In his closely read annual letter to shareholders, published Saturday, Warren Buffett offered new insight into his choice of successor, reaffirmed his long-term confidence in the U.S. economy and stock market, and predicted an eventual, and possibly dramatic, upturn in the real estate market.
The most useful information in the letter is Buffett's insight into the market, which we'll detail below, but there was also some news.
Buffett announced he had chosen a successor as CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, although he declined to name him. Buffett is 81, his partner Charlie Munger is 88, and some market watchers believe their advanced ages have weighed on Berkshire's share price. Shares declined 4.7 percent last year, compared with a
Buffett had previously acknowledged there were three leading candidates for the top job at Berkshire (BRK), but now he has narrowed it down to one. Buffettolgists will be buzzing over clues in his latest letter. Chief among them: He writes that the two money managers he hired in the past year -- Todd Combs and Ted Weschler -- "will be helpful to the next CEO of Berkshire in making acquisitions." In other words, neither of them will be the boss.
One manager who Buffett singles out for particularly heaping praise is Ajit Jain, who runs Berkshire's reinsurance group, arguably the core of the $200 billion company (Berkshire's market value is roughly equal to Google). Buffett says Jain has added many billions of dollars of value to Berkshire, and that Munger "would gladly trade me for a second Ajit. Alas, there is none."
Berkshire announced fourth quarter financial results Saturday as well. The company's net income of $3.05 billion fell short of analysts expectations, and was well below year ago results of $4.4 billion. The shortfall was mostly due to paper losses in the company's dervative portfolio, but also because of weakness in its housing holdings and underwriting losses in its insurance group. Buffett's preferred measure of success -- book value of Berkshire's holdings -- climbed 4.6 percent.
True to form, Buffett diverges from the standard CEO playbook and devotes a chunk of his letter to detailing his 2011 mistakes. For starters, he kicks himself for buying bonds of of Energy Future Holdings, an electric utility in Texas. He writes that "the company's prospects were tied to the price of natural gas, which tanked shortly after our purchase." Buffett hasn't had great success in the energy sector; he bought ConocoPhillips when oil and gas prices were near their high in 2008.
He also notes that in last year's letter he predicted a housing recovery would have begun by now. "I was dead wrong," he writes. That said, he still believes his only error was timing: The U.S. is creating households faster than it's building houses, he reasons, so eventually supply will outstrip demand and the market will snap back, reducing unemployment and goosing the economy.
Many people look for wisdom, rather than news, in Buffett's annual letter, and he came through:
- Buffett warns investors away from supposedly "safe" investments such as gold and bonds, in favor of "productive assets" such as stocks, farmland and real estate.
Explaining his aversion to bonds, which have historically low-yields right now, he quotes the late investor Shelby Cullom Davis describing bonds as offering "return-free risk." While your principal may be guaranteed, you are also guaranteed to lose purchasing power to inflation, Buffett explains. That doesn't mean you shouldn't own some bonds or cash as a shock absorber or emergency fund, but don't expect to build wealth.
- Buffett seems particularly scornful of gold, one a class of assets that will never produce anything, but that are purchased in the buyer's hope that someone else - who also knows that the assets will be forever unproductive - will pay more for them in the future." Buffett acknowledges that the trade has worked for the past decade as investors became ever more fearful of other assets, but the bubble will eventually pop, he believes.
- Ever the contrarian, Buffett also makes a case for owning good stocks that are declining value. In the case where a company is buying back shares (as Berkshire holding IBM is doing now), he reasons, investors will find their share of the company, and its earnings, increasing. Another way to think about it: If you are putting money in stocks every two weeks via your 401(k), a falling market is a good thing since you are getting more shares for your money. Eventually, of course, you'll want to sell, but better to have a furious rally once you've got a decent accumulation in your account.
The logic is simple: If you are going to be a net buyer of stocks in the future, either directly with your own money or indirectly (through your ownership of a company that is repurchasing shares), you are hurt when stocks rise. You benefit when stocks swoon. Emotions, however, too often complicate the matter: Most people, including those who will be net buyers in the future, take comfort in seeing stock prices advance. These shareholders resemble a commuter who rejoices after the price of gas increases, simply because his tank contains a day's supply.So if the market keeps us waiting a while longer for Dow 13,000, look on the bright side.