Horserace
August 19, 2008 11:02 AM

DNC Looks To Exploit McCain's "$5 Million" Comment

At Saturday evening's forum at Saddleback Church, Pastor Rick Warren asked both Barack Obama and John McCain what it meant for someone to be rich.

"I would argue that if you are making more than $250,000, then you are in the top 3, 4 percent of this country," said Obama. "You are doing well."

McCain, however, spoke for a minute and a half and then threw out a much higher number.

"I think if you're just talking about income, how about $5 million?" he said.

McCain was laughing as he made the comment, and added, "I'm sure that comment will be distorted." His campaign later said the candidate was joking.

Still, it's worth noting that nowhere in his response to Warren, other than in the comment above, did McCain explain what he considered rich.

He did say this: "The point is that we want to keep people’s taxes low, and increase revenues…it doesn’t matter really what my definition of rich is because I don’t want to raise anybody’s taxes." (You can watch the full exchange here.)

Now the Democratic National Committee has released a video spotlighting McCain's comment.

It opens with McCain's "$5 million" statement and then fades out as the words "Only 1 Out Of 1,000 Americans Make More Than $5 Million" appear onscreen.

McCain's claim that the "comment will be distorted" is not shown in the video.

The spot goes onto spotlight McCain and his wife's 2006 income and claim the candidate will save more than $370,000 under the McCain tax plan. It then cuts to former McCain advisor Phil Gramm's comments that "we've sort of become a nation of whiners."

It concludes with the words, "The point is John McCain is out of touch."

UPDATE: A response from Republican National Committee spokeswoman Amber Wilkerson: "Despite the DNC’s attempts to divert attention from Barack Obama’s shifting economic policies, voters can count on the fact that his plans will further hinder our struggling economy by raising taxes on American families and small businesses.”

Tags:
john mccain ,
5 million ,
rich
Topics:
Democrats
Share:
  • Share
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Mixx
Add a Comment See all 29 Comments
by mattcat25 August 20, 2008 12:59 PM EDT
"bleeding heart liberals want to walk away from responsibilities to our allies and all people that wish for freedom against communism and totalitarian rule."

"so in november when America elects John "war hero" McCain as our next Commander in Chief you can rest assure that he will seek out and destroy our enemies wherever they hide."
Posted by bswalker12


John the %u201Csuper hero%u201D McCain?

He ducks (slowly) into a phone booth (or, where there used to be phone booths) and removes his top clothes to reveal (not superman) but, %u201COLD MAN!%u201D

Faster then a sleeping snail!
Stronger then a toy locomotive with spent batteries!
He can leap, he can sort of%u2026.well, he can barely walk.

It%u2019s not bird, it%u2019s not a (world war I) biplane, IT%u2019S SUPER GRAMPY!!!!




Reply to this comment
by ipublius August 19, 2008 7:24 PM EDT
When told that the people had no bread, he said "let them eat cake"

The current economic condition is no joking matter. Our way of life has been stolen by the policies that favor the rich.

Reply to this comment
by notintaxachu August 19, 2008 6:12 PM EDT
Still no one able to figure out that $250,000 is only considered "rich" in certain areas of this country?? Is that per household, or per individual???
Reply to this comment
by jmurrieta1 August 19, 2008 6:03 PM EDT
"Us Hillary supporters are offended by not only the way you treated the Clintons during the primary, but your gross mismanagement of the Obama campaign. The problems always start at the top. Pelosi and Dean have to go."--Posted by elevando



Hillary supporter eh? I think we can read "Bush supporter".

Another Neocon Repug shill.

Discount it!
Reply to this comment
by jmurrieta1 August 19, 2008 6:02 PM EDT
McCain translation:

"I have 10 houses and my wife is worth lots and lots of money from the sale of beer, so I really don''t know what the guys who pull my strings want me to say so I''ll make something up then laugh to pretend I don''t really believe it."

If you have liked 8 years of having a brain-dead puppet as president, McCain is your man.

For the rest of us--Obama ''08.
Reply to this comment
by mrtutto August 19, 2008 5:18 PM EDT
How are we supposed to know when McCain is joking ? Is it whenever he opens his mouth ? Is it his failing memory. Just because he says afterward that It was a joke, doesn''t make it so....
Why do we need a President with a sense of humor, I''ll bet he will just stand there and laugh as he BOMB BOMB BOMB BOMB BOMBS Iran.
Reply to this comment
by mrtutto August 19, 2008 5:13 PM EDT
At some point McCain has to stop using jokes to cover up for his incompetence....... The best line from this campaign has been when McCain misspoke on a position. Right away his handlers came out with this." Senator McCain does not speak for this campaign " If that''s not rich, I don''t know what is.
Reply to this comment
by deacon20081 August 19, 2008 4:48 PM EDT
Orrin Hatch sent me an Email asking for $7.00 for the Republican Party expenses of sending protesters to disrupt the Democratic Convention. $7.00 a head for all those talking heads!

ROTFL
Reply to this comment
by getcentered August 19, 2008 4:37 PM EDT
Republicans are deserting their Party''s "brand name" and lining up to sweep the entire party''s slate of national and state candidates into the dustbin. And, Independent voters are turning their backs on the GOP. National Security starts at home with a strong economy.
The story across this summer will be the national outrage at what the Republicans have done to our economy.

Events are overtaking the national dialogue about race and gender -- we are Americans first and we have started doing something about the attack on our national wellbeing.
All Republicans must go---all must be pushed from their seats of power -- and cast aside in 2008. Every single Republican candidate must be held accountable for their support of the Bush Presidency and its horrendous impact on our nation.

From Maine to Hawaii --- Republicans must be defeated so that we can restore our American priorities and American values. They had their chance -they chose to support Bush - they chose to borrow, borrow, borrow and then -spend and spend and spend -- now they must pay.
Reply to this comment
by kname2 August 19, 2008 4:24 PM EDT
hmmm,...$5 mil a year sounds rich to me...I think y''all are reading wayyyy too much into this. The more worrisome comment is that only 3 to 4% make $250K a year.
Reply to this comment
by kname2 August 19, 2008 4:23 PM EDT
hmmm,...$5 mil a year sounds rich to me...I think y''all are reading wayyyy too much into this. The more worrisome comment is that only 3 to 4% make $250K a year.
Reply to this comment
by notintaxachu August 19, 2008 4:03 PM EDT
McCain is correct. It''s not up to the government to decide who is rich....$250,000 is a lot of money if you live in Mississippi, Alabama, Texas, the goes on. It''s not a lot of money in the Northeast, or California!! Whose out of touch now?? Talk to individuals in NYC who can''t buy an apartment for a family for less than $1 million.
Reply to this comment
by elevando August 19, 2008 4:01 PM EDT
Can this commercial even be considered a swing and a miss. C''mon, DNC, it is a Democratic year and this is the best you''ve got?

Us Hillary supporters are offended by not only the way you treated the Clintons during the primary, but your gross mismanagement of the Obama campaign. The problems always start at the top. Pelosi and Dean have to go.

Reply to this comment
by getcentered August 19, 2008 3:58 PM EDT
The mismanagement of the American "brand" has been recognized by the American electorate, and can be seen in the facts related to the huge number of Congressional seats now "in play." Reports confirm that scores of additional Republican Congressional districts are now considered ready to shift away from the failures of a "Republican" administration that has spent the nation into near bankruptcy.

Big spending Republicans are directly to blame. That''s right, Borrow and Spend, Republicans. What happened to fiscal conservatism? ...ask George W. Bush!!

Normally, Congressional seats are not influenced by American foreign policy blunders, but today, a combination of rising unemployment and skyrocketing gas prices have awoken the American voter to the fact that there is a direct connection between Republican foreign policy and economic crises here at home. Our economy and our children''s future have been mortgaged to China, so Bush could pay for HIS WAR.

The results seem to be pointing toward a tsunami of voter rejection for Republican candidates who are properly seen as aiding and abetting the Bush War in Iraq and the wholesale transfer of American jobs overseas. Blind support by Republicans for Bush has exacerbated our economic crises. And, the Republican "old hands" know it; they are retiring from Congress in droves.
Reply to this comment
by chatchoocho1 August 19, 2008 3:54 PM EDT
I guess the Dems need to make an issue out of something, Obama was trounched in the debate even though they both were given the subjects covered before-hand.
I guess the truth is above his "pay grade". looks like obama is trying to lose the election, Joe Biden as V.P. Come on, choose anyone else.
And the NBC "Cone of Silence flap", they must be in a "Cone of Stupidity", at least Olympic coverage is good, can''t say the same for objectivity. Go Fox News.
Reply to this comment
by pete691982 August 19, 2008 3:52 PM EDT
what about Obama''s $25 million comment? he was obviously joking as well, but nobody''s distorting that.
Reply to this comment
by ap_htown August 19, 2008 3:50 PM EDT
With an elite like McCain with income of way more then $5mil he thought 5mil is a conservatively accepted number tobe considered rich only to know most americans won''t make this much in their lifetime let alone in a single year. Shows how out of touch McCain is from the average working american family.
Reply to this comment
by timofmars1 August 19, 2008 3:49 PM EDT
Translated McCain:

"Gee, yes, Obama''s cuts will provide more tax breaks to 80% of Americans than my plan, and his plan will provide 800 billion in additional revenue while mine will result in 600 billion additional deficit... But at least I won''t raise anyone''s taxes, and I will just tell you that I want to raise revenues magically while giving the vast majority of breaks to those making over 5 million.

http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3251/2766543786_3f16407ed7_o.png
Reply to this comment
by getcentered August 19, 2008 3:49 PM EDT
Will the Real Tax-and-Spender Please %u2019Fess Up?

%u201CMcCain is picking the areas where rates go up and ignoring the areas where Obama is trying to rebalance the tax code so that taxpayers would save,%u201D said John Irons, research and policy director at the Economic Policy Institute, which is generally viewed as sympathetic to working families. Mr. Irons said that %u201Cthe important thing is to look at overall impact on people%u201D and that on this score, %u201Cthe vast majority of the population, almost the entirety of the middle class, would see more from Obama than McCain.%u201D

Economists have also criticized the methodology behind Mr. McCain%u2019s assertion that Americans from all kinds of backgrounds could end up paying thousands of dollars more in taxes if Mr. Obama got his way. Several criticized him as apparently basing his claim on an average figure in which, as Mr. Irons said, %u201CBill Gates is mixed with you and me, and everything gets skewed.%u201D

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/13/us/politics/13check.html


On drilling, taxes and the economy......I''ve found that McCain will lie right to your face with no fear of retribution from the media.
Reply to this comment
by allurfears August 19, 2008 3:45 PM EDT
Cindy McCain needs every penny to ensure she can continue spending $75,000 per MONTH on her credit cards.

ANYONE who thinks these ELITISTS give d*mn about the American Middle Class are fooling themselves.
Reply to this comment
See all 29 Comments

About Horserace

Description for Horserace

Add to your favorite news reader
google
yahoo
msn