World Watch
June 21, 2009 7:52 AM

Removing The Veil That Covers The Truth

The Iranian government has done an effective job of putting a veil over what is happening on the streets of Tehran. Yet, tech-savvy Iranians are finding ways to bypass the shutdown of cell phones and the Internet, passing Tweets, photos and videos to the outside world.

Because of restrictions placed on the media by Iranian authorities, radio and television outlets and Web sites searching for the latest news are sifting through tens of thousands of fragments — text messages, photos, videos and phone calls — that show up on Twitter, FriendFeed, YouTube, Facebook and other sites, trying to piece together a picture of what is happening on the ground in Iran.

(YouTube )
(Left: Image of a video posted on YouTube of an Iranian election protestor apparently shot by security forces during a demonstration in Tehran, June 20, 2009.)

The few foreign correspondents left in Tehran are confined to their hotel rooms and watched over by Iranian government officials. Without eyewitness reporting from journalists, nearly every fragment of information carries the caveat, "We can't confirm the authenticity of anything we are showing."

It remains unclear just how many people were in the streets of Tehran and other cities, or how many protesters were killed or injured. But despite the fragmentary nature of the information, a basic picture emerges:

Several thousand protesters took to the streets yesterday in defiance of orders from the Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. Iranian security forces tried to block access to areas, and used tear gas and water cannons. Protesters threw rocks at security forces. Some protesters were killed by gunshots. Opposition activists shouted from the rooftops, "Allahu Akbar" (God is greatest).

There are also unconfirmed tweets of helicopters pouring some chemical on people from the sky; riots in other Iranian cites, including Tabriz, Mashad, Isfahan and Ahwaz; Iranian security forces arresting injured protesters at hospitals; foreign embassies and hospitals accepting (or rejecting) injured protesters seeking to avoid the police at hospitals; bus worker strikes and calls for the "sea of green" dissenters to march today.

Meanwhile, the political drama and power struggle in Iran, as well as on the world stage, continues to play out. Iran's Guardian Council said that 10 percent of the vote would be recounted. Mir Hossein Mousavi, whose supporters believe actually won the vote over President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, allegedly said he is prepared for martyrdom, and that if he is arrested the nation should go on strike indefinitely. Former president Ayatollah Hashemi Rafsanjani also looms as a strong force opposing the re-election of Ahmadinejad.

Keep track on the latest on the Iran situation at IranWatch

President Barack Obama called on the Iranian government to stop the violence against its own people. "We mourn each and every innocent life that is lost. We call on the Iranian government to stop all violent and unjust actions against its own people. The universal rights to assembly and free speech must be respected, and the United States stands with all who seek to exercise those rights," he said.

As expected following Mr.Obama's remarks, today on Aljazeera TV, Iranian President Ahmadinejad asked the United States and United Kingdom to stop their interference in Iran's internal affairs.

Former President Bill Clinton speaking in Cincinnati, Ohio, said yesterday the Iranian government is at odds with the modern world.

“Basically, this is about a government trying to deny the modern world. Ultimately, they don’t think they can keep control if everyone can say what they want and do what they want and go where they want. And they’re right. We’re all going to have to get used to having less control if we want to live in win-win world instead of win-lose,” Clinton said.

(CBS)


Governments can't keep the world from seeing and hearing what is happening, even if it's fragmentary evidence in the modern world--the Internet Age. The graphic video of the woman identified as "Neda" apparently shot by Iranian security forces posted on YouTube, and which has galvanized support for the opposition, as evidenced by images circulating online (above), is the kind of image that could be a pivot point in the course of Iranian history.

CBSNews.com Editor-In-Chief Daniel Farber


To watch Elizabeth Palmer's report on Saturday's election violence click on the video player below.

Tags:
worldwatch ,
Iran ,
internet ,
twitter ,
facebook ,
youtube ,
protests
Topics:
World Watch
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 62 Comments
by jincstress June 21, 2009 10:38 PM EDT
And just think...She's in heaven now with 69 other girls being a promised virgin for some suicide bomber. Allah Aackbar. The US needs to stay out of this. Send them our prayers but not ONE drop of our military's blood. This is how ALL of our unjust wars start- propaganda. My heart goes out to Neda and her family- just as yours, but that's where our involvement should end.
Reply to this comment
by rednomo June 21, 2009 10:01 PM EDT
What's good for the goose...
Reply to this comment
by gravyboat3000 June 21, 2009 9:23 PM EDT
It seems, that Americans are,"war weary". You don't care about,"freedom", if it means American lives.

You don't care about freedom, if it means,"sacrifice"?

GW's war in Iraq has taken it's toll on ALL Americans.

In many forms.

It's time to re-group, and re-think our vision of freedom.


The people of Iran are speaking out, and they'll need our help.

Not militarily, and not through sanctions, but by US being HERE for them.

