8th Body, Plane Wreckage Found in Hudson

The wreckage of a helicopter is lifted by crane from the Hudson River and placed on a boat as seen from Hoboken, NJ, Sunday, Aug. 9, 2009. The wreckage of a helicopter is lifted by crane from the Hudson River and placed on a boat as seen from Hoboken, N.J., Sunday, Aug. 9, 2009. Divers recovered a piece of a submerged helicopter and a fifth body Sunday as investigators searched the Hudson River for wreckage from the helicopter and a small plane that collided in midair, killing nine people. (AP Photo/Seth Wenig) AP Photo/Seth Wenig

Hudson River divers on Monday found the wreckage of a small plane and one of two victims missing following a midair collision with a sightseeing helicopter that killed nine people.

The wreckage of the single-engine Piper was found in about 60 feet of water in the middle of the river, indicating it had drifted from the spot where it crashed, closer to New Jersey's riverbank, said the New York Police Department's top spokesman, Paul Browne. It was found on its side with no wings visible.

NYPD divers couldn't remove the man's body from the aircraft wreckage. The Army Corps of Engineers was being consulted about trying to pull the plane to the surface of the river, which is less than three-quarters of a mile wide at the crash site between New York and New Jersey. The mangled helicopter was raised from the river Sunday.

Nine people - two men and a boy from a Pennsylvania family on the plane and five Italian tourists and a pilot on the helicopter - died in Saturday's collision, which occurred in a congested flyway popular with sightseers. Before Monday afternoon, seven bodies had been recovered.

Listen: Hudson crash 911 calls
Reporter's Notebook: Hudson Tragedy
Is Oversight of For-Hire Flights Too Lax?

Families Mourn Crash Victims

At an afternoon briefing, National Transportation Safety Board chief Debbie Hersman said an eight-day NTSB survey of the river corridor before the collision had counted about 225 aircraft flying within a 3-mile radius of the collision site each day.

The airspace where many of these tour craft fly is below 1,100 feet, where pilots are largely free to choose their own routes, radioing their positions periodically but not communicating regularly with air traffic controllers.

Sources say the plane's pilot closed in on the back of the helicopter and apparently never saw it...as his right wing clipped the chopper's rotor, reports CBS News correspondent Bob Orr.

The helicopter may have been in the pilot's blind spot and neither aircraft had equipment to warn crews of an impending collision, reports Orr.

Hersman said air traffic controllers at Teterboro (N.J.) Airport told the pilot of the small plane to switch radio frequencies so controllers at Newark (N.J.) Airport could communicate with him but Newark controllers never made contact. She said a Teterboro controller asked the plane pilot if he wanted to go down the river or southwest.

When the Piper pilot answered, "Either," the controller told him to "Let me know."

"OK, tell you what," pilot Steven Altman answered, "I'll take down the river."

The divers Monday fought currents exceeding 3 knots. Silt reduced visibility to less than 6 inches in some places on the river bottom and was never better than a foot, said New Jersey State Police Lt. Albert Ponenti.

Police suspended their diving operations Monday evening and were to return to the water Tuesday.

All seven victims recovered have been positively identified through dental records and fingerprints, the New York medical examiner's office said. Autopsies completed Monday found they died from blunt-impact injuries.

Italian Ambassador Giovanni Castellaneta said he had met with the medical examiner in New York and with relatives of the five Italian victims.

"Today the relatives were asking me, 'How it can be that a holiday in New York can become such a tragedy?"' Castellaneta said in Italian. He promised to find out and said, "We intend to keep that promise."

(AP / CBS)
About a half-dozen relatives of the Italians were still in New York, including cousins and uncles, waiting to travel back with the bodies. A group of 10 tourists traveled from Italy, two to celebrate a 25th wedding anniversary.

"They are destroyed by pain," Castellaneta said.

Other members of the tourist group had gone on a helicopter ride a day before the crash and had planned to go again, he said.

"They told me that the day before, they had the tour on New York City and were very happy about the tour," Castellaneta said. "And they had booked another tour, but of course that was canceled."

Prosecutors in Bologna, Italy, on Monday opened a routine investigation into the crash after receiving a complaint from Codacons, an Italian consumers' group. The probe for multiple manslaughter and causing a disaster does not name any suspects.

The NTSB's Hersman told CBS' "The Early Show" Monday morning that the agency tasked with investigating every civil aviation accident in the U.S. isn't laying blame until it completes its investigation.

"We know that there is a lot of traffic over the Hudson," Hersman said. "We don't know all of the facts. We've only been here a day, and so we won't be reaching any conclusions" at this time.

Witnesses said the small plane approached the helicopter, which had just taken off from Manhattan's West Side for a 12-minute tour, from behind and clipped it with a wing. Hersman said the helicopter was gaining altitude when the two hit. Both aircraft split and fell into the river, scattering debris and sending weekenders enjoying the beautiful day running for cover.

  • CBSNews

Comments

Watch CBSN Live

Watch CBS News anytime, anywhere with the new 24/7 digital news network. Stream CBSN live or on demand for FREE on your TV, computer, tablet, or smartphone.