Econwatch
April 23, 2009 4:57 PM

Senators Want Emergency Credit Card Rate Freeze

(CBS/AP)

This post was written by Stephanie Condon.

While President Obama met today with executives from the leading credit card companies, two senators called on the Federal Reserve to immediately implement an emergency freeze on interest rates tied to existing balances on credit cards.

The Federal Reserve plans to implement a new set of rules for credit card lending beginning July 2010, but that is too long to wait, Senators Chris Dodd (D-Conn.) and Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said in a letter sent to Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke and other regulators. Companies are increasing interest rates now before the new rules go into effect, they said.

"Consumers describe situations to our offices in which the interest rates on their accounts have doubled or tripled overnight, without any misconduct on their part," the letter says. "This kind of practice clearly violates the spirit and intention of the rules, even if the delayed implementation date has the effect of making such behavior legal."

Congress is working on legislation that would codify the Fed's new rules, but the bill is still in development.

After meeting with 14 executives from companies like Bank of America, Wells Fargo, and Visa, President Obama said that his administration would work with Congress to evaluate proposals for reform.

"We're at a time where issues of credit and how businesses and families are able to finance everything from a car loan to a student loan to just paying their bills every day is on a lot of people's minds," the president said. "We want to preserve the credit card market, but we also want to do so in a way that eliminates some of the abuses and some of the problems that a lot of people are familiar with."

The card executives at today's White House meeting agreed to work with the administration to address the president's concerns, according to the American Bankers Association, and are currently working to implement the Federal Reserves' new rules. The ABA, however, took issue with the new regulations.

"The Federal Reserve itself has indicated these rules are likely to shrink credit availability and result in increased rates for some consumers," ABA President Edward Yingling said in a statement. "The goal of any additional efforts should be to achieve the right balance between enhancing consumer protections and ensuring that credit remains available to consumers and small businesses at a reasonable cost."

Some Republicans are also concerned about the impact of the new regulations. Rep. Scott Garrett (R-N.J.), a member of the House Financial Services Committee, said the legislation to codify the new rules is well-intended but will have negative consequences.

"There's no one on either side of the aisle who does not want to have more transparency so that people know what they're getting into and what they're dealing with," Garrett told CBS News. "But with the credit market already tightening, now is not the time to make it even more difficult for the moderate-income family, with even more reasons to rely on his credit card, to find out he can't get one."

He said implementing any of the Fed's new rules immediately, as Dodd and Schumer are requesting, would only exacerbate the impact.

"One benefit (of the current regulatory change) is it goes into effect later on, and we can hope the recession we're in now will be loosening up for other reasons," he said. "Once they go into effect, I think they will have a dampening effect on the availability of credit."

Tags:
credit cards ,
interest rate ,
recession ,
economics ,
unintended consequences
Topics:
Credit Cards
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 25 Comments
by keithle1 April 28, 2009 10:35 PM EDT
Hooked on plastic. Can't even pay for a cup of coffee & a sandwich without pulling out the plastic. God forbid anyone pays cash. Cash? What's that? Eeeeewwwww.
It's dirty! If you just have to have a credit card then get a low credit limit. Why do you need a $10,000 credit limit?

How much of the credit card business is the result of women shopping?
Reply to this comment
by cheetah-man7 April 28, 2009 10:41 AM EDT
I say jack the interest rate to 50% I pay my cards every month so I pay 0%
Posted by dwilson59



Big deal your are a rich scumbag who wants to brag about how good your doing financially.........ANYONE who sides with the greedy thieves is against America recovering......wishing ill economics upon the people of this country is about as unpatriotic as it gets....I bet you are one of those flag waving idiots that thinks the answer to everything is military action, and supports the two lie wars we are in now. Maybe another Madoff will end up with your riches and you can start worrying about how to eat and pay bills too, like millions of GOOD DECENT Americans are doing now because of ripoff tactics that corporate America is doing to the people.
Posted by tincup356
__________________________

I agree with you 100%, tincup. I bet Sean Hannity brainwashed dwilson with his ill-branding of what being a patriotic American is all about. These people totally disgust me as well as the banks they support.
Reply to this comment
by oftencensord April 25, 2009 7:35 AM EDT
The reason credit rates are so high, is they are unsecured loans, and you are paying for everyone else who defaults. That is why credit card rates have ALWAYS been high.

What is amazing to me, is people get a credit card with a promotional "sucker rate" and now think it is their right to keep that rate, and want the US Government to FORCE banks to give to them! Maybe we can have the US Government force them to give us more airline miles too!

Credit cards are merely a convenience, not a right people!

