Last Updated Sep 10, 2010 12:37 PM EDT
The "You Can Have It All" annuity pays you 100% of the average return of the S&P 500 index every year!
To see how this plays out in the real world, let's assume the S&P 500 total return is 12%. And let's say you actually read the part where the insurance company noted it was taking a two percent spread. What do you think your return will be?
- a) 10 percent
- b) 8 percent
- c) 5.4 percent
- d) 3.4 percent
The language in the sales pitch specified the "S&P 500 index" rather than the total return of the S&P 500. Total market returns come from two sources - capital appreciation and dividends. The index return is only the part that comes from the appreciation. Dividends, averaging about two percent annually, have been conveniently stripped out. So before the spread is deducted, your 12 percent return has already been cut to 10 percent.
Trick #2 - "average annual" return
If you actually possess the attention span to slog through the 373 page disclosure document, you would clearly see on page 189 that the term "average annual return" is defined as 1/12 of the first month plus 1/12 of the second month, etc. This translates to getting an expected tad over half the total annual return. Depending on the timing of the market increase, this could be either more or less than half. In this example, it yields about 54% of the total increase of the index.
Thus, the 10 percentage point index return turns into only 5.4% for you, as illustrated in the chart below.
Two Tricks and a Spread
So, after taking into account the stripped dividends, and the tricky language to take back nearly half of the rest, your return is 5.4 percentage points less the two percentage point spread. That's right, you net 3.4 percentage points, or only slightly more than a quarter of the market return. The correct answer was (d). This is far less than what you'd get if you built the functional equivalent of this annuity with a CD and a low cost index fund yourself.
It gets worse
If I haven't depressed you enough, nearly every EIA contract I've reviewed gives the insurance company the unilateral right to change the spread and the cap you can earn going forward. In short, the game is rigged. And this is merely one provision an insurance company uses in its sales literature. The industry has many other tactics I wish were illegal.
The Equity Indexed Annuity is the ultimate behavioral sale on the planet. Earning market returns without risk plays to our human instincts of fear and greed. If it were real, however, I wouldn't be writing about it - I'd be rich.
Postscript: AllFinancialMatters.com just posted a great piece on the return of this annuity in 2009, a year where the total return of the S&P 500 was 26.5%.
More on MoneyWatch
Build Your Own Annuity
Four CDs That Protect Against the Bond Bubble
Insurance Investing and the $100,000 Challenge