Horserace
September 25, 2008 4:51 PM

Liberal Groups Attack McCain's Health

(WASHINGTON) Two liberal political action committees, Brave New PAC and Democracy for America, launched an aggressive attack on John McCain's health this morning in an ad featuring unflattering images of his melanoma scars. The ad calls for McCain to release his medical records, something he already did earlier this year.

"Another bout of cancer for John McCain while he is president of the United States would profoundly impact his capacity lead," Dr. Michael D. Fratkin says in the ad. "Melanoma is the deadliest of skin cancers," Dr. Noah Craft then explains, adding "the chances of survival if you have melanoma spread through your body are very slim." The ad closes with a graphic asking, "Why won't John McCain release his Medical Records?"

The 30-second television spot is set to run on MSNBC in a $50,000 buy over a few days. The groups hope to extend the buy to battleground states or possibly purchase a full page ad in the NY Times in the coming weeks if they are able to raise necessary funds through donations from supporters.

"Special interest attack ads are part of what is wrong with Washington," Republican National Committee spokesman Alex Conant said in response. "It is absurd that Barack Obama's allies would be attacking John McCain at a moment when when we are trying to put politics aside."

In addition to the ad, the groups initiated a petition for doctors with the hopes that with enough signatures they will "ultimately deliver the petition and create enough grassroots support to get a full disclosure of the [medical] records,” Brave New PAC spokesman Axel Woolfolk told CBS News. So far they say they have collected 2,500 signatures.

However, the thing is, McCain has released his medical records.

On May 23, a small group of reporters were sequestered in a reading room outside of Phoenix, Ariz., and given several hours to review 1,173 pages of McCain's medical records spanning from 2000 to 2008. In 2000, during McCain's first presidential bid, his campaign released hundreds of pages of medical records including psychological tests run after his prisoner of war confinement.

There is in fact a precedent for releasing medical and other records in a highly supervised and time-limited way. In 2004, a small group of reporters traveling with John Kerry were allowed a half-hour to review 36 pages of his military medical records. According to the New York Times, the Kerry campaign argued their review parameters were generous compared to the 20 minutes the White House allowed reporters earlier that year to review Bush's military medical records.

"We don't think its misleading at all," Woolfork said when asked about the May records release, "this release was so limited it wasn't really a release, it was a press stunt."

"It was extensively reported that this release was done in three hours, no cells, no internet no cameras," he added.

Meanwhile, the liberal MoveOn.org secured a $100,000 national cable buy today to run an ad which attacks McCain for his association to Rick Davis, Phil Gramm and President Bush, who the ad argues contributed to the financial crisis. "Americans shouldn't have to foot the bill for mistakes that John McCain and his friends made," a narrator claims.

