Political Hotsheet
May 8, 2009 11:33 AM

Arabic Linguist Fired From Army For Being Openly Gay

(AP / file)
In spite of President Obama's declared stance against the "don't-ask-don't-tell" policy that keeps openly gay individuals out of the military, the U.S. Army on Thursday told Lt. Dan Choi he is being dismissed for publicly revealing his homosexuality.

Choi is not the first servicemember to be dismissed because of his sexuality under the Obama administration, but his dismissal stands out because of his noted skills. Choi is an infantry platoon leader in the New York National Guard who is fluent in Arabic. He graduated West Point and recently returned from Iraq.

As founding member of Knights Out, an organization for openly gay, lesbisan, bisexual, and transgender West Point alumni and their supporters, Choi advocates allowing openly gay people to serve in the military. He announced his own sexuality on MSNBC on March 19.

On the campaign trail, Mr. Obama specifically criticized the dismissal of openly gay servicemen who have special language skills. He also told the Advocate, a gay newsmagazine, that the don't-ask-don't-tell policy is a "counterproductive strategy."

"We’re spending large sums of money to kick highly qualified gays or lesbians out of our military, some of whom possess specialties like Arab-language capabilities that we desperately need," he said in an interview with the magazine. "That doesn’t make us more safe."

Since the don't-ask-don't-tell policy was implemented during the Clinton administration, around 12,500 servicemembers have been dismissed because of their sexuality.

The White House also recently came under fire from liberal bloggers who noted a change in the language addressing the issue on Whitehouse.gov. The site initially said Mr. Obama supported "repealing" don't-ask-don't-tell, but it later said the president supported "changing" the policy "in a sensible way." After taking heat on the matter, the White House changed the wording on Whitehouse.gov once again to say the president "supports repealing Don’t Ask Don’t Tell in a sensible way that strengthens our armed forces and our national security."

Defense Secretary Robert Gates has also been noncomittal about repealing the policy. While touring war colleges in April, Gates said he did not yet have a position on whether gay troops should be open about their sexuality.

Mr. Obama has also come under pressure from gay advocates to appoint an openly gay person to the Supreme Court.

Below is Choi's March 19 appearance on MSNBC:



Make a prediction about the future of "Don't Ask-Don't Tell" Below:

Tags:
Don't Ask Don't Tell
Topics:
Defense
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 392 Comments
by calibr3 July 2, 2009 1:57 PM EDT
Iam a sergeant in the us army that deployed with Lt choi. Iam a heterosexual man,Lt Choi is an outstanding leader,leaders are born not made,you people can take your nasty and disrespectful comments and swallow them down the wind pipe.Lt choi just like me risked his life from aug 2006 nov 2007 operation iraqi freedom not for the money, but to represent the USA in a third world country,and to prove to the world that we are not animals like they assume we are.I Know the Lt for three years and i just found out his sexual preference only because i was watching the news,he is very moral and more professional than he you wont be able to find.He will loose nothing being separated from the army.I have noted that the army would rather keep alcoholics,ex-convicts and drug abusers. Just ask yourself, who would you trust a person that is gay and professional good at what he does or a drug abuser in a combat zone? Go ahead seperate him and all the soldiers that are worth a gold mine,then realize on your own that the armed forces are no longer effective,it is happening now!recruitting and retention is down.all we have left are jail birds and junkies give your self a round of applause and pat your self on the back.
Reply to this comment
by rmyurick May 14, 2009 3:28 PM EDT
What's a coal string--anything like a coatstring?

Yes it IS "gay"of him to say he is gay (lol). But why should he be dismissed? It makes no sense and it is a shame. I'm sure there are many who are not even completely aware of their sexuality when signing up at that young age. Especially when society does everything it can to brainwash you straight.
Reply to this comment
by Trust_me_ May 11, 2009 11:01 AM EDT
Obama won, get over it!
If he wants gays in the military he will ask them to join!
Reply to this comment
by Trust_me_ May 11, 2009 11:00 AM EDT
slownewsday05

He knew how hard it was to get in and he knew the current laws. He is playing on the liberals coal strings.
It was gay of him to attempt this game and he lost.
Reply to this comment
by Trust_me_ May 11, 2009 10:55 AM EDT
Wait Wait <
Obama was going to fix this, was this not the first thing he was going to sign when elected?

Are you saying he lied to the homosexes?
Reply to this comment
by informedone1 May 10, 2009 10:49 PM EDT
What a disgrace. In this day and age to destroy someone's life and career because they are homosexual is abhorrent. Throw in the fact that he speaks Arabic fluently and that's doubly insane. And how does homosexuality make him "morally or professionally derelict" or "negatively effect the good order and discipline" of the National Guard. The government is pathetic. And as long as homosexuals are treated as second class citizens, they are under absolutely no obligation to pay the same taxes or obey the same laws that that the first class citizens, heterosexuals, do. It's high time Gay Americans start fighting back, with violence if necessary.
Reply to this comment
by slownewsday05 May 9, 2009 9:56 PM EDT
Why do all of these cases seem to start with a deliberate stealthy entry into the military, if not dishonest, in order to later stage a grandstand play?

Posted by 6591Hou

How is it dishonest? The military permits gays. It just doesn't permit them to talk about it.

Quite an elaborate scheme, imho. Do you know how hard it is to get into West Point? You think he staged the whole thing as a spectacle? LMAO!

