Political Hotsheet
July 1, 2009 3:08 PM

Obama: Health Care Reform Will Impact All Americans

(AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
When Debby Smith was diagnosed with a second tumor in her kidney, causing her renal failure, she had no way to pay for health care. So she turned to President Obama.

The president comforted the tearful questioner at the health care town hall meeting he held Wednesday at Northern Virginia Community College in Annandale, Va.

"Debby is a perfect example of somebody, in a country this wealthy, we should be able to provide coverage for her health care problems," Mr. Obama said, after hugging Smith. "What we don't want is a situation where Debby gets worse and worse because she's not getting treatment and then goes to the emergency room," raising costs for all taxpayers.

Health care reform will impact every American, the president said.

"If we do not act to bring down costs, everybody's health care will be in jeopardy," he said. "We've got to stop clinging to a broken system that doesn't work."

Mr. Obama repeated his previous assertions that two thirds of his reform proposals could be paid for by re-allocating money already in the system, while one third would be paid for by raising revenues. He indicated he is more open to the idea of taxing health care benefits than he has been in the past.

While Mr. Obama on the campaign trail opposed Sen. John McCain's proposal to eliminate the current tax exclusion for employer-based health benefits, the president pointed out that the debate in Congress is currently about capping -- not eliminating -- the exclusion. For instance, someone with a $17,000 plan may have to pay taxes on the last $4,000.

"This is something that's going to be debated in the House and the Senate," he said. "My bottom line is if you've got health insurance right now, you shouldn't suddenly see your costs go up because of health care reform."

Mr. Obama said as he has before that he would prefer to raise revenues by capping the itemized tax deductions wealthy Americans can make.

The president said the most important thing Americans can do to move health care reform forward is stay informed

"I want everybody to be well enough informed so the scare tactics of those who oppose reform don't work," he said. "When you hear somebody say Obama is proposing a government takeover of health care... I actually think reforming the system is the most likely way for you to keep the health care you've got."

He said that the pressure regular Americans can put on Congress will be effective.

"Those who said we couldn't do it, they're already being surprised," he said, citing examples of progress made so far such as the pharmaceutical industry's agreement to cut the cost of prescription drugs for seniors.

"I am very pleased the drug companies decided to cough up $80 billion to close up this doughnut hole," he said, referring to the gap in coverage the industry has agreed to help pay for.

He added, however, "Were it not for the prospect of serious health reform, they would not have given up that money -- that's just my guess."
Tags:
health care ,
Barack Obama
Topics:
Health Care
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 24 Comments
by CAV123456 July 7, 2009 8:09 PM EDT
I realize change is difficult for everyone. My father is a critical care physician, my aunt is the head nurse of a hospital and I was a CNA now stay at home mom. I have been on both sides of this issue. From the person caring for a patient with minor illness that should have been seen in a Dr.'s office but couldn't afford it, to the mother taking her daughter with a mild feer there for the same reason. I don't know how I feel about Obama's reform (I just haven't had enough time to consider all the pros and cons). I can tell you this, the USA needs to help Americans help America. Every time I or any one else went to the ER for a scrape, bruise, cut, cold, fever, or other non-emergency because it was there only option it hurt the country. Everytime someone will go to their family Dr. for those minor illnesses that still need care will help every American. I'm sure I will be called a TRUE Democrat, or Robin Hood, or what ever name you choose to use define people whom you disagree with. I want you to know I voted republican and I still feel that something DOES need to be done.
Reply to this comment
by AverageJoeLE July 1, 2009 9:24 PM EDT
This is a FRIGHTENING possibility for if ObamaCare fails in its current form. He may force us to take universal healthcare by necessity. http://bit.ly/hNUSy
Reply to this comment
by xlib July 1, 2009 8:07 PM EDT
Hey libtards, carter was bad and you are the lemmings who brought up Bush. As for this jerk, yep, he's making the 70's look good.

