Symbol Of Shame?

Spc. Lynndie R. England, from the 372nd Military Police Company U.S. Army Reserve Center in Cumberland, Md., is shown in an undated photo displayed Friday, April 30, 2004, on the LaVale, Md., Wal-Mart's 'Wall of Honor' with more than 30 other photos of local men and women currently serving or retired from the U.S. military. AP

Army Pfc. Lynndie England, 21, the woman shown in photographs smiling and pointing at naked Iraqi prisoners, has been charged by the military with conspiring to mistreat detainees and other crimes.

Pictures of England and other Americans humiliating and degrading naked Iraqi detainees have sparked an international outcry over the U.S. military's handling of war prisoners.

In one photo from Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad, England is shown standing making a thumbs-up gesture behind a pyramid of naked Iraqi men; in another, cigarette dangling from her lips, she points to a hooded and naked prisoner.

A third photo shows her leading around a naked Iraqi prisoner by a leash that is tied to his neck.

But family and friends of the Army reservist, a member of the 372nd Military Police Company based in Cumberland, Md., defend her and say she is being scapegoated by the military.

"I'm proud of my daughter," England's mother, Terrie England, told CBS News Correspondent Thalia Assuras. "She is not herself in them. It's like it's staged."

England's sister, Jessica Klinestiver, echoed that sentiment at a Friday press briefing in Fort Ashby, W. Va.

"Yes, I am very proud of my sister. I'm behind my sister and anybody else that's in the 372nd," said Klinevester, adding, "I think you're using her as a scapegoat. They're just picking on her."

A close family friend, Destiny Goin, said she believes the photos "were posed. I don't believe Lynndie would actually being doing the actions that you see in the photos. It's not like her to be like that, she's a caring person."

Terrie England says her daughter was just following orders, afraid she would get in trouble if she didn't go along.

"She told me, 'They told us to do whatever you have to do in order to get them to talk,'" says Terrie England. "She took orders. I mean she had questioned them to other soldiers with her but like the others said, 'Yeah, we just follow orders.'"

Spc. England frequently visited another soldier in the military police unit, Sgt. Charles Graner. A onetime Pennsylvania prison guard, there are published reports Graner had a history of domestic violence.

CBS News has been told that England and Graner, both divorced, were involved in a romantic relationship in Iraq and that England is pregnant.

Unlike six other 372nd members, England has not been charged, but she is being detained at Fort Bragg, N.C.

Many residents of this rural, one-stoplight, Mineral County town about 10 miles south of the Maryland border are wary of the media. But those who do talk express revulsion for the stories of abuse.

"Those people should pay for their actions," said William McGregor, 61, who retired as a master sergeant after 25 years in the Marine Corps, including two tours in Vietnam. "They had enough training to know right from wrong, and what they did was wrong."

In his hometown of Uniontown, Pa., Graner's friend Thomas Zavada is more forgiving.

"We're at war. We don't know the pressures," Zavada says, "being away from home. There's a lot of guys that could be in that position if the occasion arises."

Meantime, England's mother fears her daughter has become a scapegoat.

"She stood up for her country and she will stand up for her country no matter what. She feels like she's been let down," Terrie England says.
  • Joel Roberts

Comments