Political Hotsheet
May 13, 2009 4:35 PM

My Side Of The Story: Gibbs And The Cell Phones

(CBS)
The issue of the day at the White House briefing: the Obama administration's reversal of the decision to release photos of detainees being tortured. After an appeals court refused to hear the case, the administration said last month they would abide by the lower court's decision and release the photos. So the President's decision NOT to do so was the topic of most questioning today - intense at times.

Intense, that is, until a reporter John Gizzi's cell phone began chiming one of those vaguely familiar ring tones which have become this era's elevator music.

Spokesman Robert Gibbs looked up and said, "just put it on vibrate man. We did this before...it happened twice one day."

He resumed. Ten seconds later, Gizzi's phone went off again.

"Give me the phone," said Gibbs - and started down from the podium, hand outstretched.

Laugher all around.

Gibbs took the phone, walked to the pressroom door, and pitched it to someone inside.

More laughter.

Then the briefing resumed -- for thirty seconds.

That's when my phone rang - a standard ring, nothing imaginative. I answered. It was a source I'd been waiting to hear from.

"You too," asked Gibbs? "So you want to do it too? Here, come on."

"Gibbs wants to take my phone," I explained to the caller as I got up from the chair and headed outside.

"I assume it's your banker, with a suit like that?" Gibbs quipped as I walked out, in reference to my pin-striped suit. "There's cotton candy down the street. It's a circus."

I spent about five minutes on the phone and came back into the briefing.

I asked Gibbs if I'd missed anything.

He joked in response: "Will somebody brief Bill on our new Supreme Court nominee?"

Watch the video here:



Bill Plante is a CBS News senior White House correspondent.
Tags:
Topics:
White House
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 81 Comments
by CharlieQuinn July 6, 2009 4:44 PM EDT
All of you need to get a life. Bill Plante is the best political correspondent on any media. CBS is fortunate to have this multiple Emmy Award winner on its staff. Plante possesses the most sophistication and poise "under fire" of any reporter I've seen/read. Let's not forget his coverage of the exodus from Saigon at the end of the war...or his reporting of the assasination attempt on Reagan (when he was recovering from a broken leg).

Look, in these days of dismal news at every turn, a little heartedness in the Press Room (which has never been compared to the Sistene Chapel)should be welcomed. Come on folks, if you want to see a real "circus", just switch to Fox News: clowns AND bimbos!
Reply to this comment
by mike8654 May 23, 2009 10:28 PM EDT
It was very insulting. It created the impression that you thought Gibbs was not wothy of respect . Thanks.
Reply to this comment
by fauxmaux May 20, 2009 1:51 AM EDT
great timing! nice riff. entertaining!
Reply to this comment
by Steerpike2 May 18, 2009 7:28 PM EDT
This was unspeakably rude behavior. CBS ought to fire you for doing this. If I had been running the meeting I'd have thrown you out and revoked your credentials. I've done it before in meetings I've hosted.

Here's a hint: you're a reporter. You don't actually do anything. You go to the press briefing and get spoon fed what they want to spoon feed you. No thought is required. Just sit there, shut up, and absorb information. There is no--REPEAT NO--phone call important enough for you to interrupt a press briefing for. You're not that important.
Reply to this comment
by arthernan May 18, 2009 7:17 PM EDT
I agree with marymac123, there seems to be a lot of angry comments. Nobody died ect.... But the fact is that this was very rude behavior. And now with the benefit of hindsight he should apologize, he also is not going to die for doing so. That would be the end of it. Because he is clearly unapologetic I think that he has some personal attitude problems.
Reply to this comment
by gilboastro May 16, 2009 5:04 PM EDT
(The difference is in his smug behavior.)

If CBS was wise, they would send him packing. He insults us when he insults the president. But I don't think they will. He is one of their own.