But hey, keep drinking the koolaid and never, ever question him. He can't take any criticism at all, can he.
Reply to this comment
by sjc_1 July 1, 2009 6:17 PM EDT
Optional National Health Insurance, private policy, public policy or NO policy at all if you choose.
Reply to this comment
by specialty8 July 1, 2009 5:28 PM EDT
Obungler is going down the same tube Jimmy did. Promise everything,no results but more taxes. History is repeating again.
Reply to this comment
by gravyboat4000 July 1, 2009 6:41 PM EDT
Shhh! Listen to the dittohead, as he rears his ugly, mullet covered noggin from his arse...talking points in mouth,(transfer to hands complete), hands...

Listen, as he tells us, again, and again, and again, and again, and again how Obama is Carter II...

After 6 months.

lol
by iam4honesty July 1, 2009 7:12 PM EDT
Silly dittoheads. They think Carter was bad, but Nixon was good. They think Obama is bad, but Bush was good. Silly dittoheads.
by keystonebull July 1, 2009 4:55 PM EDT
I think Obama is losing popularity with the public and losing it fast. Another year will tell us how the people feel about him.
Reply to this comment
by mattcat25 July 1, 2009 5:22 PM EDT
I think you said the same thing during the election campaign one year ago?
by lorinkundert July 1, 2009 4:54 PM EDT
Nothing that Marxist does will affect this American all of my money is in a stable bank outside of jurisdiction where I now live. Too many people are too lazy to do anything to force this government to obey the Constitution and I don't want to live among them.
Reply to this comment
by libscrytoo July 1, 2009 4:39 PM EDT
Then tell me this Honesty, Why did the government CUT (take away) my 60 year old Aunt's medical? Your too stupid to look at what is going on. Take off the darn blindfold and stop listening to the suits and look at every day people. For god sakes, you want honesty, open your eyes and look around you. They are taking away medical for people who need it.
Reply to this comment
by iam4honesty July 1, 2009 7:07 PM EDT
Identical posts thirty minutes apart?? Did you mean to do that?
by cdegolier July 1, 2009 4:36 PM EDT
Once again I will say, ***. Tax the responsible people to pay for their own health insurance and give to the ones who don't. First off start denying healthcare to all illegals, that will for sure cut costs. In California they have been responsible for the closures of 84 hospitals. You can't go to another country and expect free healthcare, why here. Another great scare tactic. I have been paying for my own health insurance since I was eighteen, the only time I have been without is between jobs.
Reply to this comment
by andejack July 1, 2009 4:26 PM EDT
Yet another transparent example of the "Obama Scare Technique" that he has capitalized on so very, very effectively. "Disaster is just around the corner, but I WILL SAVE YOU!" The "GIMEE, GIMEE" folks will think this is wonderful, but the rest of us will ask, at what price?? Day by day, step by step, this guy attempts to move us further and further into a socialistic society. Many believe it is GREAT, but I am extremely scared and fervently wish there was a realistic alternative for an old guy like me and my kids and grandkids. This IS NOT a healthy, viable direction for America. Label me a Republican (I'm not), a Conservative (I'm not), a misdirected whacko (I really don't think so!) or whatever, but I AM incredibly concerened about the future of our country and whether or not we will be capable of sustaining the "world class" quality of life so many have sacrificed to make possible for us.
Reply to this comment
by July 1, 2009 6:35 PM EDT
Glad you are concerned. But don't blame the current messenger who happens to be POTUS. The real national debt in 2008 was not the 10.5 trillion that politicians told you. It is 56 trillion counting the unfunded liablities of Medicare and Social Security for the next thirty years.
http://www.pgpf.org/about/nationaldebt/

And yet, the reason private insurers don't want a public option like Medicare for everyone is that it is too cheap paying only 2% overhead. Healthcare costs are going up 8-15% per year. Bottom-line: Do nothing and your "world-class" quality of life will be sacrificed anyway.
by impeachbhb July 1, 2009 4:18 PM EDT
There is no doubt we need healthcare reform. However, Obama needs to quit trying to scare us into taking action too quickly. There at least needs to be time for a bill to be read and reviewed before being voted on by Congress. The American public also needs to be better informed regarding what the government is planning to do. We were sold a bill of goods with the "stimulus bill" that actually proved to offer very little stimulus at all.

