Public Eye
December 12, 2005 11:11 AM

The Wiki War

Well, the mystery of the wiki has been solved: On Sunday, the Tennesean reported that Nashvillian Brian Chase created the fake online biography of journalist John Seigenthaler that linked Seigenthaler to the assassinations of two Kennedys – and set off a debate about Wikipedia, the online encyclopedia that can be edited by all comers.

Chase said he created the fake Seigenthaler biography in order to play a trick on a coworker – and didn't know anyone used Wikipedia as a serious reference tool. He hand delivered a letter of apology to Seigenthaler and deemed the whole kerfuffle "a joke that went horribly, horribly wrong." Seigenthaler accepted the apology, but said "it doesn't lessen my frustration that anybody can put anything on Wikipedia."

A book indexer named Daniel Brandt helped force Chase into the public eye by tracing the computer used to make the offending entry to a delivery company in Nashville where Chase worked. He subsequently called and emailed the company, and a New York Times reporter called as well, which made employees nervous. Now Chase is out of a job, under somewhat unclear circumstances. From the Times' account:
Mr. Chase resigned from his job because, he said, he did not want to cause problems for his company. Mr. Seigenthaler urged Mr. Chase's boss to rehire him, but Mr. Chase said that, so far, this had not happened.
If you don't want to read the Tennessean or the Times, of course, you can always learn about Chase on – ahem – Wikipedia. And as befits Wikipedia's philosophy, there's also a debate on whether Chase should have an entry in the first place.
Tags:
Wikipedia
Topics:
Media Issues
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment
by alphaa10-2009 December 12, 2005 8:42 PM EST
Wikipedia offers articles of amazing breadth and depth and a surprising degree of reliability, timeliness and sophistication. Its general track record is good (like any other researcher, of course, you should verify key points with other sources). Billed as an online (free) encylopedia for everybody, Wikipedia appears to join the trend of web publishers to bringing an editor/publisher layer of accountability for posts and content-- however formalized this control turns out to be. Every reputable website has some degree of identification, as in a "Contact Us" page or "Who We Are". Wikipedia's is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Contact_us Wikipedia is a welcome counter to an increasingly worrisome trend in web publishing. Lately, tollbooths are springing up for website visitors as online publishers try to turn web ventures into the moneymaker their conventional efforts may not have been. But the internet is a different environment, and this approach usually drives prospective visitors away. For the same reason, the tollbooth approach tends to restrict access along economic lines and widens the gap between information haves and have-nots. Wikipedia, for all its warts and developmental flaws, is a novel, altruistic enterprise for the general public and should be supported in the same spirit.
Reply to this comment
by wintermute1-2009 December 12, 2005 8:06 PM EST
I wonder if we'll find out how Brandt got the IP. Here's Wiki on disclosure; best guess is he got cooperation from an insider: http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Privacy_policy#Policy_on_release_of_data_derived_from_page_logs
Reply to this comment
by peterbaldwin-2009 December 12, 2005 3:19 PM EST
Not only has "Big Brother" arrived, but Danny Brandt's sleuthing demonstates that "Little Brother" is out there too, able to track down each and every errant email. "Outing" Chase is ample warning to all potential Wikipeia malfeasors that little brother is laying in wait to spill the beans on any devious shananighans. Not such a bad thing. Wikipedia, however, is really just undistilled collective knowledge, and has never been presented as Daniel Webster. I think I'll check the Wikipedia entry for wikipedia and maybe google it too.
Reply to this comment
by jaguar0 December 12, 2005 2:53 PM EST
Well I got curious, just to see how easy it was to place a phony piece of info, on "Wikipedia." So finding the PR, page for a certain, radio network, (CBS), I thought, I would tell everybody about the great comedy show that was broadcast everyday on CBS, radio. You know the one I's talking about> The one in which George Bush, is giving a half-hour of jokes? Obviously, their is no such show> My "experience test" proved, that less then three minutes later, the listing for the "George Bush" comedy half hour, was gone. Obviously, someone at Wiki, is doing some kind of checking>
Reply to this comment

Exclusive Webshow

Mike Huckabee on GOP "rock stars," 2012, health care reform and more. Watch Now

About Public Eye

Description for Public Eye

  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Lambert: Offering No Apologies

    (485 recent comments)