Hypoallergenic dogs won't help allergy sufferers much, says study

The most famous Portugese Water dog, Bo, is currently residing in the White House. However, the high-profile pooch - selected because Malia Obama has allergies - may have helped fuel the myth of the truly hypoallergenic dog. The perception that you can side-step allergies by "something as simple as getting a shorter-haired animal or even a hairless animal is just not accurate," says Dr. Sublett. And spending a few hours with an animal won't tell you if it will pose future problems, he says. Daily exposure can trigger a new allergy or "keep the fire stoked" on chronic problems.More from Health.com: How to stop allergies at home Chuck Kennedy/The White House via Getty Images

bo, obama, portuguese water dog, hypoallergenic
Bo, the Obama family's Portuguese Water Dog may be adorable, but is he hypoallergenic?
Getty Images

(CBS) Sorry, hypoallergenic dog owners. That labradoodle you dropped big bucks on might make for a cuddly companion, but won't help your allergies.

That's what the author of a new study says about the class of dogs that are thought to shed less and produce less allergy-inducing pet dander.

"We found no scientific basis to the claim hypoallergenic dogs have less allergen," study author Dr. Christine Cole Johnson, chair of Henry Ford's Department of Public Health Sciences, said in a written statement.

Woof. Then why do so many people buy hypoallergenic dogs? Numerous websites extol the benefits of owning a hypoallergenic dog. "These dogs will allow those of you that do suffer from allergies to keep your allergies at a very comfortable level, allowing you to enjoy owning and raising a dog," said Puppy-Basics. Even President Obama famously said the White House dog would have to be hypoallergenic because daughter Malia has allergies, before the family settled on Bo, a Portuguese Water Dog.

So researchers put the hypoallergenic claim to the test, for the study published in the July issue of the American Journal of Rhinology and Allergy. They analyzed dust samples from 173 homes with one dog and a newborn baby. All together, 62 dog breeds were studied, 11 of which were considered to be hypoallergenic. The researchers found there were no differences in allergen levels between hypoallergenic dogs and non-hypoallergenic ones. And that's not all, in homes where parents' said the dog wasn't allowed in a newborn's room, hypoallergenic breeds gave off more allergens than their counterparts.

"The idea that you can buy a certain breed of dog and think it will cause less allergy problems for a person already dog-allergic is not borne out by our study," Johnson said.

What gives?

Dr. James T.C. Li, chair of the division of allergic diseases at the Mayo Clinic may have the answer.  He says the real source of pet allergies is not the fur, but a protein that's found in a dog's saliva and urine, that sticks to dried flakes on the pet's skin, known as dander. Some dogs, he says, are "marketed" as hypoallergenic because they don't shed as much.

"Because these dogs don't shed, the allergy-causing dander that sticks to their fur doesn't get released into the air or onto the floor as much as it would with a shedding dog," he writes on the Mayo Clinic website. "While you may have fewer allergy symptoms with a so-called hypoallergenic dog than with a shedding dog, no dog breed is hypoallergenic."

Not every hypoallergenic dog-owner agrees. Gail Widman, founder and president of the Australian Labradoodle Club of America, who also breeds them told Time her clients have been helped by hypoallergenic dogs.

"It makes an extreme difference for people with allergies."

What do you think, dog owners?

Comments

CBSN Live

pop-out
Live Video

Watch CBSN Live

Watch CBS News anytime, anywhere with the new 24/7 digital news network. Stream CBSN live or on demand for FREE on your TV, computer, tablet, or smartphone.