Top 10 Management Myths

Last Updated Apr 7, 2011 7:19 PM EDT

Top 10 Management MythsThere are as many management theories as there are management gurus, academics, and bloggers. And since theories - true or not - have a tendency to stick around, well, that means there are lots of myths.

Management isn't a science; it's an art. It involves millions of people in thousands of organizations, each of which is unique. That's what makes it so subjective, by definition. Sure, certain innovative management concepts become the rule, but they're rare, that's for sure.

These management myths aren't just the most common, they're also some of the most mythical and therefore easy to debunk. And one thing successful managers have in common is that they don't drink the Kool-Aid or buy into BS fads. So, if you aspire to be a successful manager, don't buy these:

Top 10 Management Myths
  1. Bad managers are a bad thing. It's ironic that society is okay with bad spouses, bad marriages, bad workers, bad professionals - hell, bad people - but not bad bosses. Listen carefully: there's a bell curve for all things involving people. It's reality; it can never and will never change. Deal with it.
  2. It's not what you know but who you know. Ah, the mantra of the perpetual underachiever, the assumption being that because he can't get a promotion it means the guy who did must know somebody. The truth is that overachievers work harder and yes, they schmooze harder too. That's why they know more successful people and are therefore exposed to more opportunities.
  3. It's the path to big bucks. For the vast majority, that's simply not the case. There's at least as good a chance that you'll hit the jackpot as a professional, individual contributor, or entrepreneur. That's because the big bucks are in a thin sliver of executive management and few managers ever get there.
  4. You should be prepared for the job. Sure, young managers should get some basic training, but anyone who says he was adequately prepared for his first management role is BSing. A great deal of management skill simply can't be taught; it's best learned on the job, under fire, in the real world.
  5. Abusive, confrontational, or dysfunctional managers are bad managers. Some of the most successful managers of our time fit that description: Larry Ellison, Bill Gates, Andy Grove, and Steve Jobs, to name a few famous ones. Sure, there are plenty of best-selling books that promote the myth, but like it or not, I've never observed a correlation.
  6. It's all about managing people. This is probably the notion I most strongly want to dispel. Sure, managing people is a big component, especially for line managers. And employees certainly want to believe they're first and foremost in the hearts and minds of their bosses. But if you look at the specific goals - how success is defined for most managers - they're typically more about managing a function or a business than about managing people.
  7. Leadership and management are unrelated. I hear this all the time and it's a huge misconception. While it is true that there are different skill-sets, they're still intimately related. The truth is that good management skills make better leaders and the converse is also true. I would argue that great management requires excellent leadership skills.
  8. MBAs make better managers. Yes, you learn a lot getting an MBA. Yes, it's a good piece of paper to have - especially from a top notch school - if you aspire to senior management. But no, there is no credible evidence that it will make you or anyone else a better manager. That's largely because management is more art than science.
  9. It's tougher to get in than it is to do. The truth is just the opposite. If you're capable, you'll become a manager. But it takes a helluva lot more than that to become a successful manager.
  10. You should be able to do the jobs of those you manage. I can't even honor this myth with a logical argument; it's so ridiculous. For some people in some jobs - primarily line managers - it can help. In the vast majority of cases, however, there's little correlation and it decreases further the higher you go up the management chain.
Bottom line. Perhaps the supreme, overriding uber-myth here is that there's a formula for management success. As long as people are unique individuals and organizations are unique entities - and they surely are - there can be no formula for successful management.

Sure, certain qualities and processes work better for certain people in certain organizations and industries, but that's a far cry from a general blueprint for management success. It simply doesn't exist. So if you stop looking for formulas, you'll go a long way to becoming a more successful manager.

Also check out:
Follow Steve Tobak on Twitter or Facebook
Image: NightRPStar via Flickr

Comments

CBSN Live

pop-out
Live Video

Market Data

Watch CBSN Live

Watch CBS News anytime, anywhere with the new 24/7 digital news network. Stream CBSN live or on demand for FREE on your TV, computer, tablet, or smartphone.

Market News

Stock Watchlist