Political Hotsheet
May 21, 2009 4:07 PM

Word Cloud Of Obama And Cheney Speeches

President Barack Obama and former Vice President Dick Cheney both spoke Thursday morning on the issue of national security in what were billed as dueling speeches. Certainly, the Obama and the Bush administrations have significantly divergent philosophies on ways to best secure the nation and protect it from terrorism.

A visual representation of the speeches created via wordle.net shows that while the president's speech was peppered with lofty rhetoric and broad ideals, he was focused on addressing one specific element of national security: the closing of the Guantanamo Bay prison. Cheney, by contrast, framed his speech in the context of the current political debates but had the broader goal of defending the overarching policies of the eight-year administration to which he belonged.

Here is a picture of Obama's speech as seen by the words most common to appear:

(www.wordle.net)


Clearly, Guantanamo Bay overshadowed anything else the president had to say. "American" and "people" were two other words that featured prominently in the president's speech -- making it evident whom the president intended to address.

Mr. Obama said in his speech that there were "no easy answers" on what to do about moral and practical quandary of Guantanamo but that the military prison had "set back the moral authority that is America's strongest currency in the world."

While his central thoughts were bolstered by pragmatic language like "detainees," "security," "legal," "terrorists," and "administration," Mr. Obama devoted less breath to the principles underlying his goals. Words like "values," "institutions," "transparency," and "justice," were used far less.

Cheney, meanwhile, suggested in his speech that he wanted to respond to moments when Mr. Obama "faults or mischaracterizes the national security decisions we made in the Bush years."

Those decisions were clearly based on one word: "terrorism." A visual representation of his speech shows in no uncertain terms that the events of 9-11 and the threat of terrorists defined his vice presidency.

You can look at that picture below:

(www.wordle.net)


While Cheney did react to Mr. Obama's interest in closing down the Guantanamo prison, he chose to devote most of his speech to defending the interrogation techniques the Bush administration enacted and the intelligence learned from them.

The two speeches may have been based in dueling philosophies, but their aims were different: While the president was focused on moving his administration forward with the closure of Guantanamo Bay, Cheney was more interested in explaining the past.
Tags:
Guantanamo Bay ,
Obama ,
Cheney ,
terrorism
Topics:
Terrorism
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 55 Comments
by Audrey_Dern May 24, 2009 12:06 AM EDT
I don't know if anyone heard this, but, Iraq had a "hit" put out on his father....Bush Sr. That is one of the reasons that we went to war with Iraq, that plus the fact that Bush is so stupid that he does not know his geography that well and doesn't know where Afghanistan is!!!!! He had ALL of our soldiers killed or mutilated to get back at Iraq over the "hit" on his daddy!!!!!!!!!!!
Reply to this comment
by ReallyMeanIt May 23, 2009 10:49 AM EDT
"Remember, by the Bush (I.E. Cheney) administration ordering prisoners of war to be tortured (and not be called POWs) and for that Gov't to order that the Geneva convention to be ignored, for 8 years we gave permission to all "enemies" to sexually assault and torture our own POWs."
Posted by drrealitycheck
-------------------------------------------------------------
Naivite seems rampant among the libs.
For starters, these scumbags are not POW, they represents no country and their sole purpose is to kill us in the name of their religion by using any means available.
If you think for 1 sec that if we treated them right and they will treats ours right is extremely ignorant. It's their gods that dictates to them to destroy us regardless of any Conventions.
If anything, barrack gives the enemies greater comfort by letting them know that they's nothing to worry about once capture and they can keep their mouth shut without a care in the world.
Torture is defined by intent. What if I tell you that a person took a household drill and used it to put a hole into another person head, you'll say that's torture right? but in fact, he was call a hero! Context is everything!!
Reply to this comment
by drrealitycheck May 23, 2009 2:23 AM EDT
Remember, by the Bush (I.E. Cheney) administration ordering prisoners of war to be tortured (and not be called POWs) and for that Gov't to order that the Geneva convention to be ignored, for 8 years we gave permission to all "enemies" to sexually assault and torture our own POWs. We also lost our moral justification as a nation and even to be seen as a modern nation. Bush and Cheney should be tried at Nuremberg for crimes against humanity and the evangelical republican churchs that put them in office should be taxed and maybe shut down before they destroy what's left of Christianity in the US. I remember when we had real Christianity in this country, supporting civil rights and the constitution, not racist war mongers trying to spread rape and torture around the world while trying to destroy our constitution. We've taken government out of darkness; lets do the same for American Churches as well.
Reply to this comment
by JoJo1958 May 22, 2009 7:22 PM EDT
I have to wonder how many posters here actually WATCHED both speeches, or if they are picking up whatever bits of info from the daily KOS. Obama read his teleprompter as usual, blamed Bush, as usual, had NO solutions or PLAN as usual. Just talk, talk, talk, spend, spend, spend. Can't wait until my credit card company comes after ME to make up for their losses from the BUMS that overspent on not one, not two, but several cards. If people are THAT stupid to rack up huge amounts of debt, I don't think people that pay their accounts off in full each month should have to shoulder that! Also, I can;t pay an additional 150.00 per month more on average for my electric bill due to the Cap and Trade (failed in europe, so of course Obama wants to do it), and then pay even more taxes for that european style health system that ignorant Americans seem to think is FREE. I lived in europe for several years...HELLO...it's NOT FREE...Then there's the green jobs that has failed in Spain...unemployment because of them is over 17%. Yes, let's copy THAT plan too!

