Health Care Passage Plan Unconstitutional?

House leaders are considering a parliamentary maneuver because they don't have enough votes to pass the Senate health reform bill outright with a direct vote. Too many House members object to what's in it.

The maneuver would let them approve the bill without actually voting on it. CBS News correspondent Sharly Attkisson explains how that can happen.





If Democrats get the votes, here's how it would work:

The House votes on the health care bill that the Senate passed December 24 -- the one with those controversial sweetheart deals for select states, like the Cornhusker Kickback, the Louisiana Purchase, and what some see as federal funding for abortion. Next, the House would vote on an updated version that fixes things they don't like, like those sweetheart deals. That becomes a "reconciliation bill." The Senate passes that, and it's a done deal.

The problem is, Democrats don't yet have the votes to do it that way. So House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is considering a controversial strategy to help give cover to those vulnerable Democrats facing tough elections.

Under the House "self-executing rule," members vote only on the reconciliation bill, the one with the fixes. The controversial Senate version is automatically "deemed" to be "passed" - deem and pass - without a separate vote.

Republicans say it's unconstitutional, and have taken to calling the approach the "Slaughter rule," named for Louise Slaughter, the top Democrat on the House Rules Committee overseeing the process.

Republicans Have Used "Slaughter Solution" Many Times
CBSNews.com Special Report: Health Care

"If they are going to slaughter democracy, they shouldn't do it in public," said Greg Walden, R-Ore.

The namesake herself begs to differ.

"There's no way in the world we would be doing an unconstitutional thing," said Slaughter, D-N.Y.

Both parties use the self-executing rule. It's how they passed the smoking ban on domestic flights, an employment verification measure, and a census bill.

Some legal scholars say the method raises serious questions.

"The constitution says both houses, the House and the Senate, must pass an identical bill which then is passed on to the president for his signature before it would become law," said CBS News chief legal correspondent Jan Crawford. "That doesn't look like it would be the case here."

So why hasn't the self-executing rule gotten much attention before? It's never been used on anything this big. Democrats know it could add to the appearance that backroom deals are pushing through something a lot of Americans don't like, but it may be the only way the White House believes it can get done.

More Coverage of the Health Care Reform Fight:
Countdown to Health Care Vote Spurs Final Push from Dems, Opponents
Door Closed on Health Care Protesters
Cloudy Skies Start Clearing For Dems
GOP Tries to Block "Slaughter Solution" in Health Care Vote
Explainer: How the House Could Pass Health Care Reform with One Vote
Liberal Groups Turn on Dems to Pass Health Care Reform
Groups Seek to Influence Health Care Debate Without Disclosing Donors


  • Sharyl Attkisson On Twitter»

    Sharyl Attkisson is a CBS News investigative correspondent based in Washington.

Comments

CBSN Live

pop-out
Live Video

Follow Us

Watch CBSN Live

Watch CBS News anytime, anywhere with the new 24/7 digital news network. Stream CBSN live or on demand for FREE on your TV, computer, tablet, or smartphone.

On Twitter