Don't make it my problem if you are ignorant about credit cards and how to use them.
Reply to this comment
by noloyalisti April 24, 2009 1:16 PM EDT
Maybe it is time for We the People to take over the credit companies as well as the banks.
Reply to this comment
by bubba027 April 24, 2009 11:41 AM EDT
If you would like to help pressure Congress for a credit card bill of rights please join our voting bloc at:
http://votingbloc.org/Credit_Card_Rights.php
Posted by pontesisto at 3:14 AM : Apr 24, 2009

Quit using credit cards altogether. That's the most effective vote you have.
Reply to this comment
by bubba027 April 24, 2009 11:38 AM EDT
They are not going to get any new laws passed in time to help anyone. By the time such laws take effect, everyone with a credit card balance who is stupid enough to keep paying on it will already be paying a 30% APR -- which will, of course, be grandfathered in.
Posted by Void_Master at 9:13 PM : Apr 23, 2009

Why wouldn't you pay off what you borrowed? Wouldn't it be stealling if you didn't? Companies do give you notice before they raise your rates. When that happens to me, I either switch cards or pay it off and quit using it.
Reply to this comment
by esquin April 24, 2009 11:36 AM EDT
Congress needs to stand up & do the morally correct thing - impose usury laws on banks, the credit card rates are no better than payday loans.
Reply to this comment
by bubba027 April 24, 2009 11:34 AM EDT
I am going to an all cash economy - if I can't pay cash, I won't buy anything. They can "service" my account all they want, but I'll be damned if they get any more of my hard earned dollars.
Posted by superdem1 at 7:48 AM : Apr 24, 2009

You likely should have satrated paying cash before your rate got to 25%--ouch. How is squashing what the banks can charge in interest going to improve the credit crisis? they will just stop lending to those who they thought they needed to charge 25%. I have credit cards but don't use them much. My rates are at record lows and I have other companies begging me to take their cards, but i don't need them. oh, I'm not rich muckity muck either. Live within your means and you won't need to worry about credit card interest.
Reply to this comment
by superdem1 April 24, 2009 10:48 AM EDT
A freeze won't help - my credit card interest rate is 25% !!! THAT should be against the law ! The REPUBLICANS let them do that ! Freezing these high rates does NOTHING to stop the damage. And people think they aren't getting socked if they pay on time - WRONG ! The banks start sucking your blood with "service charges" the moment you make a purchase ! I am going to an all cash economy - if I can't pay cash, I won't buy anything. They can "service" my account all they want, but I'll be damned if they get any more of my hard earned dollars.
Reply to this comment
by whitemale08 April 24, 2009 10:28 AM EDT
Another example of how the system is bankrupt.

CALL CONGRESS AND DEMAND AN END TO ALL BAILOUTS!

TELL GOLDMAN SUCKS, JP MORGAN TO GO INTO RECEIVERSHIP!

WE DO NOT BAILOUT WORTHLESS DERIVATIVES AND CREDIT-DEFAULT SWAPS!
Reply to this comment
by Void_Master April 24, 2009 12:13 AM EDT
They are not going to get any new laws passed in time to help anyone. By the time such laws take effect, everyone with a credit card balance who is stupid enough to keep paying on it will already be paying a 30% APR -- which will, of course, be grandfathered in.
Reply to this comment
by janefondu April 23, 2009 11:25 PM EDT
loan sharks rates arent this high!!!
Reply to this comment
by kark741 April 23, 2009 11:20 PM EDT
You got Spam, I got Spam We all got Spam
its all on TV, its in our Mail box, its in the news paper, its on the radio,its in our Email and its even on out street conner, how to get rich. and we let it happen. I am up to my ears owning on bills so yes i to been spamed i pay my bills just like everyone else and the interest rate is high as a kit but i am paying them.
and once they are payd i am closeing that mess down.
The Spam MUST stop. Close them Down put them out of bussiness once and for all, and let do this the way we did it years ago but for the CC's were out.
Reply to this comment
by tiredofthebs April 23, 2009 10:51 PM EDT
The new administration is goin' at this all wrong. The financial sector is starting to TURN DOWN or RETURN TARP money. Translation, the Gov't. needs us more than we need them. Financial Institutions can impose even tighter restrictions on lenders, making the economic situation worse. I would continue negotiation before I tried strong arm tactics to impress/woo the American people. Just a thought ......
Reply to this comment
by homespunlady April 23, 2009 10:22 PM EDT
Posted by tincup356 at 5:41 PM : Apr 23, 2009

I'm not a rich scumbag but I too try to pay off in full when due.
It IS the smartest use of those financial instruments.

Occasionally, like when a bank backed out of my roofing loan at the last minute with the roofers waiting on my lawn to start - I resort ironically to "teaser rate" offers which I'm careful to pay off ASAP or at least tide me over until I can resolve the EMERGENCY.

I've seen far too many who DON'T understand what credit cards REALLY are - a "profit center" for lenders and for the astute - a way to track expenses while limiting the risk of cash or vulnerable checkbooks and time taken to acquire necessary loans.

Quite often for the "average person using a "debit card" is a MUCH SMARTER move if they want to use it for regular spending as they have become as "easy" to use but limit the "impulse" purchases.

I'm a FIRM ADVOCATE of FINANCIAL TRAINING in our public schools and suspect that many students would suddenly take a bigger interest in Math if they actually realized how they could win or lose in "real life" by understanding what the Banksters, government, casinos, etc. use it to take their paycheck.

At least the high school age kids I taught finances to are doing better than their peers by avoiding the traps and taking advantage of the opportunities by knowing the difference.

If you first create financial idiots by NOT teaching them and then Blame them for NOT KNOWING and consequently COSTING YOU in "personal bailouts" through taxes or charity - Who is REALLY the BIGGER FOOL!

PREVENTION through Knowledge WORKS!
Reply to this comment
by homespunlady April 23, 2009 9:57 PM EDT
For those that do pay off their cards every month -there's STILL a GOTCHA from the Credit card companies - the FEES they charge the companies that accept their cards.Some of those can be SEVERAL percentage points of whatever's been charged and the Businesses COVER THEIR EXPENSES by CHARGING YOU MORE.

So Nobody -even those that pay cash gets away from enriching the credit card companies.

They get us buying, borrowing AND paying.
It's a VERY PROFITABLE BUSINESS even if what I suggest occurs.

MY suggestion? BRING BACK the USURY LAWS we had a few decades ago!!

The states HAD laws on the books that kept lending at around 10 percent or so.

IT WORKED until lenders got GREEDY, Delaware broke ranks and suddenly the Credit card corporations ALL were headquartered there -then North Dakota DROPPED their USURY LAWS to get a piece of that greed pie and WALLAH!! The usury laws crumbled state by state.

So, with RECORD PROFITS the BANKSTERS LOBBIED for "protections" of THEIR USURY and GOT it with the Bankruptcy "reform" LAW that passed Congress a year or so ago!!!

CORRUPTION at it's FINEST!

We don't need to REINVENT THE WHEEL - Just REPEAL and RETURN the USURY LAWS that served this nation VERY WELL before the BANKSTERS bought Congress!
Reply to this comment
by tincup356 April 23, 2009 8:41 PM EDT
I say jack the interest rate to 50% I pay my cards every month so I pay 0%
Posted by dwilson59 at 5:01 PM : Apr 23, 2009 ...................................................
Big deal your are a rich scumbag who wants to brag about how good your doing financially.........ANYONE who sides with the greedy thieves is against America recovering......wishing ill economics upon the people of this country is about as unpatriotic as it gets....I bet you are one of those flag waving idiots that thinks the answer to everything is military action, and supports the two lie wars we are in now. Maybe another Madoff will end up with your riches and you can start worrying about how to eat and pay bills too, like millions of GOOD DECENT Americans are doing now because of ripoff tactics that corporate America is doing to the people.
Reply to this comment
by tincup356 April 23, 2009 8:32 PM EDT
Credit card companies are ORGANIZED CRIME endorsed by BOTH parties of congress,,,,,with their total lobby dollar blessing. They are ALL traitors who deserve to be charged with HIGH TREASON.,,,,,,,,FREEZING rates AFTER they increase them is just benefiting the credit card companies ,,,NOT THE PEOPLE ,,,,what needs to be done is set a limit on what they can charge,,,that is more in line with the discounted rate that THEY get OUR tax dollars for from the FED,,,,,,they pay less than 1%,,,,,and charge us 30%....HOW does this help the economy?,,,,,It doesn't.......it hurts it.
Reply to this comment
by toldyouso29 April 23, 2009 8:15 PM EDT
Indeed, as the executive from Bank of America met with the President, his company is the most aggregious offender; having recently (warrentlessly and unceremoniously) raised our APR to 25.99% effective May 1, 2009. The altenative provided to customers is to forfeit usage of the card. I think that may be a blessing in disguise.
Posted by aswar at 3:20 PM : Apr 23, 2009


When you forfeit the usage, your credit score goes down. Then other companies get to pile on...and if you pay your cards off too fast, there are penalties for that too (like a yearly fee)
Reply to this comment
by toldyouso29 April 23, 2009 8:13 PM EDT
"There's no one on either side of the aisle who does not want to have more transparency so that people know what they're getting into and what they're dealing with," Garrett told CBS News. "But with the credit market already tightening, now is not the time to make it even more difficult for the moderate-income family, with even more reasons to rely on his credit card, to find out he can't get one."


that is not the point and republicans know it. cREDIT CARD COMPANIES ARE UPPING THE RATES AND THEREFORE THE PAYMENTS FOR:

1. pEOPLE HAVING TOO MANY CREDIT CARDS
2. too many co. reviewing a credit score
3. to compensate for those who default
4. to prevent some folks from paying off to soon by upping the interest rate to minimize the principle payment
5. due to any inquiries on your credit score, no matter how good
6. Because a person lives in a certain region or area

Or my personal favorite: because one of the reporting companies has looked at your credit score, determined it was too high, and readjusted the rate, even at 839 (which is excellent credit) such a move justifies increases in interest.
these moves are what make it harder for people to pay off their cards--but then, cc companies really don't want consumers to lower their debt anymore than the big pharm wants healthy clients...it would sort of defeat the purpose, now wouldn't it?
Reply to this comment
See all 25 Comments

About Econwatch

News and analysis on the state of the economy from CBS News.

E-Mail EconWatch

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn