Political Hotsheet
June 11, 2009 1:58 PM

Obama Pushes Public Health Care Option At Town Hall

(AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)
President Obama on Thursday told a town hall audience in Green Bay, Wisc. he continues to support a government-sponsored health insurance option, or a "public plan," as a means to improve health care in the United States.

"One of the options... should be a public insurance option," the president said, addressing one of the most contentious issues in the current health care debate. "The reason is not because we want a government takeover of health care."

He said a public option would keep private companies honest and would keep prices down.

"We've got to admit the free market has not worked perfectly when it comes to health care," Mr. Obama said.

He rebuked conservative attacks that the introduction of a public plan would lead to a government "monopoly" of health care.

"Don't let people scare you," he said. "If you're happy with your plan, you keep it."

He emphasized that the next eight weeks of debate in Washington will be critical.

"If we don't get it done this year, we're probably not going to get it done," he said.

The president, however, acknowledged that his plan "comes at a time where we don’t have extra to spend. Tax revenues are down, more people are seeking help from the state, so we've got a lot of pressure on our budget."

He repeated his administration's promise to keep the reform package budget-neutral over the next ten years through reduced Medicare payments, bringing down fraud and other means of reform. He also repeated his proposal for limiting tax deductions for the rich back to rates in place during the Reagan administration.

Reforming the current system, however, is "central to our economic future, and central to the long term prosperity of this nation," he said.

The United States has the most expensive health care system in the world but is not any healthier for it, the president said. Spending on health care across the country has continued to increase, though more so in some areas than others. Green Bay has a relatively cost-efficient health care system.

"We have reached a point where doing nothing about the cost of health care is no longer an option," Mr. Obama said. "The status quo is unsustainable."

High costs have crippled families, small businesses, and corporate giants like General Motors and Chrysler, he said, and has strained the federal budget as well.

"So if you’re worried about spending and you’re worried about deficits, you need to be worried about the cost of health care," Mr. Obama said.

Besides reducing costs for the currently insured, the president said there is a "moral imperative and an economic imperative" to provide options for the uninsured.

"When someone without health insurance is forced to get treatment at the ER, all of us end up paying for it," he said.

Watch President Obama's Remarks In Green Bay, Wis.




More CBSNews.com Coverage Of Health Care Today:

Health Care Reform Enters Critical Phase - A Look At The Status Of The Health Care Debate In Washington

House Leaders Duel Over Health Care - Pelosi, Boehner Draw Lines In The Sand Over A Public Plan


Tags:
health care ,
town hall ,
Barack Obama
Topics:
Health Care
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 110 Comments
by suhaydal September 7, 2009 12:30 PM EDT
Everyone needs to step back and look at the financial meltdown of the last 2 years, large companies reported that they lost money due to the benefit packages given to their workers. Health Insurance being a primary part of their loss. Small businesses always admitted they had issues with health insurance and many are getting their health insurance through their spouce's plan and do not carry health insurance with their small business. To turn our country around and get our economy on track, we have to have insurance reform, we need a competitive public option plan that is bipartisan and draft a plan that is truly in favor of the public and not lobbyists. How do you pay for this plan, I believe a federal sales tax would be more beneficial than the public paying for all of the emergency visits by uninsured citizens that need attention. The citizens are already paying for the uninsured through the private insurance companies who increase our insurance plans. In Missouri during this hot debate Health Insurance was increased for the public school district of Ritenour by $100.00 per month through Signa, so insurance is increasing while we are talking. It is TIME to take action and side with the citizens of the United States and demand Insurance Reform.
Reply to this comment
by brokedownbrown June 20, 2009 1:01 AM EDT
Insurance Companys are running this nation.







Insurance Companys are running this country now. Why not let the government run our health care for a change. It couldn't be any worse. People are suffering so senators please, lets get it done.
Reply to this comment
by cydygitt1 June 12, 2009 10:16 AM EDT
Only in America, a country ruthlessly propagandized to embrace no-holds-barred capitalism, even when it demonstrably destroys its own citizens, would the idea of a publicly run insurance option be considered the harbinger of complete communist domination of the nation.

The rest of the capitalist world has been happily functioning with this public option for 30 years, at half the cost that it digs into Americans, but HEY, this is the EXCEPTIONAL country. The one that defines all others!! LOL.

Posted by ubrew12
------------------------

Yep.....simply amazing how these supporters of the current for-profit system are using the same propaganda of "rationed" health care by the government, when in actuality, this is exactly what we have now -- rationed and managed by lawyers working as claims supervisors in the for-profit insurance companies. How totally ironic!

It is just a sick society that has championed unfettered capitalism, especially when it comes to health care and energy -- two necessities of life -- and Americans have left this control to unscrupulous investors only interested in the almighty American dollar, instead of following Our Constitution which states in the Preamble, "promote the general Welfare," which obviously means health of our people.

We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
Reply to this comment
by cydygitt1 June 12, 2009 9:51 AM EDT
The lobbyists are far to powerful, with their copious deep pockets. When are the legislators we place in office, going to finally work for the majority of the American people.

We need medical care that everybody can afford, without deductibles and that doesn't drown car makers, small and large companies in red ink. If the ultra wealthy health insurance industry cannot achieve some kind of workable compromise--dump them as they dump their insured.

If this paramount issue cannot be negotiated agreeably, then eliminate the commercial health insurance providers for a Universal, single payer system just like some European countries. The multi-million dollar lies are already contaminating TV, Radio and magazines...

Posted by Daves1221
---------------------------

Good post pointing out the underlying problems with health care reform, especially the deep pockets of the corrupt lobbyists placating the congresscritters with billions of dollars in profits from the for-profit industry, earned by breaking the backs of middle class Americans.

The for-profit insurance industry has been cutting a fat hog for years at our expense, and had no desire to give Americans affordable health care -- just more of the same managed and rationed care -- mostly by lawyers working as claims supervisors, denying care and dropping the insured since profits were more important. They have shown no compassion for the average American, so why should we be shedding any tears for their demise since all they have is excessive GREED.

Actually, the patients should come well before profits, and our health care system lacking any efficiency is very poor for the $2.5 Trillion we pour into the system, and it certainly should be reform as in 'single-payer' universal health care, but those lobbyists with their deep pockets have already derailed any hope through their mis-information and dis-information campaigns already littering the airwaves with their abundant LIES.

America is ready for health care reform, and it will be interesting to see exactly in what form it arrives in 2009.
Reply to this comment
by cydygitt1 June 12, 2009 9:29 AM EDT
One thing is obvious, the private companies have colluded and corrupted until there is no more free market.

Since they cannot provide cost-effective and affordable product, they are of no use, and should go out of business.

Posted by brianbwb-2009
--------------------------------

Exactly! With the for-profit insurance companies raising health care costs 130% over the past 10 years, rationing care as they please and keeping health care from 50 million Americans due to the high cost, they certainly don't want to see any competition that would lessen profits. They've been cutting a fat hog for years, and all to the detriment of the American worker and middle class.

Now is the time for health care reform, and I could care less how many of these "middlemen" insurance companies that provide no health care -- just rationing -- go out of business due to their incessant GREED!
Reply to this comment
by cydygitt1 June 12, 2009 9:11 AM EDT
We have our problems, yes. Health care must be solved, as many other things.

Posted by christianh16
-----------------------------

Too bad the bush mistake never felt the need for health care reform as health care costs have risen 130% over the past 10 years. It's always been the republican'ts that have blocked health care reform at every turn, and now the party of NO has NO NEW IDEAS or SOLUTIONS for any of America's many problems -- just obstruction!
Reply to this comment
by cydygitt1 June 12, 2009 9:03 AM EDT
this isnt health care reform. Its alternate health insurance in competition with private insurers.

I am on Medicare...

Posted by McHineguy
-------------------------

Typical neocon with that darn "socialistic" Medicare complaining about the needed health care reform, so the rest of us can see some competition from the for-profit insurance companies for a change. Of course, as long as YOU have your affordable health care through the government-run Medicare, everything is just peachy, but don't let the rest of Americans have affordable health care. Just more of that selfish republican't lunacy!
Reply to this comment
by christianh16 June 11, 2009 11:55 PM EDT
You damn right this is an exceptional country. The only reason the rest of the "free world" is still around is because of the exceptional sacrifices American Soliders have made over the course of the last century.

We have our problems, yes. Health care must be solved, as many other things.

But last time I checked people from every country in the world are risking there lives, giving up everything to move to our "doomed" utopia!
Reply to this comment
by ubrew12 June 11, 2009 11:29 PM EDT
Only in America, a country ruthlessly propagandized to embrace no-holds-barred capitalism, even when it demonstrably destroys its own citizens, would the idea of a publicly run insurance option be considered the harbinger of complete communist domination of the nation.

The rest of the capitalist world has been happily functioning with this public option for 30 years, at half the cost that it digs into Americans, but HEY, this is the EXCEPTIONAL country. The one that defines all others!! LOL.

Americans will be the last to figure out how horribly they've been disfigured by their devotion to no-holds-barred capitalism. They frankly deserve the death and destruction their 'private' insurance option has doomed their citizens to.

And its by no means certain they'll see the light this time.

Fine. The better to out-compete that wasted nation. God, what a laughable fate. What a lesson to the rest of the world.
Reply to this comment
by Daves1221 June 11, 2009 11:04 PM EDT
There is going to be a political fire storm, if some kind of low cost, governmental health care doesn't pass in the Senate. The lobbyists are far to powerful, with their copious deep pockets. When are the legislators we place in office, going to finally work for the majority of the American people. When are the lobbyists of K Street going to be thrown out, along with their political puppets. We need health insurance without co-pays, premiums and clauses that deny care to people with pre-existing conditions. We need a health care for everybody who lives in this nation legally.