The Clerics are CLEARLY not internet savey.

hehehe
Reply to this comment
by willcad June 21, 2009 11:44 PM EDT
I care about AMERICAN freedom.

Americans have sacrificed for their own freedom. If other countries want freedom THEY have to be willing to sacrifice to get it, and sacrifice to keep it, just as Americans have for 200 years.

It's neither our responsibility nor our right to bring freedom to the rest of the world.

Freedom isn't free. And the rest of the world has to be willing to pay the price for their own freedom - America has already paid the price, and we're tired of footing the rest of the world's bills.
by ClaudiaW2010 June 21, 2009 8:31 PM EDT
The new technology's involvement in this historical event in Iran is absolutely amazing. I spent a great part of yesterday reading the tweets on Twitter and watching videos on YouTube. As I read through the tweets, some of them just so moving, I would constantly refresh the page to find hundreds and hundreds more comments. After word of Neda's death, the word spread like wildfire on Twitter. To read the words instantaneously from people all over the world just overwhelmed me. The messages showed I was not alone in these feelings. It is almost miraculous an invention that we are watching world history before our eyes in such a rapid manner. Just two weeks ago, a friend and I were mocking Twitter as a uselss new toy for bored teens. I'll never mock it again.
Reply to this comment
by sean7phil June 21, 2009 8:14 PM EDT
"Why should we even care what's happening in Iran? This is an internal political struggle that has escalated to violence; it will either settle quickly, or escalate to civil war. But either way, it doesn't directly affect the US, so why should we bother paying so much attention?"

Because people matter wherever they are. Because there is more to life than just your narrow self interest.
Reply to this comment
by willcad June 21, 2009 8:44 PM EDT
"Because people matter wherever they are. Because there is more to life than just your narrow self interest."

That sounds very noble and enlightened, but sacrificing the lives of your children to save the lives of other peoples children isn't nobility, it's short-sighted foolishness. And sacrificing the lives of other peoples children so that they may secure liberty for still other peoples children is the very definition of evil.

What you call my "narrow self-interest" is neither narrow nor limited to myself. My interest is broad, covering over 200 million people - I'm interested in the rights, freedoms, and well-being of the United States of America, the country in which I live. My interest in the affairs of people on the other side of the planet, most of whom dislike or even hate my country, is minimal and academic, at best. If they choose to fight for freedom, I cheer for them and wish them all the best. But I don't want to see American lives lost to fight for the cause of other people in other countries, particularly those who despise us and our way of life, as so much of the Islamic world does.

If they want help writing a new Constitution when the current unrest if over, I'd be willing to send them copies of ours for reference. If they need experienced diplomats to help negotiate peaceful settlements, I'm sure we can rustle up some appropriately qualified people who are willing to take the job. But I won't support sending them money (we're broke already), or troops (we're way overextended already), or anything else that we can't afford to spare, and that's where I see this going.

Iran is not a nation of children, and we're not their papas and mamas. They are a nation full of adults who are perfectly capable of taking care of their own problems, and I say we should let them. I also say the same thing about Iraq, Afghanistan (after we blast the last of the Al Quaeda terrorists out), China, and North Korea.

Let the rest of the world live they way they choose to live. That's what freedom and self-determination are all about - living with your own choices. And no one, not even the great democratic savior United States, has a right to take that freedom away from anyone else.
by LeslieNewYork2 June 21, 2009 6:06 PM EDT
Unrest in Iran:
To be alive is to be Present in the roll call of Life each and everyday, and it must be done only with our existence to be FREE as a people. Iran, your country is currently on a speeding train and it has no brakes.

The Youth of Iran, the sick & tired, the meek will forever change the Old with authentic possibilities and most importantly, the FREEDOM to exist on this great planet Earth as FREE people.

Iran the world is watching, and most of us are 110% behind you.
Journey on to Freedom,
Leslie Esperanza Espaillat
EspaillatUSA@Yahoo.com
Reply to this comment
by government_control June 21, 2009 6:06 PM EDT
obama = weakness

obama = cowardice

obama = appeasement
Reply to this comment
by ubrew12 June 21, 2009 8:17 PM EDT
Most notable news item about Barack Obama in his presidency (more than Afghanistan, Iraq, finance sector reform, healthcare reform, stimulus package):

"We will continue funding the Defense Department at Bush levels: $600 billion a year."

No, dipsh*t, this is no neville chamberlain. First, show me the 'Hitler' he is appeasing (other than himself). Second, show me how purchasing 20 times the military that our nearest competitor is purchasing constitutes 'appeasement'.

Americans have been so horribly compromised by their empire. You are totally being used by the global 'plugged-in' wealthy (Saudis, Israelis, Europeans, etc) who could give a rats **s for your quaint and useless notions of 'nationalism'. Your nationalism is the new 'Pap for the masses'. (look it up).

