The Office's Michael Scott: His 6 Worst Management Moments

Last Updated Apr 28, 2011 8:43 AM EDT

Steve Carell, aka Michael Scott, will exit The Office on Thursday, April 28. While Will Ferrell has made a terrific temporary replacement as branch manager, I'm sad about Carell's character leaving. Michael Scott has been an inspiring TV icon -- of how not to lead a staff. He's the quintessential bad TV boss and I have enjoyed following his follies. Here are some of my favorite examples of his lousy leadership skills. Thanks to Steve Carell for the laughs -- and the lessons.

Management Mistake #1: Making HR The Enemy Throughout the series, Michael made it clear he had no respect for "stupid Toby" and pitted himself and the rest of the staff versus the human relations department. In reality, teaming with HR makes good managerial sense, since they can help you communicate better with employees -- and also document any issues, which can benefit management in the event of a firing or a sexual harassment lawsuit.
Management Mistake #2: Trying To Be The Most Popular Man In The Office Michael bribed his employees with liquor, ice cream, and movies in the conference room. But if you're after affection, better to find some love at the local animal shelter rather than seeking it at work. Part of being a manager is making tough decisions that people don't want to hear -- and it's impossible to do that and be perpetually popular at the same time.
Management Mistake #3: Taking Friendly To A Whole New Level When a fellow employee insulted Phyllis, Michael tries to show her that she's beautiful -- and crosses the line not only physically but also verbally. This makes for one hilarious moment for television -- and some lawyers a whole lot of money if it were to happen in real life.
Management Mistake #4: Indiscreetly Dating a Colleague The office can be a great place to meet a potential partner -- you already have one common interest -- but please, do it discreetly. When Michael started dating Jan, he acted like Tom Cruise jumping on Oprah's coach when he was psychotically psyched to be sharing his love for Katie Holmes. Eventually, respect for Jan at the executive level declined and she was forced out of her powerful position. Sadly, what happened to Jan was one of the more realistic plot lines in the entire show.
Management Mistake #5: Being Culturally Insensitive While Michael's bumbling over PC protocol with Stanley was a laugh for viewers, this type of banter in real life would be hurtful and likely litigious. Ditto for Michael's never-ending ribbing of Oscar for being gay.
Management Mistake #6: Avoiding Confrontation And Playing Games When Dwight attempts a power play for Michael's job by secretly meeting with Jan, Michael catches him in a lie about a dental appointment. But instead of confronting him immediately, he toys with Dwight before eventually exposing his fib. Most managers would argue that they don't have time for games -- and they're right.
While all of these clips seem outrageous, real-life bosses make similar management mistakes every day. After Thursday, we'll have to see if Will Ferrell gives us some new laughs -- and lessons.

What's your favorite Michael Scott moment? Have you ever had a boss like him? Please sign in below and share them.
Follow MWOnTheJob on Twitter
More on MoneyWatch:
  • Amy Levin-Epstein On Twitter»

    Amy Levin-Epstein is a freelance writer who has been published in dozens of magazines (including Glamour, Self and Redbook), websites (including AOLHealth.com, Babble.com and Details.com) and newspapers (including The New York Post and the Boston Globe). To read more of her writing, visit AmyLevinEpstein.com.

Comments

CBSN Live

pop-out
Live Video

Market Data

Watch CBSN Live

Watch CBS News anytime, anywhere with the new 24/7 digital news network. Stream CBSN live or on demand for FREE on your TV, computer, tablet, or smartphone.

Market News

Stock Watchlist