his chance (won't you Al?)
Reply to this comment
by ridinguzzis June 30, 2009 5:18 PM EDT
So acorn's crimes pay dividends again. and the left hails the Ventura court decision. To bad this guy's most profound thoughts were included in the title to his classic opus "Rush limbaugh is a big fat idiot". Doubtful if his intellect can recapture those glory days.
Reply to this comment
by specialty8 June 30, 2009 4:55 PM EDT
Mrzerto,
I would not trade one for the other. Pelosi, Reid , Kennedy, Gore, Byrd,Biden,need I go on,You don't have much to brag about. By the way where in the world has Pelosi and Reid gone? When Obama first went into office they showed him where to sign every money spender in all the pictures.
Reply to this comment
by mrzerato June 30, 2009 5:09 PM EDT
Well I guess we will have to agree to disagree. I mean, who wants a michele bachman, Inhofe, jim bunting and sarah palin as their leaders. I don't and you do
by specialty8 June 30, 2009 5:17 PM EDT
Nope I don't want none of them. Look at the mess Pelosi and Reid have caused since they took over. Where is Pelosi and side kick Reid? When Obama took office they showed him where to sign every money spending waste bill in every picture. Are they sick or what?
by The-Wrongs-of-Man June 30, 2009 4:46 PM EDT
Done deal. Let's get on with actually DOING SOMETHING about the REAL challenges confronting America in the Third Millennium.

It'll take years, if not decades, to repair the damage we're all suffering from right now. The stronger the Democratic majority, the better chance we have to heal from the destruction of all those painful years of RapePublicCon majorities in all three branches of government: legislative, judicial and executive.

Rape the Public. . . . Con the Public. . . . That's all RapePublicCons are good for. . . .

They can thank themselves for their losses. And we can thank them all for ours.
Reply to this comment
by dartplayer501 June 30, 2009 4:46 PM EDT
Last time the GOP lost the house, senate and the White House, it took them 40 years to come back. Here's to the next 40.
Reply to this comment
by mrzerato June 30, 2009 4:50 PM EDT
cheers!!!
by bradkt1 June 30, 2009 4:41 PM EDT
Now that the Minnesota Supreme Court has spoken, we can cut the stalling by the losers and seat Senator-elect Al Franken now. Just because Rush Limbaugh and a few conservatives claim that the election was "stolen" doesn't make it so. For all of you who claim to believe in states' right, this should be it...accept the outcome and, if your candidate didn't win, there's always another election.
Reply to this comment
by ibsteve2u June 30, 2009 4:51 PM EDT
Re: "...accept the outcome and, if your candidate didn't win, there's always another election.

Seriously. I mean, all you have to do to win in America is prove that you put your constituents first, and are not in reality the tool of a few individuals or corporations.

Now that is a handicap that the Republicans suffer from - but it is a handicap they decided they wanted and so they sought it. If a Republican wants to bad enough, he or she can go back to being an American, first and foremost.

I am sad to say, however, that I have seen no indication that they have any desires along those lines.

Worse, the Republicans jump and dance to the tunes sung by the right-wing radio and television talking heads, and the latter are in general paid by and thus are the tools of people whose wealth grows whenever legislation that puts the well-being of the American people second is passed.
by whitemale08 June 30, 2009 4:41 PM EDT
Old cap-toothed Coleman lost to that one comedian on Saturday Night Live reads Coleman's obituary.

LMAO!!!
Reply to this comment
by melchg07 June 30, 2009 4:40 PM EDT
I knew normie would drop it after this.

The Governors chair will be opening up now that Pawlenty is bowing out before he is forced out.

Norm never would have gained the seat in the first place if Senator Wellstone didn't die in a plane crash 1 week before the last election years ago. Wellstone was extremely popular and Coleman didn't stand a chance.

Now that the govenors chair is open Coleman will likely run for that (again.......and lose......again.)

I'm not particularily thrilled with the prospect of Franken, but Coleman was nothing but the same old BS from the Bush days.

Good Bye......Good Riddence.
Reply to this comment
by impeachbhb June 30, 2009 4:33 PM EDT
Is it possible that Barney is his father? There appears to have been a misprint on the birth certificate.
Reply to this comment
by ibsteve2u June 30, 2009 4:31 PM EDT
What will likely actually happen is some of the "blue dogs" in the House who tagged themselves as Democrats in order to get their foot in the door will drop all pretense of being anything but covert Republicans.

Legislation does have to go through both the Senate AND the House - and money speaks far louder than honor, ethics, morality, or even patriotism to too many of our elected officials.

On the bright side, it won't be long before we know who has to go next!
Reply to this comment
by impeachbhb June 30, 2009 4:27 PM EDT
A wonderful addition to our socialist movment. Down with Capitalism. Long Live Obama! Long Live Pelosi!

The country will fall without a single shot being fired. Chickens are coming home to roost!!!
Reply to this comment
by Oregon_State_OSU June 30, 2009 4:27 PM EDT
Congragulations Al Franken its GREAT to have another Democrat in Washington.
Reply to this comment
by BeckieBest June 30, 2009 4:24 PM EDT
Goodbye GOP! Don't come back until you've learned from your mistakes. The American people don't want any more of your incompetence and corruption. Hollow slogans won't be enough any more.
Reply to this comment
See all 113 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
HOTSHEET ON TWITTER