News flash: you sacrificed 5000 soldiers in Iraq and what (other than the price tag) did you get for it? Its time you started searching for who is profiting by the deployment of your awesome military (hint: it AIN'T you... plebe).
by credibility2 June 21, 2009 5:41 PM EDT
Although no blood in the streets, but where was the outrage when the Chinese government censored journalists from all over the world covering the Beijing Olympics by blocking access to a number of websites the government thought too controversial? I guess that form of censorship was OK because it involved sports and the event was one of unity rather than dissention. And, never mind the other forms of repressive conduct by the Chinese during this event. Media gave it little coverage because they were pandering to the Chinese government and didn't want to offend them. U.S. mention of the censorship was minimal and almost dismissive.

The situation in Tehran will get worse before it gets better. When Tiananmen occurred in 1989, many protesters were murdered for their "cause". Today, the repressive Chinese government continues its questionable policies against its own people. The cause didn't prevail. The world, outraged, in time came to accept the repression. Perhaps that is the way Iran will go. Give it twenty-years and then let's make a follow-up assessment and see where we're at and if the protesters eventually succeeded. Isn't it interesting that Mousavi is safe behind his cowardice, watching his supporters get murdered and bludgeoned all in his name. If he really cared, he'd show his face and lead the throngs.
Reply to this comment
by ubrew12 June 21, 2009 5:07 PM EDT
The picture of Neda is a reminder of the true cost of keeping people down through force of arms. Shame on the Iranian government.

I have a question for those Americans who are touched by this picture, however: How many Neda's just died in Iraq? 1,000? 10,000? 100,000? Does it mean something that we don't even know? How many of them became posters within 24 hours of their deaths? Can any of you recall seeing ANY photos of ANY Iraqi casualties from the war just prosecuted on them? I don't, and I feel strange that I don't. A photo like Neda's makes you feel the injustice passionately. But Iraq (other than Abu Graib) is like a black hole. I guess people died there, but I didn't see them, soldier and citizen alike, they are forgotten people. I understand that it makes it easier to prosecute a war with a news blackout like that. I'm just not sure it's right. In a way, it creates two casualties: the victim of war, and the observer, who remains innocent of it. War is never that clean, and shouldn't be represented that way. Its like not knowing where food comes from. It just shows up and you eat it.
Reply to this comment
by karenbe111 June 21, 2009 4:39 PM EDT
Great title to this story...wish it would be applied to what has been done by this country...in our name! CBS, how about some real reporting on the past actions of your own government and giving the American people what is being demanded by the Iranians...an actual democracy, which requires that the public be "truth fully" informed!!!
Reply to this comment
by curiously1 June 21, 2009 4:30 PM EDT
"Why should we care about Iran", you asked? Here is my two cents. The Iranian regime is developing nukes. They are radicals. Their book says "kill the infidels". You and I, along with almost 9/10 of the world are "infidels" (in their minds). They have announced that they will wipe out Israel, and they will. They are supporting the radicals in Lebanon and Palestine. They are destabilizing the middle east, which at the very least affects your gas prices,if not more. They have been linked to bombing and other terrorist attacks including the one in the 80's that killed U.S marines. They are slicing up their own citizens and pouring acid over their heads. But they're not done there. They are then going to all hospitals and they're taking away the injured. To where, we can only guess. You think they will have mercy on the Jews?! Or on you and your kids?!
Those who question this freedom movement in Iran fall under one the following categories:
A) Those who don't care (pot smokers, porn watchers and/or typical everyday jokers)
B) They don't get it (folks of low IQ)
C) Iranian regime supporters (pigs, thugs, incests)

How can you look the photo of this dead young girl and ask why you should care? What was her crime? Where is your humanity for God sakes?!
Reply to this comment
by mnbrant June 21, 2009 4:07 PM EDT
Whats more dangerous to the west? An Iran who has a functioning democracy and an economy that is on its way to becoming a superpower? Or, a religious cast system that keeps the country stuck in the middle ages. Obviously if your on Obama's team your gonna be ambivalent about it. If your a Republican your gonna blast out your support in hopes for the highest death count so you can continue business as usual. Its so much easier for the CIA when you everything is all black and white. Lots of foreign money is spent keeping the Arab states the way they are now.
Reply to this comment
by erasmus111 June 21, 2009 3:35 PM EDT
by WayAround June 21, 2009 9:23 AM PDT
...and would you, too, please learn how to use "Reply to this post". You and gravyboat3000 are living proof that the empty barrel makes the most noise.


I HATE the "reply to comment". It's better when you post it at the end.
Reply to this comment
by South-of-Heaven June 21, 2009 3:11 PM EDT
Politics and Religion are the mixture of pure evil.
there is no Evil more vile than opressing peoples will
by the gun and excusing it by Calling it Gods will.