Now I'm hearing that Gregory Mankiw and former International Monetary Fund chief economist Kenneth Rogoff are encouraging the Fed to let inflation get out of control. Rogoff suggested the Fed adopt a whopping six percent inflation target!

All I read and hear about are stupid, unworkable ideas. I'm beginning to wonder if the REAL plan is to break the US to the point where we have to adopt international currency and give up our liberties. People may dislike Cheney, but he knew what he was talking about, and terrorists would fear having a man that meant business like he does. I know that it wouldn't have taken Cheney DAYS like Obama to free that captain from those pirates (zero comparison to REAL terrorists) it would have taken ONE phone call and the pirates would have been history.. Who the heck REALLY respects Obama? They are polite to his face, but laugh behind his back. I guess europeans don't admire his "coolness" or "swagga" as much as some Americans do. I would prefer someone that knew what he was doing. Nuf said. Can't wait to vote him OUT
Reply to this comment
by TooComplex May 22, 2009 3:00 PM EDT
Perhaps Mr. Cheney himself, should be the subject of a military tribunal. I hear they require very little evidence to convict. Or better yet, hand him over to the Hague War Crimes court. I have a feeling he wouldn't fare any better there either. Accountability must be had. The precedent must be set or we face even worse in the future
Reply to this comment
by TooComplex May 22, 2009 2:57 PM EDT
Cheney's speech shows what a paranoid sociopath the man really is. He can't defend the actions and policies of his administration because they were illegal and immoral and basically indefensible. From the exploitation of 9/11 for their preemptive war agenda to the unbelievable detention and torture policies, this was an administration that believed itself above the law. Cheney finally had his imperial presidency.
Reply to this comment
by cmc1227 May 22, 2009 10:47 AM EDT
My point remains-- from Lynch to other wars-- prisoner treatment rules matter a great deal for US troops held captive. Lynch is the most recently celebrated case in which prisoner treatment rules appear to have mattered. .

Posted by alphaa10000

And my point is that since Lynch the outcome of their treatment towards our POW's is irrelevant to the way in which we treat their POW's. Regadless of how we treat theirs, ours have and always will be killed. If you honestly think that if we treat tthem any different it will change their view, then you're a fool.
Reply to this comment
by midvale3 May 22, 2009 8:28 AM EDT
There are some really naive people commenting here on this post. Forget how much you dislike Cheney. The main theme is terrorism folks, and I don't care what methods were used on the bums who tried to undermine our security, and succeeded at the WTC. If you want more of the same, that's your problem.
Posted by rmoore17 at 5:11 AM : May 22, 2009

And you are one. What people are trying to say is the end does not justify the means. An extreme example would be the experiments carried out on the Jews and Concentration camp Prisoners by WW2 Germany. Good information was gained in areas such as hypothermia, but does that justify the experiments the test subjects went through. Few suffered that many could gain benefit but does that justify it? We were attacked on 9/11 and lost 3,000 people, but does that justify a war against a country who had nothing to do with the attack and the deaths of 4500+ US troops and thousands of innocent civilians? Is the loss of freedoms and possiblity of being wrongly targeted worth the false sense of security you think you have. No, you are the naive one. This is a much more complex issue than "you hit me so I hit you harder".
Reply to this comment
by Slrman May 22, 2009 7:59 AM EDT
As usual, Cheney is a liar. Not only that, he is a stupid liar. He believes his own BS. He's also insulting our intelligence because he thinks we are so stupid that we will believe him, too.

The Bush administration was amazingly ignorant in believing that you can stop terrorism by killing a few of them. All they really did is act as a recruitment incentive for more Islamic extremists to sign on to suicide missions. If they had bothered to study even the history of the USA, they would have seen that never works. But led by greed, stupidity, and arrogance (how often they all go together!) they led the USA to the brink of destruction.

It is incredible that there are still people that can accept their lie even after it has been demonstrated repeatedly that they knowingly and deliberately lied.

They are all guilty of treason and attempting to undermine the constitution. ("It's just a ******* piece of paper" - George W. Bush) If Obama was not just another politician, he would be leading the charge to put them all in prison for the rest of their lives.
Reply to this comment
by didserve May 22, 2009 7:44 AM EDT
Great Deviding Line LOL!