The McCain campaign announced Wednesday that they will suspend all campaign events, including pulling down all television and radio ads, until Congress reaches a deal on the financial bailout.
Tags:
john mccain ,
health ,
Melanoma ,
Brave New PAC ,
Democracy for America
Topics:
Advertising
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 22 Comments
by nhtom-2009 September 27, 2008 8:19 PM EDT
I didn''t see any advertisement, but evidence indicates that Senator McCain%u2019s melanoma is more serious than some suggest.
His physicians%u2019 statements at the time of the release of his medical records (quoting a clinical staging of IIa) appears to discount details of the pathology report that was also reported in May, 2008.
Based on information published by the New York Times (and subsequently uncontested), Senator McCain had tissue removed from his left temple that included both a 2.2 mm deep lesion AND an adjacent %u201Csatellite%u201D lesion.
Using internationally accepted, evidence-based pathological criteria (the %u201CGold-standard%u201D), a 2.2 mm primary lesion plus any satellite lesion yields T3aN2cM0/Mx, using TNM (tumor, node, metastases) criteria. This yields at least pathological Stage IIIb melanoma. If this is NOT TRUE, Senator McCain''s team can easily refute it with release of the pathologists'' report.
According to a peer-reviewed medical article on the subject, %u201CThe estimated five year survival for Stage IIIb patients is 53%.%u201D(pg.143)
A fifteen-year Kaplan-Meier survival curve in the same reference, demonstrates that there is no actual late plateau phase for Stage IIIb melanoma. Only about 40% of patient%u2019s with Stage IIIb disease survive to 10 years. (Figure 4)
(Reference: Balch CM, etal. An Evidence-based Staging System for Cutaneous Melanoma. CA Cancer. J Clin 2004;54:131%u2013149)
Reply to this comment
by carol16451 September 27, 2008 3:22 PM EDT
Has anyone seen Biden''s medical record???? Hasn''t he had some serious problems?
Reply to this comment
by kanig September 26, 2008 6:06 PM EDT
Sen. McCain did NOT release his medical records. He allowed a small handful of non-medically trained reporters, carefully selected by the McCain campaign, three hours to review 1173 pages of highly technical medical records, with no ability to copy anything. That''s less than 10 seconds per page. Having watched Gov. Palin''s most recent interviews with Katie Couric, I regard the possibility of Palin suddenly assuming the presidency as utterly terrifying. So, yes, this ad very deliberately gets attention in a way that is not entirely respectful of Sen. McCain''s privacy. I would reply that Sen. McCain''s selection of Sarah Palin shows not onlyh lack of respect but complete contempt for the United States.
Reply to this comment
by kanig September 26, 2008 6:02 PM EDT
Giving a small handful of non-medically trained reporters, carefully selected by the McCain campaign, three hours to review 1173 pages of highly technical medical records, with no ability to copy anything, by no stretch of the imagination can be accurately characterized by saying that ''McCain HAS released his medical records''. Having watched Gov. Palin''s most recent interviews with Katie Couric, I regard the possibility of Palin suddenly assuming the presidency as utterly terrifying. So, yes, this ad very deliberately gets attention in a way that is not entirely respectful of Sen. McCain''s privacy. I would reply that Sen. McCain''s selection of Sarah Palin shows not only lack of respect but complete contempt for the United States.
Reply to this comment
by kanig September 26, 2008 6:01 PM EDT
Giving a small handful of non-medically trained REPORTERS, carefully selected by the McCain campaign, three hours to review 1173 pages of highly technical medical records, with no ability to copy anything, by no stretch of the imagination can be accurately characterized by saying that "McCain HAS released his medical records". Having watched Gov. Palin''s most recent interviews with Katie Couric, I regard the possibility of Palin suddenly assuming the presidency as utterly terrifying. So, yes, this ad very deliberately gets attention in a way that is not entirely respectful of Sen. McCain''s privacy. I would reply that Sen. McCain''s selection of Sarah Palin shows not only lack of respect but complete contempt for the United States.
Reply to this comment
by kanig September 26, 2008 5:56 PM EDT
Giving a small handful of non-medically trained REPORTERS, carefully selected by the McCain campaign, three hours to review 1173 pages of highly technical medical records, with no ability to copy anything, by no stretch of the imagination can be accurately characterized by saying that "McCain HAS released his medical records". Having watched Gov. Palin''s most recent interviews with Katie Couric, I regard the possibility of Palin suddenly assuming the presidency as utterly terrifying. So, yes, this ad very deliberately gets attention in a way that is not entirely respectful of Sen. McCain''s privacy. I would reply that Sen. McCain''s selection of Sarah Palin shows not only lack of respect but complete contempt for the United States.
Reply to this comment
by ilgoldstein September 26, 2008 6:34 AM EDT
I am a staunch Obama supporter, a lifelong Democrat and no friend of McCain. I saw the ad and thought it was disgusting.

I''m still not voting for McCain. I still support Obama. I just did not like that ad.
Reply to this comment
by kansas1946 September 26, 2008 3:29 AM EDT
Senator Obama has repeatedly stated that this is the largest financial crisis that this nation has faced since the Great Depression, yet it also appears that he is not willingly to be on the front-lines, let alone cast a vote on what could be the most important piece of financial legislation since the Great Depression
****************************
Say what?? When did Obama say he wouldn''t vote on this?
Reply to this comment
by kansas1946 September 26, 2008 3:28 AM EDT
Although I am a huge Obama fan and fully support him, I think these ads are dispicible and that Obama should censure these groups. I know that he, or McCain for that matter, can not control these private groups, they certainly should not be encouraged by silence. If they think they are helping Obama, then they are delusional.
Reply to this comment
by greenfun September 26, 2008 2:11 AM EDT
By Obama''s Definition, British Prime Minister Brown Unable To Multitask!
Personally, I always thought the mark of governmental leadership was the ability to prioritize, not to multi-task. However, it appears that to Senator Obama a Foreign Policy Debate holds the same level of prioritization as the meltdown of US financial system. Senator Obama has repeatedly stated that this is the largest financial crisis that this nation has faced since the Great Depression, yet it also appears that he is not willingly to be on the front-lines, let alone cast a vote on what could be the most important piece of financial legislation since the Great Depression
Reply to this comment
by PulSamsara September 26, 2008 1:41 AM EDT
Cancer Ads = Stupid...

About as Junior High school cheesy as the General BetrayUs ads...
They are counter productive...
Dumb@$$es.
---------------------------
Why would America REWARD complete Republican failure ?

We wont.

Reply to this comment
by ajm072 September 26, 2008 1:09 AM EDT
What''s up with McCain''s left eye? Is it me or is it a bit more droopy than ususal? Stroke possible? Possible reason to "postpone" debate?
Reply to this comment
by lbinak September 25, 2008 11:48 PM EDT
dburfears,
Need you be reminded of G Wuubya''s admitted cocaine use?? He''s been ruining the country now for 8 years without any of the complications you mentioned.
Reply to this comment
by greenfun September 25, 2008 10:24 PM EDT
In The Chicago Sun Times today.


Obama grant being probed
$100,000 DEAL | State to charity: What happened to garden money, other cash?

Recommend (202) Comments
September 25, 2008
BY CHRIS FUSCO AND DAVE MCKINNEY
Obama''s $100K Grant for a Garden Never Built

More videos
; Click to enlarge image

A group headed gy Kenny B. Smith (top right) was awarded a state grant by then-state Sen. Barack Obama to create a botanic garden in Englewood. Plans now call for the city to take back the garden site because the project never happened. Attorney General Lisa Madigan is investigating.
(Keith Hale/Sun-Times/AP)


RELATED STORIES
Video: Grant for a garden never built
Exclusive: Obama''s $100K (unbuilt )garden
Special section: Barack Obama
More in Watchdogs

A $100,000 state grant for a botanic garden in Englewood that then-state Sen. Barack Obama awarded in 2001 to a group headed by a onetime campaign volunteer is now under investigation by the Illinois attorney general amid new questions, prompted by Chicago Sun-Times reports, about whether the money might have been misspent.

The garden was never built. And now state records obtained by the Sun-Times show $65,000 of the grant money went to the wife of

Kenny B. Smith, the Obama 2000 congressional campaign volunteer who heads the Chicago Better Housing Association, which was in charge of the project for the blighted South Side neighborhood.
Reply to this comment
by thisniss September 25, 2008 9:39 PM EDT
The McCain campaign has NOT suspended anything - they still have ads running where I live (North Carolina), and their offices and phonebanks are all open. Like everything else in the McCain campaign, the truth of the "suspension" is different from what McCain says it is.
Reply to this comment
by da1215 September 25, 2008 9:22 PM EDT
This is very true and I think that Americans need to know about this. I know because a recurrance of melanoma killed my mother in 4 months time. Sarah Palin would be president. ARGH!
Reply to this comment
by dburfears September 25, 2008 9:17 PM EDT

Obama PRIVATELY called McCain at 8:30 Thursday morning to work through a TRULY BIPARTISAN EFFORT.

Why not WORK WITH OBAMA FIRST before making a TOTALLY POLITICAL MOVE? - POLITICS

So McCain says to himself "HEY, WE CAN MAKE SOME POLITICAL POINTS IF WE MAKE IT LOOK LIKE IT WAS OUR IDEA!"

THEN McCAIN HURRIES OUT AND SAYS "MY IDEA, MY IDEA!"

If McCain REALLY wanted this to be a "Country First" moment, he would have AGREED TO OBAMA''S BIPARTISAN PROPOSAL. Instead MCCAIN USED THIS for POLITICAL GAIN.

It''s clear- McCain wanted to get a big CAMPAIGN SPLASH. His claims of BIPARTISANSHIP are a SHAM.

If MCCAIN REALLY MEANT IT - HE WOULD HAVE DONE THE JOINT STATEMENT THAT OBAMA CALLED HIM ABOUT THURSDAY MORNING. THEY COULD HAVE JOINTLY ANNOUNCED A BIPARTISAN INITIATIVE. Instead McCain made his "splash" then later agreed to a joint statement.

MCCAIN IS SLIME.
Reply to this comment
by kristiann85 September 25, 2008 9:11 PM EDT
So, why no searching about the long term effects of Obama''s admitted cocaine use? Last I knew cocaine related health problems include:

-Cardiovascular problems, including irregular heartbeat, heart attack, and heart failure
-Sleeplessness or sexual dysfunction
-Diminished sense of smell or perforated nasal septum
-Nausea, and headaches
-Neurological incidents, including strokes, seizures, fungal brain infections, and hemorrhaging in tissue surrounding the brain
-Pulmonary effects, such as fluid in the lungs, aggravation of asthma and other lung disorders, and respiratory failure
-Psychiatric complications, including psychosis, paranoia, depression, anxiety disorders, and delusions
-Increased risk of traumatic injury from accidents and aggressive, violent, or criminal behavior

I''d like to see Obama''s medical records. Any pulmonary issues from his excessive addiction to heavy smoking.
The way I see it, he''s not fit to be president.
Reply to this comment
by skyk239 September 25, 2008 9:03 PM EDT
This country wants doers, not talkers.


Liberals are idiots.
Plain & simple.

Posted by john43218 at 05:22 PM : Sep 25, 2008


Oh YEAH! He answered it alright... a WEEK late and AFTER he told us the Fundamentals of the Economy were strong, proposed a 9/11 Commission to "Study" the Crisis, Opposed the accepted the AIG Bail Out, LIED about the connection between the head of his Campaign and Fannie Mae, THEN when the Debates get close all of a sudden he responds? LOL With someone like that responding to the 3 AM call, we would be under a NEW Government before he acts!! LMAO
Reply to this comment
by judyplace September 25, 2008 8:56 PM EDT
If there is nothing wrong with John McCain''s health he should have no problems opeing his mediucal records to assure the American people that he is healthy. I am concerned because he have not proven to be be the most honest person so far in this race. Whay should I trust him on this, especially with his face so swollen.
Reply to this comment
See all 22 Comments

About Horserace

Description for Horserace

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn