Political Hotsheet
July 14, 2009 5:54 PM

Soldier Challenges Deployment, Citing Obama's Birth

(AP / CBS)
Here's a story tailor-made to burn up the Internet: A soldier is objecting to his deployment to Iraq because he believes President Obama wasn't born in the United States.

Conspiracy theories about where Mr. Obama was born abound in some quarters despite the fact that the Obama campaign posted the then-candidate's Hawaiian birth certificate online last year. Skeptics call the certificate a forgery, though their claims have been repeatedly debunked.

Among the doubters is conservative politician Alan Keyes, who has taken the question of the president's birth to court. Keyes believes Mr. Obama is not a "natural born citizen" and is thus ineligible for the presidency under the Constitution.

Now comes word that U.S. Army Maj. Stefan Frederick Cook, a reservist who lives in Florida, is challenging his deployment based on that argument. Reports the Ledger-Enquirer out of Columbus, Georgia: "Cook’s lawyer, Orly Taitz, who has also challenged the legitimacy of Obama’s presidency in other courts, filed a request last week in federal court seeking a temporary restraining order and status as a conscientious objector for his client."

Cook is arguing that because Mr. Obama isn't really the president (and thus isn't the commander in chief), the soldier "would be acting in violation of international law by engaging in military actions outside the United States under this President's command. ... simultaneously subjecting himself to possible prosecution as a war criminal by the faithful execution of these duties."

A hearing on Cook's request is set for Thursday morning.
Tags:
Barack Obama ,
birth ,
birth certificate ,
soldier ,
Afghanistan ,
Stefan Frederick Cook ,
Alan Keyes
Topics:
The Off Beat
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 100 Comments
by g_not_g July 29, 2009 8:10 AM EDT
What passport did Mr. Obama use to travel to Pak?
Reply to this comment
by JJJJackson July 28, 2009 2:22 PM EDT
When campaining he claimed he was born in Queen's hospital, but now he says he was born in Kapi'olani hospital, 49 years old and doesn't know where he was born? We cannot trust him to tell the truth on a simple matter of where he was born - and we are going to trust his ObamaCare program with our lives? What is wrong with this picture? This is Chicago Politics at it's best!
Reply to this comment
by JJJJackson July 28, 2009 1:05 PM EDT
I believe he has a short form - do not need to be born in HI for this. The question is "What Hospital and who was the delivery doctor and attending staff?" Hospital records should be available for this? Maybe not in HI but available in Kenya? Why do we know more about Palin's family and the proposed impriorities than we know about the Commander in Chief????? Is this the change to believe in?
Reply to this comment
by armywife84 July 25, 2009 8:16 AM EDT
First off let me say that I can see the truth and passion in both sides of this argument but let me say that it is completely ridiculous to believe that Obama was not thoroughly checked during the campaigning considering he was called a terrorist then.

What people need to understand is that there are different ways to prove one's citizenship. The big point that is being argued is that he hasn't produced a long copy birth record and I know that one is not needed to prove your citizenship. Other than the fact that the State of Hawaii has declared that all hard copies were destroyed in 2001 I have an example. My husband is currently stationed overseas in Korea and unfortunately due to a problematic pregnancy we were forced to have our daughter in a Korean hospital. She was not born on American soil so we had to go through steps to declare her a citizen and because of that she does not have the normal birth records other babies would have. Would you argue that she is not a natural born citizen due to that? Of course not, she is white child born into an ideal American family. People need to get out of their mind that Obama is a black man with Muslim family members, in the Oval office and concentrate on how is trying to fix our country.

I agree that the tax increase is unfair but he isn't the one who put us in deficit and he isn't the only one who decided it, he needs congressional support. Furthermore, Obama is not the President who addressed the country declaring war. As a military spouse I believe it is our duty to support any decision made by all of our Presidents- past, present, and future. Somewhere along the line this soldier has lost sight of why he took the oath, however I won't judge him, military life is hard. Don't condemn a good man who has served a good career and fought the good fight just because he made one bad decision fueled by a finicky, childish media.
Reply to this comment
by ericjohnvillalobos July 18, 2009 8:32 PM EDT
SHOW ME A DEMONCRAP AND I'LL SHOW YOU A CROOK
Reply to this comment
by ericjohnvillalobos July 18, 2009 8:21 PM EDT
WHAT YOU CANNOT SEE IS OBAMA'S TRANSPARENCY
WHAT YOU CANNOT SEE IS OBAMA'S TRANSPARENCY
WHAT YOU CANNOT SEE IS OBAMA'S TRANSPARENCY
Reply to this comment
by ladypirate2 July 20, 2009 4:35 PM EDT
I see it very clearly! I just wish everyone else could! In fact I wish they had seen through him before the election! He is deceiver and he has the whole nation deceived! I think soon, though, his true identity and self will begin to be evident and people will see what he really is and they will regret voting for him.
by wjneill July 17, 2009 12:26 AM EDT
Cook should be sent to Afghanistan immediately as a PVT E-1 and upon arrival, handed to the Taliban in exchange for the real American soldier they are holding and threatening to murder. At the very least, Cook might be able to atone for his scurrilous conduct because he has willfully compromised his citizenship, personal integrity, and oath to uphold and defend the Constitution.
-
And he oughta take his ding bat lawyer with him because she's a professional loser at this particular game. Maybe she'll find more favor with the Taliban than she has so far with any US court, particularly the Supreme Court. A dentist practicing law with a computer-generated degree. Ain't America great?
-
Even CG SOUTHCOM has stated he doesn't want this piece of fecal matter serving in his command area because he cannot be trusted and he is unfit for service. And the govt pulled his security clearance for the same reason, no less than they did for Jonathan Pollard.
-
Whatta loser. Just like Ollie North, a convicted criminal.
Reply to this comment
by mandmarndt July 22, 2009 11:54 AM EDT
Substitute the name of Cook with Obama and I think you make good sense
by liberalrapture July 16, 2009 8:58 PM EDT
This article - like many others in the Main stream media state that Obama produced a birth certificate. This is simply not true. Obama produced an ABSTRACT. This abstract even says that it is an abstract. A long Form birth certificate has never been produced by Obama or any of his people.

Please stop misleading people on this basic fact.
Reply to this comment
by old1oncnet July 16, 2009 12:13 AM EDT
Cook & Tiatz are now national heroes. If Cook can be allowed to disregard an order because the military does not want to challenge the eligibility of the Magic "0", what next? Can every men and woman in the military refuse any order given by any officer in the military by simply stating that we have no legal acting Commander in Chief? How do you keep order when no one is legally in charge? This is either the start of the solution to the illegal President problem or the end to the American Military Machine. I think it is time for the SCOTUS to finally take a look at our ?President's? hidden past and standing as a British Citizen from Birth. The 6 worst months in American history may well be close to an end.
Reply to this comment
by cjh1452000 July 15, 2009 9:56 PM EDT
It'll be a great day when the Satanic Communist Muslim is forced to show his real documentation. Who knows what his past is really like. I think we've all been lied to, people. Flame if you want, but something evil is swallowing up this world and this man is the apex of this reality.
Reply to this comment
by mattcat25 July 15, 2009 1:38 PM EDT
what? a troop doesn't support the troops???
Reply to this comment
by July 15, 2009 12:59 PM EDT
The only "proof" offered by Barry Soetoro (or the Obama campaign) has been an incompetently doctored JPG computer image of what purports to be a Hawaii "Certification of Live Birth" (COLB), a document which is *not* a birth certificate, and which can be issued to anyone resident in the State of Hawaii whether they were born there or not.

Indeed, one source stipulates that the doctored JPG image in question was drawn not from a COLB issued to Mr. Soetoro but rather to his maternal half-sister, Maya Soetoro-Ng, who was born in Djakarta, Indonesia. That COLB was apparently used as the template from which the forgery was devised.

See http://polarik.blogtownhall.com/ for further information (in grinding detail) on the nature of the forged COLB and how it was foisted upon our nation.

No real, stamped and signed Hawaii State utterance of any kind - COLB or birth certificate - has ever been submitted to a competent forensics document examiner regarding the "natural born" citizen status of the individual who unlawfully holds the office of President of these United States.

We've got us a "Nixon Moment" in the works, folks.

And just like Richard Milhouse, Barry really *is* a crook.
Reply to this comment
by mainer501 July 15, 2009 12:46 PM EDT
Seems Maj Cook has had his orders rescinded! Maybe NO one has to go to Canada to avoid the war.
Reply to this comment
by bruce22980 July 15, 2009 11:20 AM EDT
I think that if Obama really wanted to be transparent he would simply post his real "LONG FORM" birth certificate rather than this certificate of live birth that anyone could have applied for after a birth...A certificate of live birth means nothing...

I approve this solder and his brave stand and no one should do anything till Obama PROVES he is qualified to fill this office. Until then he is just RESIDENT OBAMA
Reply to this comment
by Tommygun21 July 15, 2009 11:00 AM EDT
I believe that this soldier is a patriot in every sense of the word.