We need medical care that everybody can afford, without deductibles and that doesn't drown car makers, small and large companies in red ink. If the ultra wealthy health insurance industry cannot achieve some kind of workable compromise--dump them as they dump their insured. If this paramount issue cannot be negotiated agreeably, then eliminate the commercial health insurance providers for a Universal, single payer system just like some European countries. The multi-million dollar lies are already contaminating TV, Radio and magazines, so learn from other sites that are not for profit. Businesses that have everything to gain, and much to lose.
Reply to this comment
by formrusmcsgt June 11, 2009 8:26 PM EDT
The United States has the most expensive health care system in the world but is not any healthier for it, the president said.
---
Here is the crux of the issue.

For American companies to be competitive, we have to have realistic coverage costs.

Simple economics.
Reply to this comment
by brianbwb-2009 June 11, 2009 8:24 PM EDT
"...yeah right, until your plan is forced out of business trying to compete with a welfare plan..." Posted by TryTakingMyMoney

So what? If you are insured, and can afford it, who cares where it comes from?

One thing is obvious, the private companies have colluded and corrupted until there is no more free market.

Since they cannot provide cost-effective and affordable product, they are of no use, and should go out of business. This used to be a central principle of free market capitalism, if you cannot compete, bye bye. This concept has been perverted by the failure to consider that collusion, corruption, and monopolistic, cartel-like behavior of businesses actually destroys the free market.

Unless of course the "new neo-con" has officially adopted unlimited welfare, and no competition for already cash-rich private businesses as it's new platform plank.
Reply to this comment
by cydygitt1 June 11, 2009 8:21 PM EDT
Do the right thing for all Americans not just the 51% that elected you. There are 49% of us out there who are just as relevant.

The last thing we need is another idiot hell bend on doing his way regardless of the consequences...

Governing is just that governing, not dictating.....
Posted by christianh16
---------------------------

Excuse me, but it seems as if the bush mistake was selected by the SCOTUS not elected, since he lost by 500,000 votes and only got 47.9% of the vote. Seems that bush was the fascist dictator ramming the UN-patriot Act by his GOP-led congress down our throats removing many rights we used to enjoy. On the other hand, Obama won by 10 million votes in 2008, or 53% of the vote and an electoral college landslide of over 2:1 or 365 vs. 173, hardly your fantasy figures or sore-loserman whining!

We've needed health care reform badly for decades, since we pay more than any other country by double and have poor and very inefficient performance, ranked 37th in the world. Why didn't the bush mistake and the GOP-led congresscritters reform health care 8 years ago? Simple....the for-profit insurance companies and the pharmaceutical industries along with their lobbyists didn't want them to cut into their huge and growing profits.

Health care costs America $2.5 Trillion and 18% of GDP now, and it has only increased 130% over the past 10 years, which translates into huge profits!
Reply to this comment
by naj1953 June 11, 2009 8:15 PM EDT
What happen to the jobs???Try putting Americans back to work first...What happen to bringing our jobs back??? We are used to not having health insurance.
Reply to this comment
by thusspokezara June 11, 2009 8:13 PM EDT
Who is gonna want to spend 4 years of college + 4 years of medical school + 4 years of residency + 2 years of fellowship (total= 14 years) and accumulate > 100,000 in student loans to end up working for the US Government ?
Reply to this comment
by thusspokezara June 11, 2009 8:08 PM EDT
Change. Change. Change. Chainge. Chainge. Chainge. Chaing. Chaing. Chaing. Chain Chain. Chain. Chains. Chains. Chains.
Reply to this comment
by grabandgo June 11, 2009 8:00 PM EDT
So he pays for this one!
Reply to this comment
by TryTakingMyMoney June 11, 2009 7:58 PM EDT
Amazing con job from our liberal socialist messiah! "You can keep your current plan and doctor"...yeah right, until your plan is forced out of business trying to compete with a welfare plan. Then, due to high taxes to pay for Obama-care, you will be forced to join the socialist plan. America, how many times are you going to be conned before you wake up?
Reply to this comment
by incog-nito June 11, 2009 7:33 PM EDT
To the "privateers" out there who love to condemn Medicare as an example of government "failure". Let's say we get rid of it. Do you really think insurers will write a policy for an elderly retired person that he/she can actually afford?

Retired people obviously cannot get employer-based insurance, and cannot get insurance through their working children (insurance companies made sure of that), and usually have ongoing health issues. Insurers will either not cover them at all, or write a policy that's extremely expensive. Do you think retirees on a fixed income should be left to die, because that's the free market, and we can't have "socialism"?
Reply to this comment
by blog_fever2 June 11, 2009 7:16 PM EDT
SOCIALISM!
The different classes will receive different treatment.
It's that way now.
But the Government don't control it.
Senator receive Health Care, life and their current salary's of $174,000.00 for life for serving just one term.
You want these leeches to decide your health care and retirement.
Obama gets money for President and Senator and free health care for the rest of his life!
Posted by Libertarian1776 at 3:47 PM : Jun 11, 2009
*********************************************************
We are already a socialistic society..... Why wont you guys admit that?? I get it, you only want to admit it when it furthers your own agenda. I hope we do away with private insurance all together and make a simple, universal healthcare system for all.
Reply to this comment
See all 110 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Lobbyists Pushed Off U.S. Advisory Panels

    (206 recent comments)

HOTSHEET ON TWITTER