If a plan is a great one, it does not need to be rushed. I cannot beleive our elected officials would vote on legislation without reading it. I will gladly devote any time and money I can to see that the Republicans and Democrats that are willing to do this are not re elected.
Reply to this comment
by July 1, 2009 5:39 PM EDT
the "stimulus bill" proved to offer very little stimulus at all"

NOT TRUE. Only ~5% of the funds have kicked in. Go to recovery.org to see where they are being spent in your neighborhood. Then pressure your Congressman to make sure they get spent right.

The other myth is that Obama's plans broke the budget. From the CBO "DATA" spreadsheet, the 2009 budget was already 95% planned before Obama took office.
http://www.cbo.gov/budget/budproj.shtml
1. $1.6 trillion of the $1.8 trillion defict in 2009 was already planned before Obama took office.
2. Ten years from now, deficit is 765B more with Obama spending proposals than without them
3. The main differences are caused by
- Obama's middle class tax cuts
- Obama fixing the AMT
- Obama's middle class tax credits for "making work pay" and children

The only way to pay down the debt is to re-build a country that is capable of paying it down, not just blindly balancing the budget in the middle of a deep recession. The trillion dollars of new debt from ARRA and bank bailouts is aimed at new private industries in energy, infrastructure and health while, upgrading our educational system and being able to get financing for new projects.
by libscrytoo July 1, 2009 4:09 PM EDT
Then tell me this Honesty, Why did the government CUT (take away) my 60 year old Aunt's medical? Your too stupid to look at what is going on. Take off the darn blindfold and stop listening to the suits and look at every day people. For god sakes, you want honesty, open your eyes and look around you. They are taking away medical for people who need it.
Reply to this comment
by libscrytoo July 1, 2009 4:39 PM EDT
She has some of it, but the government is giving her hell on some medical surgery's that are needed for her illness. So instead of helping with her life, they are dragging their feet. And Yes, they did cut some of her cancer treatment
by iam4honesty July 1, 2009 6:16 PM EDT
So, what you are saying is your aunt is in a 'universal' health care program and you are upset because the government is not doing enough, correct?

For your information, my wife is an Advanced Practitioner. She runs the 'fast track' emergency department in a large hospital in Florida. If you were to go to that hospital with a laceration, she might be the one to stich you up and write you a prescription. You seem to have a problem keeping up. The problems that ER's are facing have been widely publicized of late. You see, lib, in this country emergency rooms cannot refuse care. So, those without medical insurance nor the means to pay for a doctor's care end up in the emergency rooms for their primary care. (that means colds, flu, etc.) The average cost of a visit to an emergency room is about $700, can you guess who is paying for those visits? That's right, lib, we are. Now, if we had a 'real' universal health care system those people would be re-routed to clinice where the cost for a visit is about $60. Sooo, lib, we would save a lot of money. Not only that, real emergencies would be handled more effeciently without the overcrowding.

I hope that helped.
by iam4honesty July 1, 2009 4:00 PM EDT
Steady as she goes, Mr. President. We're with you.
Reply to this comment
by mattcat25 July 1, 2009 5:20 PM EDT
It's being reported that over (possibly more then) 75% of Americans are in favor of an improved Healthcare Reform Bill.

Republicans and Democrats in Congress (along with their supporters) should be unable to participate If, a more then likely WHEN, Healthcare Reform takes place.
by July 1, 2009 5:28 PM EDT
I'm with the President too. We already have universal healthcare...through emergency visits for uninsured at 100 to 1000 times the cost of preventive care. There several examples of examples of public systems that work better than ours just like there are examples of those that don't. Its about creating accountability for everyone...the patient, the doctor, the hospital and the insurer.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=89651916
by xlib July 1, 2009 8:03 PM EDT
You can speak for yourself and no one else. No need to cite some trumped up poll numbers. Save your lib breath.
I haven't adopted the group think of the left. I think for myself and I am not with him.
Before you go all "you're a racist" on me, I'm disagreeing with his white half.
Better?
See all 24 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
HOTSHEET ON TWITTER