Oh, and putting his life on the line in Iraq was certainly part of his "scheme".... Get real!
Reply to this comment
by 6591Hou May 9, 2009 7:35 PM EDT
Define "openly".......was he "openly" gay when he applied to West Point, openly" gay when he reported to his first commanding officer, or did he wait until he was able to say he successfully completed a tour in Iaq in order to get more press attention? Why do all of these cases seem to start with a deliberate stealthy entry into the military, if not dishonest, in order to later stage a grandstand play? Why not instead start with honest protest and develop grass-roots support for change - unless you're afraid there is no grass-roots support for change.
Reply to this comment
by hakori May 9, 2009 2:36 PM EDT
iam4lies....yes he made a calculated move. As did those who refused to leave lunch counters in the south simply because they were black. Sometimes a caluclated move is made with the greater good in mind. This man has more courage than you and I and most people posting here combined. For you to sit in your cozy home and throw bigotted insults takes not an ounce of courage, but it takes a great deal of gall and ignorance!
Reply to this comment
by hakori May 9, 2009 2:27 PM EDT
the_sir_mr .............FIRST OF ALL, homosexuality is in now shape or form a sickness. It can be debated wether or not bigorty is.....something you obviously suffer from. Second of all, you people have been extremely vocal about your views on gays for years. Fortunatley the nation is moving on and people are starting to loose their homophobia. Thirdly, gay Americans have absolutely no desire to control you or anyone else. They simply wish to have the same legal protections you enjoy.

You have a very strange idea of "sick" when you dehumanize an entire group of people.
Reply to this comment
by iam4honesty May 9, 2009 10:33 AM EDT
I am sorry, but this guy is making a calculated move. Read the article. This is not just the release of a gay who came out of he closet, he has his agenda. He knew full well that his release (considering his expertise) would get national attention and he CHOSE to make the moves he has made.
Reply to this comment
by mensarino May 9, 2009 9:42 AM EDT
The anti gay crowd on this site is truly un-American.They are either violent,criminal homophobes or rambling jesus freaks mumbling their mumbo-jumbo ad nauseum.No wonder they are losing.
The expansion of gay rights is inevitable.You can either gracefully make the most of it or remain intransigent and be viewed as a recalcitrant oddity from a bygone age.
Reply to this comment
by hakori May 9, 2009 8:04 AM EDT
Culture_Warrior_in_09 .............people used the Bible to allow women to remain in servitude. Do you think your right to vote should be taken back? Using your logic it most certainly should!
Reply to this comment
by hakori May 9, 2009 8:03 AM EDT
Culture_Warrior_in_09 ............our founding fathers used the Bible to justify slavery as well. Are you now going to say you think slavery was just hunky dory?
Reply to this comment
by hakori May 9, 2009 7:59 AM EDT
azulene ...........is that what you think this is all about: gays wanting to legislate acceptance? Really, you need to think about this a little more deeply. Do you think the civil rights movement was about blacks wanting to legislate acceptance? The civil rights movement was about gaining equal protection under the law. Trust me, I live in the south and there are plenty of people who still do not accept blacks on any level. That's a personal choice, but just because these people don't accept blacks doesn't mean they have the legal right to discriminate against them. Do you really think gays care one bit about what you or anyone else thinks about them? Is your ego so big that you believe anyone else needs your "approval"? This is about equal protection under the law...PERIOD! How can you give an informend answer on this issue when you don't even know the question?
Reply to this comment
by CMancos May 9, 2009 7:55 AM EDT
You people are sick we have had gays and lesbians open sharing rooms showers etc. We have not had one case where there was a problem. But then you got that stupid Jesus thing going.
Posted by jerryomara at 12:10 AM : May 9, 2009

Yes, you have had gays sharing AIDS too. That "stupid Jesus thing", you should not comment on because you know nothing about it. You have no God because you think you are God and the truth offends you. Any time you find someone making a comment such as yours, you can bet they are into some decadent behavior themselves that is why they come down harsh on "the stupid Jesus thing", it does not agree with their unnatural life-style. Perhaps you should step back and look in the mirror and ask yourself who is smarter, you or the Creator and if you do not believe in God, then the answer is clear.
Reply to this comment
by excoachken May 9, 2009 7:34 AM EDT
Weak minds will use any means to hurt people they can't understand. With the talent and ability that this man has the military has shot itself in the foot, again. Time to keep the "Best and the Brightest" in the service. Bigotry is out of style. Come on, Barrack, "lock the heels" of the fools who made this decision. That's why the civilized portion of our voters backed you.
Reply to this comment
by I_am_me1953 May 9, 2009 7:15 AM EDT
Why is our country so enthralled with what happens in our neighbor's bedroom?

(wait, my neighbor just drove into his driveway)

On a Friday, this early?

I'll be back...

Posted by gravyboat45 at 11:43 PM : May 8, 2009
_________________________

Gone to get your telescope and camera huh?

Bet those photos will show up on you tube any minute now.
Reply to this comment
by gravyboat45 May 9, 2009 2:43 AM EDT
Why is our country so enthralled with what happens in our neighbor's bedroom?

(wait, my neighbor just drove into his driveway)

On a Friday, this early?

I'll be back...
Reply to this comment
by justsane-2009 May 9, 2009 2:11 AM EDT
mr. president--this is a no-brainer, and it is easy to do. repeal "don't ask, don't tell" and order the immediate reinstatement of lt. choi....
Reply to this comment
See all 392 Comments

About Political Hotsheet

Stay up to the minute on the latest news and developments from Washington, from the White House to Congress and everything in-between with the best political reporters from CBS News and CBSNews.com.

E-Mail Political Hotsheet
Follow On Twitter

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn
  • MOST POPULAR
HOTSHEET ON TWITTER