Why Won't Men Commit?

Fireworks explode over the United States flag Friday, July 3, 2009, after the Hutchinson Monarchs baseball game in Hutchinson, Kan. AP/Travis Morisse, Hutchinson News

The Early Show explores the new findings from the study, "Why Men Won't Commit: Exploring Young Men's Attitudes About Sex, Dating and Marriage," and examines the social health of marriage in America with the co-author.

Featured on the National Marriage Project's annual report, the study is based on eight focus groups with 60 single men between the ages of 25 to 33 in four metropolitan areas: northern New Jersey, Chicago, Washington, D.C., and Houston. Researchers explored men’s attitudes on sex, dating, meeting women, living together, marrying a soul mate, the timing of marriage, social pressures to marry, divorce, desire for children and about balancing a job and having a family.

The purpose, according to Barbara Dafoe Whitehead, co-director of the National Marriage Project at Rutgers University, is to answer what she calls, the perennial question from women, "Why are men fearful of committing?"

She says, "We wanted to talk to men because very often, they are the neglected ones in this whole debate."

The most common reasons that young men aren't committing according to the study:
  • They face few social pressures to marry.
  • They are more willing to live together than marry.
  • They can get sex more easily without marriage.
  • They want to avoid the financial fall-out of divorce.
  • They are waiting for the perfect soul mate.
  • They fear that marriage will require too many changes and compromises.
  • They want to delay having children.
  • They are reluctant to marry a woman who already has children.
  • They want to own a house before they get a wife.
  • They want to enjoy single life as long as they can.

The study observes that there are no big social pressures on men to marry.

"There use to be and you can debate if it was good or not," says Whitehead. "There were family pressures and the idea you would be a more responsible employee and the peer pressure that people tended to marry before 25. In 1960, half of all single men were married by 25 and the rest followed shortly thereafter. Now, the median age of entry into a first marriage for men is 27. For college-educated men, it tends to be a little later than that. The rule of thumb is about a year to a year and a half after the median age."

Young men also don't marry as much because there are many more couples living together than in the past. Whitehead says that they are either living together before they get married or as an alternative to marriage — which is very new.

A lot of survey and census data show that women are living with their boyfriends first, rather than with a husband. It's part of trying out to see if it will work.

"When people live together, women see it as a progress toward marriage. Men see it as something they are happy with indefinitely,” says Whitehead.

“Half of all co-habitating relationships turn into marriage. One of the things we find is that the guys really like this and they don't see the need to move forward. They get a lot of the same benefits and they also feel free to keep looking. And they say this."

A lot of these young men also said they would prefer living with someone to marrying the woman because they knew if they got married and divorced, she would take a lot from them. The researcher called this fear of the "pocketbook risk."

Whitehead gives the following tips for women looking for a commitment:


  • They should have a basic knowledge about these trend changes and factor them in when making decisions about their relationship.

  • There needs to be social occasions, other than bars and clubs, for men and women to meet each other. Friends and family can help by having barbecues and other get-togethers and inviting singles. Whitehead says that these parties should be multi-generational.

  • Even though people are living far away from their parents, it turns out that what parents think does matter. Whitehead has friends who told their son that he wasn't being fair to keep his live-in girlfriend waiting to get married so long and to make up his mind.

  • The reality is that people are sexually active while they are single. The question is not whether to have sex, but to think about when, with whom and how quickly.

  • Rome Neal

Comments