The public will start to see that the Bush administration had it almost right when complaining about the media. But It is not the arrogance of the liberal media, it is the arrogance of the media.
Reply to this comment
by bsjc May 15, 2009 7:04 AM EDT
As much as I would like to sympathize with Mr. Plante for receiving all this criticism for merely answering a phone call, I find it difficult to justify his actions in answering the call before stepping out of the press room first. If the phone call was as important as he says it was, he should have stepped out first before answering the call, or at least apologize to Mr. Gibbs for the ring before answering. His actions therefore do not bespeak a necessity but an air of smug superiority.
Reply to this comment
by tomginis May 15, 2009 2:20 AM EDT
you should be banned from white house.
Reply to this comment
by vess12 May 14, 2009 8:55 PM EDT
If you were expecting a phone call that was as important as you say it was you should have stayed out of the the briefing. Otherwise the phone call was not that important. Your phone rang and you made it worse by answering it. You were just being rude. They shouldn't let you into the briefings again if you dont know how to behave better than that.
Reply to this comment
by davidjaycrispin May 14, 2009 8:07 PM EDT
My momma would call this just plain bad manners.
Reply to this comment
by munder301 May 14, 2009 7:37 PM EDT
I'm never watching Bill Plante again. I haven't seen such simple arrogance in a LONG time. I would expect that from a teenager that's not going anywhere in life, which is exactly what I'll expect from you.
I really hope they ban you from white house duty for a while.
Reply to this comment
by rodinie May 14, 2009 5:58 PM EDT
Bill Plante, around since the dinosaurs, showed he is one. No call is so important that it needs to be answered "just right now." If the caller didn't get you on the first try, he or she would call again, i.e., if he/she were more polite than you showed yourself to be.
Reply to this comment
by chimer123 May 14, 2009 5:23 PM EDT
This would have been a good place to acknowledge that you had a momentary lapse in judgement, possibly from the threat of losing your cell phone. To rationalize it as in any way appropriate, or to think that cell phone rings are tolerable background noise, like "elevator music", is pure denial of the irresponsibility of the neglect to turn off the ring, and then the arrogance to answer it.
Reply to this comment
by marymac123 May 14, 2009 4:35 PM EDT
Wow, I am shocked by the venom in these responses. What are you people really angry about? If Gibbs himself wasn?t angered by this, why are you? Everyone in the press room had a good laugh. Nobody got hurt; nobody died; why not shake your head, chuckle, and move on?

Sure, Bill Plante?s cell phone should have been on vibrate, but to act as if this negates the years of award-winning reporting Plante has provided is positively ludicrous. And to suggest that Plante should be fired, or that he is a disgrace to his profession because of this only reflects ignorance. Bill Plante is a journalistic icon in D.C. These comments only reflect the sad state of too many Americans. You?re angry, and you don?t know why.
Reply to this comment
by haney10 May 14, 2009 4:25 PM EDT
as much as i can't stand Gibbs i have to go with him on this one! we wonder where our kids learn the rude, disrespectful behavior from!! Plante, that was pathetic. i wonder how many times he's complained about someone using their cell phone when it was inappropriate. media hipocracy???
Reply to this comment
by earlysaid May 14, 2009 4:10 PM EDT
Mr. Plant, cell phones ringing are a problem at any function. Mr. Gibbs is obviously getting tired of ringing cell phones during his briefings. You did nothing wrong if it was an important call, but putting it on vibrate would be a smart move. Since Gibbs is such a nice guy I know he would never be mean about your phone though.
Reply to this comment
by chawnyce May 14, 2009 4:05 PM EDT
The behavior that you displayed was similar to that of a child who has been caught doing wrong and refusing to acknowledge their indiscretion. Adding insult to injury, you chose to leave the briefing room, insulting the press secretary. Horrible. There is no other way to describe your immaturish lack of professional decorum. Even business students 101 know to silence the phones in meetings. For all of your years and years and years in the business, I cannot believe that this is a rule you never learned. It is easier to see that during your years and years of experience you have begun to forget things.
Reply to this comment
by lukasbradley May 14, 2009 3:53 PM EDT
I've always respected CBS News tremendously. Mr. Plante, what you did was one of the most unprofessional things I've ever seen on television. It's laughable you titled this "My Side of the Story." I didn't read anything here that remotely attempts to justify your actions.

I've lost a tremendous amount of respect for CBS News. Not only for your actions, but in this non attempt of explanation. It seems as if CBS is only milking the incident for web hits.
Reply to this comment
by stanleyharris May 14, 2009 2:51 PM EDT
Mr. Plante:

"Your Side of The Story"? Nothing but a replay of the rude, inconsiderate behavior we saw on the video. No apology, no remorse.

Only a jerk lets his cell phone ring, answers it, stands up and carries on a conversation in a meeting -- ANY meeting -- not to mention a White House briefing.

You showed disrespect for Mr. Gibbs, the White House and other media members who were sitting in that meeting trying to pay attention. Your arrogance is a discredit to CBS.
Reply to this comment
by roughshot60 May 14, 2009 1:31 PM EDT
i watched the press conference and i really felt for mr gibbs. it is rude and totally unprofessional. i don't care if edward r murrow was on the line you should have the phone on vibrate and if you know your going to be getting a call dont sit in the front row where all attention is directed at you
Reply to this comment
See all 81 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
Discussed
  1. Kennedy: Bishop Barred Me From Communion

    (330 recent comments)

HOTSHEET ON TWITTER