By

Ryan Jaslow /

CBS News/ August 2, 2012, 3:43 PM

Some supplements are actually prescription drugs

Pills and pill bottles iStockphoto
There have been more than 400 recalls of supplements since 2008, mostly for products marketed for bodybuilding, weight loss and sexual enhancement, says Consumer Reports. Many of these recalled products have contained similar active ingredients to their prescription counterparts, such as sildenafil (Viagra) and sibutramine (Meridia weight loss drug, pulled from the market in 2010 because of heart attack and stroke risk). The FDA has received reports of kidney failure, potentially deadly blood clots in the lungs and deaths associated with supplements tainted by drug ingredients.

"A number of the spiked sexual enhancement products claim to work within 20 to 45 minutes," Dr. Dana Fabriucant, director of the FDA's division of dietary supplement programs, told Consumer Reports. "When we see a product that makes claims above and beyond what a dietary supplement might do - above supporting health - and within a time frame of a few minutes, it tips us off that we might have a spiked product."

How to protect yourself: Looking to lose weight? Try diet and exercise. Want to bulk up? Try weight training. And for those experiencing issues in the bedroom, see a doctor, since it could be caused by an underlying health problem such as diabetes, high blood pressure or kidney disease.

24 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
turbo4 says:
The best way to be assured about your vitamins is to know where they are produced. If you buy your vitamins from www.vitaminspower.com you will be assured all the vitamins are produced here in the United States. True, the chances of good ingredients from vitamins made in India and China are questionable. You are right to be careful.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
johnlockesghost says:
My position on taking vitamins is that by taking vitamins today, one won't have to take prescription medications tomorrow. I have followed this idea for over 50 years adding to the list of vitamins that I take every so often, because as one gets older, the need gets greater. I am now 80. My Doctor says I'm weird because I don't require prescriptions. Conclusion: My plan works.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
bmc65 says:
The article states 6300 reported averse events between 2007 and 2012 with 10,300 of those being serious. Could someone please explain to me how you get 10,300 out of 6300?
I agree with the folks who call this article propaganda. While I agree that most of one's vitamins should come from whole unprocessed foods, I think there is a great deal more to worry about with pharmaceuticals and the inert crap being pawned off as food these days.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
RedDeath50 says:
lowlandpark...........................

Try doing some research and reading instead of relying on anything and everything you hear on Faux Noise. OH! I forgot! The US government would never lie or deceive the citizens of this country!

Pathetic...truly pathetic!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
johnlockesghost says:
To be fair, CBS ought to run a parallel article discussing the dangers of taking prescription medications which, BTW account for a far greater number of deaths than dietary supplements.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
lowlandpark says:
Please remember that the NPA is the trade group of the snake oil salesman. They exist to make money off you by selling you stuff that you almost certainly don't need. Why are you skeptical of the government and Consumer Reports and not a bunch of people who are getting very rich selling supplements? This is directed at most of the commenters above, assuming that these comments are not just planted by the NPA, which they may be.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mkeaton1 says:
Here's what the Natural Products Association had to say about the article:

The Natural Products Association (NPA) is the nation's largest association representing natural products and the leading representative of the dietary supplement industry. NPA Executive Director and CEO John Shaw and Senior Vice President of Scientific and Regulatory Affairs Dr. Cara Welch respond to a Consumer Reports story about vitamins and other supplements:

John Shaw: "Consumer Reports distorts the facts with just another smear campaign against dietary supplements. Data from the government shows that supplements have an excellent safety record, especially considering the millions of supplements sold annually. Nothing in Consumer Reports should convince anyone to stop taking their supplements."

"Supplements are foods, not drugs. If a product makes disease claims or includes a drug, then it's not a supplement. The legitimate supplement industry who we represent wants the criminals selling these illegal drugs out of business."

"Misleading stories like this one are especially unfortunate because they can hurt the mom and pop stores that sell natural products and supplements in communities across America. Tens of thousands of Americans depend on this industry for jobs. They are dedicated to supporting the healthy lifestyles of millions of people."

"Finally, the article offers advice on how to avoid choking. While this is no laughing matter, someone could choke anytime swallowing anything, not just supplements. This is another example of fear-mongering by Consumer Reports and using this issue as an argument against taking supplements is insulting to consumers."

Cara Welch: "Consumer Reports makes the obvious points that nothing is risk-free and too much of anything is not necessarily a good thing. Furthermore, it relies on disputed and inaccurate studies to draw the wrong conclusions. Consumers deserve better."

"For example, the American Heart Association has recommended a diet high in omega-3s and supplementation for those who cannot get enough from their diet. In addition, the federal government itself has approved health claims for supplements, such as associating vitamin D and calcium intake with a reduced risk of osteoporosis."

"Research shows that supplements can address nutritional deficiencies and improve overall health. Getting an adequate amount of nutrition from the diet is ideal, but unfortunately, many Americans are not getting the nutrients they need from the foods they eat. The Natural Products Association encourages a healthy lifestyle for all Americans with supplementation as needed. As always, talk to your doctor before taking any supplements."

NPA offers a variety of information and resources about supplements at www.NPAinfo.org/consumers.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
RedDeath50 says:
This article is a complete crock of crap! What is really surprising is Consumer Reports acting as the government's mouthpiece and just regurgitating the FDA's bull crap instead of actually testing themselves! Sad that even a once reputable company like CU has so badly deteriorated!

Just as an example of what total BS this is, let's take one quote from the article:

If you get some midday sun during the warmer months and eat vitamin D-rich foods, such as fatty fish, eggs and dairy products fortified with the vitamin, you probably don't need to take a supplement, according to Consumer Reports.

There are numerous studies (that CU conveniently decided to disregard) showing that in order to get enough Vitamin D from the sun, you would have to stand naked for 20 minutes outside each and every day at noon time. And that does not even factor in the fact that as we age, our ability to manufacture Vitamin from the sun decreases yearly and this would mandate longer daily exposures to the sun. We won't even talk about the increased risk of skin cancer because in order to get full benefit from the sunshine, you cannot use any type of sun block!

Also, their comment about "eating fatty fish" does not sound particularly healthy!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
wizardlady says:
This is a boo job on vitamins and supplements. If this same article was written and had prescription drugs substituted, it would be much more factual.

Apparently the FDA is doing a negative campaign against vitamins and supplements in hopes of putting them under prescription control as a "benefit to the safety of the public at large", when in fact, it is nothing more than big PHARMA feeling the hurt because some folks get smart enough not to get hooked on the Doctors 'magic' drugs.

If you are over fifty, and go to a doctor, you will leave with at least THREE prescriptions......whether you need them or not. WHY?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
the0racle says:
of course, FDA does nothing to stop the likes of aspartame, high fructose corn syrup, and GMOs such as Frankencorn. Only in America; the facts are kept obscure so corporations will profit. Other first or second world countries actually offer better protections and information for consumers. Evil reigns in America.
reply
See all 24 Comments