I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic

He is merely upholding his oath not that most libs know anything about an oath, how can you when most don't believe in God, so who could you be promising??...yourself?
Reply to this comment
by Tommygun21 July 15, 2009 10:54 AM EDT
Typical liberal responses, ignore the facts insult the ones who present the facts and put on you tin foil hat to keep from hearing the truth. The fact is that the "Live" Birth Certificate has not been provided this is the one that will definitively show where he was born. McCain had to show his because he was actually born in Panama, but on a US military base, thus electable. Look into it if you don't believe me please don't take my word for it. God Bless!
Reply to this comment
by Tommygun21 July 15, 2009 10:52 AM EDT
Typical liberal responses, ignore the facts insult the ones who present the facts and put on you tin foil hat to keep from hearing the truth. The fact is that the "Live" Birth Certificate has not been provided this is the one that will definitively show where he was born. McCain had to show his because he was actually born in Panama, but on a US military base, thus electable. Look into it if you don't believe me please don't take my word for it. God Bless!
Reply to this comment
by weeeniecbs July 15, 2009 10:35 AM EDT
CBS you suck, you lie and misrepresent. At least you acknowleged the issue even though you distort the entire story. Obama's birth certificate HAS NOT BEEN RELEASED a certificate of live birth has. As far as the "repeatedly debunked" all the Obama mouth pieces that want this to go away (like the Annenberg foundation and Kieth Oberman) don't qulify as debunking. We know nothing of this president, he is hiding almost all of his records. WHY?
Reply to this comment
by seagal76 July 15, 2009 10:33 AM EDT
Soldier needs to get on the plane with the rest of his unit and do his job! This is just an excuse to not deploy. Why did you enlist just to shirk your duty?
Reply to this comment
by ColleenBen July 15, 2009 10:19 AM EDT
About cs4466.

This is the sort of person who did vote for Obama. There are a few backers of this person's way of thinking on here as well.
The comments, some quite disgusting, really should be ignored because it is obvious that the name calling, putting down other peoples religion, is a sign of an intellectually challenged person.
All who even waste their time replying to this person's comments, in reality, should ignore this person. Responding with hate back, feeds this sort of person.
The truth is, there is no actual birth certificate of Obama's birth.
None.
I am not sure why this soldier is doing what he is, but I can tell you that I am VERY GLAD that it is now, finally, making national headlines.It is up to all of us, who want to know the truth, to keep this quest alive.
We know VERY LITTLE about this man. This man was chosen long before he announced his candidacy by George Soros and all those who follow behind him with the hope of a New World Order. The masses then were led by words only. Thankfully, not all of us and the numbers are increasing.Who is this man?
New World Order has many different meanings, in fact different in each country.
It all boils down to all us stupid meaningless people are not worthy or smart enough to govern our own lives.
This is what is happening. It must be stopped and we will stop it. One Must first recognize this "Network" and then join in and fight against it...with intelligence.
This 'Network' can only be broken apart by the people. PLEASE, all of you who do understand what is going on, type in 'March on DC 2009'.
Not into such a thing? I can only tell you it does work. It has always worked. Those who are running for office in 2010 will see the vast amount of people saying "no" and things will begin to change. I am a child of the 60's..WE THE PEOPLE are the ones who brought the end to the Vietnam war.
So, you can sit back and do nothing...maybe write a blog or on a forum which will not change a thing.Not a chance.
I am a 58 year old woman..must I do it for you? I can't. You must all participate and yes, it will work. I had and have my success in this country, things are looking dim for all of you now.
Are you a winner? Be a part of history and be known as one who gave up some of your time to change things. I have been in around 30 plus countries. I have watched socialism grow in many of them. I have seen the people become more and more unhappy. Poor medical and many times taxed over and over for things they do not even know about or why. They have lost their right to know.
Is this what you want?
If not..stop it....because you can and it must be done before their is such a strong hold that you can do nothing. If you are not aware of what is going in in some Western and mid Western European countries, please become informed.
I am not a blind sighted flag wagging redneck, as the ignorant may call all those who can see what is happening. I have had great success and I have seen much. Does it make me any smarter...NO.
Does it make me more aware as to what is happening...YES.
With all it's warts, this country, our freedom as individuals, must be fought for..through intelligence, through marching and through not ever worshiping a god like figure as many Obama followers have done. This is how Hitler came into power. He came along at just the right moment.
Thank you for your time. Please look up about the March in DC. It is just the beginning. It is also all about doing everything peacefully and intelligently.
Please spread the word and I am counting on all of you. I have had my great days..I am worried about all of you. I also have many great days ahead, because I believe in all of you and especially those who can or are beginning to see through Obama and even more...all his backers who put him where he is.
Let's Roll.
Reply to this comment
by RadsRinCharge July 15, 2009 10:51 AM EDT
ColleenBen: I am with you, and yes I know about the march. Sept. 12, DC. If these people want to know what Congress and BO are doing, go look at some of the bills being passed which are taking away our freedoms...the Hate Crimes bill, protecting gays which is actually attacking the bible...Cap and trade, which will raise your taxes by #3,000 a year per family....a bill which takes away where you want your child to attend school at...and we do not want the health care to pass. Our country cannot afford it and we are tired of not having a voice. It is our tax dollars being wasted. Oh and do you want to support a "national muslim day" while our national day of prayer is not being honored? There's a whole lot more if you go do some research on the internet or talk shows. Do not even attempt to let the mainstream media fill you in, it is a bunch of lies. Our Country is is distress.
by krockenbach July 15, 2009 5:17 PM EDT
cs4466 is not one person it's a group and i'm suprised they wouldn't like seeing BO displaced as then he would be free to tour, and write book they could buy. Would Nacy Pelosi become President or Biden? cs4466 willtry to argue it is a single person but can't. Wait here come the ridicule.
See all 100 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
HOTSHEET ON TWITTER