83 percent of America rejects the Neocon plan!

17 percent of America still supports it!

Not much of a great devide!
Reply to this comment
by didserve May 22, 2009 6:02 AM EDT
Open your eyes!

Look at where Cheney gave his speach!

In front of a bunch of Duel passport holding AIPAC members who where his puppet masters that used him to get America to rid the middle east of Israeli enemys!
Reply to this comment
by clancy49 May 22, 2009 5:41 AM EDT
Safe? How can anyone ever be safe? Can someone stop a plance from dropping out of the sky and landing on your house while you sleep? Can anyone stop that driver from drinking in a bar and driving home only to kill you and most of your family? Can you stop a drug addict from killing another for another hit? Can you stop that toddler from wandering into a pool and drowning? You've down everything you could to be safe, but there never is a safe. Torture does not make safe, it only brings pain and mental instability for the rest of your life if you even survive. This ploy of a debate? Is just another media Weapon of Mass Distriction so Congress can go on its merry way robbing from the rich to fill its personal regal coffers. What happened? The Credit Card bill supposedly to help the poor but obviously written to protect the bankers gets passed without a whimper or thought. Yeah, yesterday's news.
Reply to this comment
by ftsumner1 May 22, 2009 5:38 AM EDT
Even worse that so many people believe what Cheney says, and don't realize what a coward he really is. Even some who fought and died for his lies, and their families. I don't know if we even have a chance anymore...
Reply to this comment
by ftsumner1 May 22, 2009 4:40 AM EDT
Je suis d'accord, adt13t! DICK Cheney est pire que le diable.
Reply to this comment
by adt13t May 22, 2009 4:37 AM EDT
911 happened on dickies watch.
torture is about false confessions
and having a whipping boy to blame
for incompetently allowing the act to occur
5 deferal dick is a incompetent sadistic coward
now attempting to cover his tracks with more lies.
what about all those no bids, katrina and big pharma payoff, every thing dickie did was class warfare incompetent cronyism,
another crooked smile dick
Reply to this comment
by ftsumner1 May 22, 2009 4:28 AM EDT
I am a moron. How can I possibly believe all the stupid things that I do? Can't somebody shut me up? Even a kindergartener would know better than that crap I spout off.

Soy estupido. No tengo ninguna idea de la realidad. Mi mama hace caca.

Que faites vous? Je suis estupide.
Reply to this comment
by airboatboy May 22, 2009 4:10 AM EDT
Didn't 9/11 happen on the Bush/Cheney watch? Didn't they overlook some information that was right in front of their eyes? Great job of keepin' us safe! Cheney's so crooked his mouth won't even stay straight on his face. His momma was right on when she named him DICK.
Reply to this comment
by kenhamlett May 22, 2009 3:44 AM EDT
This disjointed battle of words has a clear message and a hidden message for me.
Up until now President Obama has been learning the ropes in Washington. He does not know who his real friends are or even which friends are actually his enemies. Today's speeches change that just a little. He, along with all of us following this "pseudo-debate" can now be sure Cheney will say anything to support his position. The only things Cheney and his sidekick, Bush, have done in the past is create a war in the wrong place for the wrong reasons, help destroy our economy and destroy our honor and credibility in the world. Today we see that Cheney actually thinks posturing and excuses will contenue to work like the lies of the past tricked many into supporting their schemes.
The clear message is that our greatest enemies are right here in this country still trying to hide their sins by screaming patriotism.
The hidden message for me? I find that I have paid lipservice to supporting our President without getting out of my chair and fighting at his side (figuratively or literally) to bring our country's honor and credibility bact to its former status and to repair the damage to our economy caused by Mr. Cheney and his profit happy friends.
I think I need to change that to what ever extent possible. Now that we have voted for our new President and are now sitting back to see what happens, I think the next step is to offer our active assistance though both thoughts words and muscle to help make things right. President Obama has correctly laid out the path we should take to recovering what we once had. It is now time we clear the path and walk it to our new destiny.
Politics and policies can only do so much. Support via action must do the rest to help make our nation better than what has been perceived to be of late.
Reply to this comment
by r9119111 May 22, 2009 2:34 AM EDT
Cheney is RIGHT!

Posted by mh4cbs1 at 9:58 PM : May 21, 2009

Without wasting words --- Cheney is wrong.
Reply to this comment
by mh4cbs1 May 22, 2009 1:45 AM EDT
Audrey,

Sorry... It is pretty sad when people can not realize that my rambling was intended to satirize the bizarre, hypocritical extremism of the NeoCon supporters -- the 'God Bless America' people who cheer Cheney/Bush when they butcher the citizens of other nations, while expecting that they can defeat terrorism while they generate so much hate and resentment.
Reply to this comment
See all 55 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
HOTSHEET ON TWITTER