Separation of Church and State
Separation of Mosque and State
Separation of Synagogue and State.

Progressives and liberal thinkers should strive to
make this century the century of enlightenment.
Reply to this comment
by walt1944 June 21, 2009 3:08 PM EDT
We could ALL take a lesson from the Iranian situation.

1. GOD and GOVERNMENT SHOULD NOT MIX!!!!
2. THEOCRACY is another name for TYRANNY!!!!
3. The TRUTH SHALL MAKE YOU FREE!!!!

HAIL OBAMA????
Reply to this comment
by Slrman June 21, 2009 2:42 PM EDT
As always when social change is needed, it's the young people leading the charge. They did in the USA during the Vietnam era and have always done so throughout the world.

Think about it, "student rebellion" is almost like one word and one that despotic regimes and politicians have learned to fear.

Iran is going to change but it will probably still be an Islamic Republic, which means that eventually, the same religious fanaticism will still be in charge.
Reply to this comment
by gravyboat3000 June 21, 2009 2:12 PM EDT
by WayAround June 21, 2009 9:10 AM PDT
I just read your post, and you didn't say squat.
by WayAround June 21, 2009 9:23 AM PDT
...and would you, too, please learn how to use "Reply to this post". You and gravyboat3000 are living proof that the empty barrel makes the most noise.
_____

Did you mean,"reply to this comment"?

It doesn't work. I click it, and nothin.

And, instead of,"attempted", insults, why don't you point out specifically what you take issue with what I've posted?

(he can't, Rush is off on Sunday)...

Oh, yeah...
Reply to this comment
by WayAround June 21, 2009 2:51 PM EDT
gravyboat3000 whined: "It doesn't work. I click it, and nothin."

Operator error

gravyboat3000 whined: "point out specifically what you take issue with what I've posted"

It's not the first time that I've had to call you on the carpet, gravyboat3000. I find your rambling comments, always belitting someone else, rather disgusting.

I would relish the opportunity to comment on your posts, but they have ZERO content. No concrete examples to support a thesis. No specific facts to support an idea. In fact, NO IDEAS. Only denigrating people who have ideas. As I wrote, you are an empty barrel making the most noise.
by rwsmith29456 June 21, 2009 1:48 PM EDT
Radical Muslims hear me. Your own people are sick of you and are coming to get you. The day will come when your empire crumbles to dust.
Reply to this comment
by Illuminated1 June 21, 2009 1:27 PM EDT
The enemy of all governments are the international corporations that work behind government veils.

They have in our country abandoned the middle class so as to produce goods for import which is claim to be cheaper.
A good example of how the American middle class is being eliminated is GM. The autoworker was the last of the middle class, now extinct.
In China, they are selling "American cars" like hotcakes, but the truth behind the veil is not a single American ever worked on building them.
The manufacturing is done inside China....therefore not "American", but another lie, and we in America don't see a dime of profit.
It seems everything imported is cheaper...
We are more dependant now than ever...making us suckers.
Just look at these examples...
Toys: I remember going to the toy stores when I was younger and I clearly see the decrease in quality toys, but to add lead based paints is illegal here. Apparently not in China.
Drugs: We have imported many drugs from the chemical industry in China.
They have no pharmaceutical industry there, and believe a 99:1 safety ratio is great....no its not...our standards are more like 9999999:1
Some of the drugs imported have been contaminated.
Food: I've seen video of farms which is used to grow foods for export to our land...I've also seen the rodents infesting the crops, yet they send contaminated foods to us for consumption.
I dont know about you, but I've gotten sick lately from food I believe is contaminated.

Yet with all these issues, WHAT HAS OUR GOVERNMENT PROTECTIONS DONE ABOUT IT?

ABSOLUTELY NOTHING.
THE VEIL OF COVER UP OCCURS IN MANY PLACES WHEN CORPORATIONS ARE BEHIND THE GOVERNMENTS AND LAWS.
Ladies and Gentlemen, this must stop.

Now we are so focused on Iran.........but don't forget what the Corporations have done to us, and don't forget the damage done to America by the previous Presidential administration which I find in contempt of the constitution and the people of the United States.

I will never back down in this.
If you care about america, demand trials, demand them now.
Reply to this comment
by Bayou123 June 21, 2009 1:11 PM EDT
These Iranian people have guts to go against their government. The American marijuana smokers are gutless.
Reply to this comment
by manuob1 June 21, 2009 6:50 PM EDT
You have a point, Bayout. When the neocons stole our 2000 election, even though Gore won the popular vote, we rolled over and played dead. The Iranians are putting us to shame.
See all 62 Comments

About World Watch

Extra reporting, analysis and more from CBS foreign desks across the globe.

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Can the Postal Service be Saved?

    (289 recent comments)