Political Hotsheet
September 3, 2009 11:47 AM

Conservatives Revolt Over Obama Speech to Students

(AP)
Next Tuesday at noon, President Obama will be delivering what the White House is billing as "a national address to the students of America."

"During this special address, the president will speak directly to the nation’s children and youth about persisting and succeeding in school," according to Education Secretary Arne Duncan. "The president will challenge students to work hard, set educational goals, and take responsibility for their learning."

The Department of Education encouraged teachers to build lesson plans around the speech and offered "educators a menu of classroom activities…to help engage students in the address and stimulate classroom discussions about the importance of education."

The Department also recommended that students be asked to write a letter to themselves on "how to help the president."

All this did not sit well with Jim Greer, the chairman of the Florida Republican Party. Greer released a blistering statement earlier this week claiming that the president is trying to "indoctrinate America's children to his socialist agenda."

"The idea that school children across our nation will be forced to watch the President justify his plans for government-run health care, banks, and automobile companies, increasing taxes on those who create jobs, and racking up more debt than any other President, is not only infuriating, but goes against beliefs of the majority of Americans, while bypassing American parents through an invasive abuse of power," he said.

Added Greer: "President Obama has turned to American's children to spread his liberal lies, indoctrinating American's youngest children before they have a chance to decide for themselves."

Some conservatives began to suggest that students hold their children back from school: Politico notes that conservative talk show host Tammy Bruce pushed on Twitter for followers to "Make September 8 Parentally Approved Skip Day. You are your child's moral tutor, not that shady lawyer from Chicago." Conservative radio host Dana Loesch also pressed parents to keep their children out of school Tuesday.

In response to the uproar, the White House has now altered its recommendations. The recommendation that students write a paper on how to help Mr. Obama has been changed to one urging teachers to have them "write letters to themselves about how they can achieve their short-term and long-term education goals," as the Washington Times reports.

Other language was also tweaked: a suggested question for older students, for example, was changed from "What is President Obama inspiring you to do?" to “Is President Obama inspiring you to do anything?"

White House spokesman Tommy Vietor told the Times that there would not have been such an angry reaction from some quarters had people actually heard the speech, which he said is focused exclusively encouraging children to stay in school and work hard, not policy or political issues.

A White House official acknowledged to the newspaper that some of the initial recommendations from the Department may not have been worded as carefully as they should have been, particularly as it was not yet known exactly what the president planned to say.
Tags:
Obama ,
Education ,
Arne Duncan ,
Students ,
Speech ,
Jim Greer
Topics:
In The News
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 176 Comments
by Cole_D September 8, 2009 6:14 PM EDT
I hope to get a lot of controversy from this statement, and that is why I am going to make it. If communism is going to work anywhere, then it would be in the United States. It's undeniable that the concept makes for one of the best possible governments, and I think that communism isn't bad per se, it is a failed communistic government that we don't want. I am in no way saying that Obama is trying to push us toward communism, I'm just saying that using it as an insult makes you seem a little uninformed.
By the way, I hope that all you parents who wanted to keep your kids away from our poisonous President read the speech. He specifically says to listen to your parents. Nowhere does he mention reporting your parents if they don't agree with him.
Reply to this comment
by hesyw00 September 8, 2009 4:42 PM EDT
I've read through most of the comments posted and definitely agree that this has a terrible outlook for adults (used loosely) from our youth. It is really a sad day when you get people (left or right) to use their children as sitting ducks in the water. These children should not know hate in such early stages in their lives. But that's how the cycle of hate continues. The people who chose to opt out or keep their kids at home today. ??? What type of message did you send to your kids, when you did this? How do you explain to them that the PRESIDENT is speaking today and I don't want you to listen? OK, keep him/her out, but don't you realize they will talk about it when they get to school. So, did you clearly explain to your kids, how to respond to discussions about staying in school or what goals do you have in life, what do you want to be or the PRESIDENT SAID, we can be anything we want if we study hard. This is what the kids will be talking about. NOT healthcare, tort reform, security issue in America. Come on you guys, we have to do better at parenting and showing respect to AUTHORITY. YOU MAY NOT LIKE IT, BUT OBAMA IS IN AUTHORITY OF AMERICA. (With the exception being GOD)

Also,I agree with Mrromeo113, I noticed the individuals who posted comments that disagreed on the President?s speech; you guys really need to watch how you post comments. There are sooooo many misused sentence structures in your writings. I?m not sure if your children should have stayed home, if you are having trouble with English. Sorry the stab, but I can?t stand it when people can?t form a proper sentence or the proper usage of words.
Reply to this comment
by Sweetpea2207 September 8, 2009 3:30 PM EDT
I just finished reading the President's speech and anyone who had any objections to children hearing this speech should be ashamed of themselves. As I am ashamed of how we are so color/political party driven that we disagree because of that alone. We tune each other completely out based on these issues and it is so sad. I sometimes feel that other countries look at us and how we handle our differences and say "those stupid Americans, why don't they not get it".

People we need to start looking at our "similarities" and stop focusing on "differences" and perhaps it won't be so difficult to come up with a healthcare plan.
Reply to this comment
by ericgarrison September 8, 2009 1:30 PM EDT
This agenda is truly the most pathetic I've ever seen offered by the GOP.
Reply to this comment
by angeegirl September 8, 2009 1:06 AM EDT
It amazes me to see what parents can do to rob their child's opportunity to think freely. To put your child's mind in a box is exactly what these parents are doing when they keep their child home from school for fear that the President of our country may corupt their minds and politicize thier classrooms. This is hypocritical and goes against the very same ethics that these "dictorial" parents are claiming to be standing for. What an amazing opportunity these children have. To be spoken to by the president. These children aren't going to remember the policies but rather the voice that they have. The president's message is to give these children a voice and let them feel that they can be involved and make changes if they choose. This is a true democracy. These conservatists are standing in the way of their own movement.
Reply to this comment
by truthwillsetyoufree1 September 7, 2009 9:09 PM EDT
I have read the speach .Saw nothing bad in it. Its not what our pres. says.Its how he will say it . He is using a type of hypnotic speak ,invented by a german Doc.The same as Hitler used.It works best w/the young and the old, but if you listen to long can snare anyone w/ago along kind of mind set.It is our duty as american's to speak out when we disagree w/ what our Gov. is doing.Don't like the war then speak out .Don't like Pres. Bush then speak out.This is not racism or biogty or crazy or a freak show you,me,we are not morons or feeble-minded.We are all americans. I sat back for eight years and listened to hate speak about Pres. Bush.There are lots of books about how to kill him when he was in office.WOW' now thats alot of hate for one man to live with. I have prayed for all my Pres.including Pres Obama and his family.I hope and pray that just like Pres. Obama said ,WE can disagree w/out being disagreable.After all that is the American way,and what far to many have died for.Together we (all of us)can make it better. GOD BLESS all of you. GOD BLESS AMERICA.
Reply to this comment
by whybs September 7, 2009 7:06 PM EDT
Let's all chill out & have a beer before we speak!

Let's hear what Laura Bush says about Obama's school speech!

http://twitter.com/whybs/status/3826456874

Obama should make her his honorary adviser to help heal this nation from further divisiveness!

Cole D, BTW, Biden had a Buckler Non-Alcoholic drink during the infamous WH beer meeting! And as a Brown grad, I highly recommend it -- if you could get in! There are a few good profs there! Good luck in school, question everything (religion/politics/etc.) & keep learning! :)
Reply to this comment
by kathrowe September 6, 2009 5:57 PM EDT
I'm flabbergasted that anyone could object to the President's encouraging children to stay in school and do their best to be successful. Isn't personal responsibility for bettering one's life what America is all about? Isn't it all about individual achievement? There's nothing socialist about that. I can't wrap my mind around the mentality of those who would condemn President Obama for trying to inspire children to do their best. It's insane. Perhaps Joe Six-Pack and the Missus have had one six-pack too many!
Reply to this comment
by ducdebrabant September 6, 2009 12:00 PM EDT
I never thought I?d see the day when parents would demand a President of the United States be barred from addressing their children. Because our current President is of another party (and, in some cases, because he is of African descent), he is now being treated as, immoral, villainous, toxic and alien. It will surely not be lost on African-Americans that a new precedent is being set for our first African-American President. Speaking as a Democrat, I have never in my life dreamed of treating any Republican President like a drug pusher or sex offender simply for offering to speak to schoolchildren. It is the height of impudence that any President?s remarks be ?screened? by parent-ideologues of the other party, by tendentious teachers or school administrators. That any teacher, principal, school board, municipality or state should take part in this outrage is nothing less than a scandal. I rarely use this term, but there is no other term for it: is un-American.
Reply to this comment
by r9119111 September 6, 2009 1:17 AM EDT
The party of NO haa apent more money saying "NO" than Obama has spent to save our broken economy. Obama is simply trying to encourage our children to stay in school and try harder. Nutjobs are hitting him from every angle. What would you rather have him do? Would you rather have him say, "Stay out of school, you're not learning anything anyway." What horible examples some misguided parents are especially if they listen to the Republican "NO" line of BS.
Reply to this comment
by hightime1 September 6, 2009 12:34 AM EDT
Usually whenever people resort to name calling and other forms of virulent comments, they no actual facts to back up what they are saying. People of goodwill have their eyes wide open and they can easily detect those who use fear and hatred to prove their points.
Reply to this comment
by troutfishyman September 5, 2009 10:52 PM EDT
LOL!

Conservatives are "outraged" that Obama will somehow brainwash their children. Which is kinda amusing, considering the typical conservative has already done this through a strange institution called "Sunday School".

What, are they afraid their children might finally hear a different point of view?
Reply to this comment
by Ca53y September 5, 2009 11:11 PM EDT
But they have a CHOICE to send their children to Sunday School or not, they do not have a choice on this unless they keep their children home from school, and that is not fair. It should be presented to children in their own homes so that the parents can decide if they want to watch it with them or not. Isn't that the logical compromise?
by FedUp0909 September 5, 2009 10:23 PM EDT
Conservatives are so right on this one.
All of those reading lessons Laura Bush gave to
school children for many years are the cause of
our low test scores, drug use in our school,
our high drop out rates, teen girls having babies.
We really need politicians to stop talking to
our students.
Reply to this comment
by Obamaborg September 5, 2009 9:49 PM EDT
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1l3o4Rf-ny8&feature=PlayList&p=DF2CE045FE395AE3&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=8

Your children have been assimilated...
Reply to this comment
by cdub121 September 5, 2009 7:48 PM EDT
I would like to point out that Cuba only went down that path for political reasons - to get the USSR to be its big brother. Cuba needed the USSR on its side to keep the US's hands off of it. If Fidel how more of his own might at the time, he probably would have gone in another direction. Let's avoid comparing present day US (a much larger country) to little weak Cuba in the mid 20th century. AND - please read Karl Marx & Frederick Engels before you start using the the words "communism" incorrectly. Let's be clear - say "Leninism or Stalinism or Maoism." They are all quite different from one another. All Marx wanted was to help the poor industrial workers of Europe in the 1830s and 40s - where there were no safety conditions and the robber baron industries were capitalizing on the poor and abundance of resources. Marx was hoping to inspire the workers to unite and take over the industries. This "taking over" would mean that everyone in the workplace would own the company and therefore "share the wealth." [Marx never intended an entire country to turn this way - and honestly one could not]. Communism was simply the next step - creating a Utopia. I know that a Utopia is impossible - but is it so bad to hope for a better world? We can't help that dictators in history have tarnished such good intentions. So, PLEASE - when you want to call something socialist or communist - be specific to the version you are referencing in history. Because there are many different attempts at communism in history - but they have all gone wrong and quite terrible. Please be specific - and if you don't really know what you are talking about - look it up and then come back and make an educated reply. That response will gain you respect and people will actually take your words seriously. Thanks.
Reply to this comment
by Pisabonito September 5, 2009 7:00 PM EDT
Mr Obama is going down the path of Cuba. Militia-Acorn, volunteer work, student indoctrination, distribution of wealth, class struggle, seizing of private enterprises this is the dossier of a communist. Sure people should be scare a very painfully aware of the dark and sinister path this administration is leading the country. It is Cuba 2.0
Reply to this comment
by deldomi September 5, 2009 5:56 PM EDT
I really want to do something to let the President know that we (the majority) support him. I also think it's important the those of us who do support him speak out and try to counteract the venemous poison being spewed by the Wacko Right (the minority). If we do not I'm afraid that they will increase their ranks with more people who are not educated. Does anyone know of any organization that wants to fight against this mean spirited, uniformed, craziness?
Reply to this comment
by tayon September 5, 2009 5:29 PM EDT
I think its really ashame an pity when we get so sour that we disrespect the President OF OUR UNITED STATES.At least allow the man to speak as others have done.STOP THE NIT PICKING
Reply to this comment
by jsilver2th September 5, 2009 3:37 PM EDT
I wish they would take their kids out of school- then they will want to watch Obama more than ever because their parents said they shouldn't- plus the other kids will know who the biggots are!
Reply to this comment
by hsanch1 September 5, 2009 3:22 PM EDT
Are we going to blacklist the President of the United States for wanting to try and get students involved in the way the country's government works? Is actually educating children a bad idea? I mean, G-d forbid that we actually tell how things really went in the course of history ... how many people can actually say why we celebrate Labor Day (that's over the age of 45) ... I'm a Social Studies Major with a Minor in History and I had to look that one up ... I don't believe President Obama is going to try and push a socialist agenda; I believe he is just trying to get the students in the United States a better chance of a good education. I'm the product of a public school and my father is a retired school teacher and he often says how appalled he is at how the education system in this country is deteriorating. Instead of jumping the gun and saying that the President is going to preach socialism, maybe we should give him a chance and hear him out ... go to your child's class room and listen to the message and give him a chance before you start name calling; otherwise, you just look like Joe McCarthy.
Reply to this comment
See all 176 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
HOTSHEET ON TWITTER