Reaction to measure requiring ID cards to show sex assigned at birth

Reaction to measure requiring ID cards to show sex assigned at birth

MIAMI - In an 11-4 vote, the Florida House Select Committee on Health Innovation voted in favor of House Bill 1639, a piece of legislation that would require transgender people to list their birth sex on their state ID's.

"Let's be genuine, who cares if gender or sex is listed on a driver's license? It's simply handed over for identity purposes," said Scott Galvin, Executive Director of Safe Schools South Florida.

The bill also requires health care providers to cover de-transition care and therapies that "treat a person's perception that his or her sex is inconclusive with such person's sex at birth,"

"There is just a small percentage of trans people that do detransition only to retransition again, there's a lot of scientific evidence on that, so once again — the point of these bills aren't new — it's very clear that they're targeted against a specific marginalized community," said Franchesca D'Amore, board member of Safe Schools South Florida.

When I requested to interview the bill's sponsor, Republican Representative Doug Bankson from Apopka, he instead told me in a statement, he called the bill the "Compassion and Clarity Bill," saying it was created to address two main points: to "make sure those suffering with gender dysphoria have an equal path to pursue personal wholeness through insurance coverage; Second, to bring clarity to identification purposes for state documents," 

He went on to say:

"The original intent of the statute was understood to mean sex at birth which is also very important in the event of a medical emergency. This bill aligns the language to match other state statutes concerning into biological sex,"

Opponents of the bill, like Franchesca Damore, a transgender woman, say if this bill is passed, it's going to put her and other transgender people in a difficult situation.

"It's going to affect me greatly — I think it's also going to cause a lot of psychological stress for my community who's already marginalized as it is," said D'Amore.

Other supporters of the LGBTQ+ community say lawmakers are wasting their time targeting transgender people when the state is facing bigger issues.

"There are a lot more important issues like homeowners' insurance that I feel legislators need to be focused on," said Galvin.

If House Bill 1639 is signed into law, the legislation will take effect on July 1.

Read more
f

We and our partners use cookies to understand how you use our site, improve your experience and serve you personalized content and advertising. Read about how we use cookies in our cookie policy and how you can control them by clicking Manage Settings. By continuing to use this site, you accept these cookies.