The site, which has been shut down, also disclosed the girls' family information, phone numbers and addresses. At least 14 other male students at the prestigious Horace Greeley High School had the password to the site.
"In many cases, there was information put out that was very sensitive, very private and information that caused a lot of anguish," said Detective Sgt. James Carroll. "All of these girls said they felt exploited by it."
The two seniors, whose names were not disclosed, were charged last week with second-degree aggravated harassment after word about the Web site spread through the school, officer Dan Cannon said Tuesday. The charge carries a maximum penalty of a year in jail and a $1,000 fine.
Cannon said it was department policy not to release the names of suspects who might get youthful-offender status from a court. The seniors, both 18, were arrested and released without bail.
Mike Weinberg, a senior at the school, told a local newspaper, The Journal News, he was angered by the site because it exposed the girls to public humiliation.
"You hang out with your friends and you make stupid comments but no one acts on it," he said. "No one makes a Web site."
Greeley is a high-achieving school in wealthy Chappaqua, home to former President Clinton and Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton.
© MMI The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed