Watch CBS News

"Duck boat" crash witness: There were bodies everywhere

Investigators with the NTSB are heading to the scene in Washington
Four dead after duck boat hits bus on Seattle bridge 02:23

SEATTLE -- A fun day designed to introduce new international college students to Seattle turned into a nightmare when a "duck boat" tour vehicle collided into their charter bus on a busy bridge, killing four students and injuring dozens.

Deadly bus collision in Seattle 01:34

Rujia Xie and other North Seattle College students were on their way to the city's iconic Pike Place Market and Safeco Field for new student orientation events Thursday when she heard the crash from the back of the bus.

She smelled gas and felt glass falling on her face. She and others jumped from the bus.

Traveling in the opposite direction, two Philadelphia friends on a road trip across the country, Brad Volm and Bradley Sawhill, were cruising over picturesque Lake Union when they said they saw the duck boat's left tire "lock up" as it swerved into the charter bus, T-boning it. Their SUV hit another truck head-on, but they escaped injuries.

"It all happened so fast. I got out of my car, and there were just bodies, just everywhere. People lying in the street," Volm said.

At a news conference Friday, North Seattle College President Warren Brown identified the students who died as Privaudo Putradauto, 18, of Indonesia; Mami Sato, 37, of Japan; and Claudia Derschmidt, 49, of Austria, who was in Seattle with her 15-year-old son. Brown did not name a 17-year-old girl from China because she is a minor, but her family has been notified.

Investigators are pictured at the scene of a crash between a Ride the Ducks vehicle and a charter bus on the Aurora Avenue bridge in Seattle, Washington, Sept. 24, 2015.
Investigators are pictured at the scene of a crash between a Ride the Ducks vehicle and a charter bus on the Aurora Avenue bridge in Seattle, Washington, Sept. 24, 2015. Reuters/Jason Redmond

"There are still wounds in our heart," Brown said. "For someone to come from another country, to learn here, to be excited about an opportunity ... and to have this tragedy occur, is painful."

All were new to the college. They and dozens of other students were on a tour of city landmarks, such as Pike Place Market, before classes were set to begin Monday.

College spokeswoman Melissa Mixon said 45 students and staff were on one of two charter buses traveling downtown. "It was to be a fun introduction to Seattle," she said.

Students and faculty, some arm in arm, filed into a private memorial service in a lecture hall Friday to honor the four students.

"Sad doesn't even begin to describe how people feel," Mixon said.

The amphibious vehicle is operated by a tour company called Ride the Ducks, which offers tours known for exuberant drivers and guides who play loud music and quack through speakers as they lead tourists around the city.

The collision on the Aurora Bridge, which carries one of the city's main north-south highways over the lake, left a tangled mess of twisted metal, shattered glass and blood, witnesses said.

Firefighters assist victims after a crash between a bus and a tour vehicle on the Aurora Avenue bridge in Seattle, Washington, in this picture from the Seattle Fire Department Sept. 24, 2015.
Firefighters assist victims after a crash between a bus and a tour vehicle on the Aurora Avenue bridge in Seattle, Washington, in this picture from the Seattle Fire Department Sept. 24, 2015. Seattle Fire Department/Handout via Reuters

Authorities say 51 people were taken to area hospitals. Susan Gregg, a spokeswoman for Harborview Medical Center, said in a statement early Friday that one person is in critical condition and 11 are in serious condition in intensive care, Gregg said. Three others are in satisfactory condition.

At the University of Washington Medical Center, two people are in serious condition, and two others are in satisfactory condition at Northwest Hospital & Medical Center, Gregg said.

The stretch of highway where the accident took place reopened for traffic about 11 p.m. Thursday, the state Transportation Department said. The National Transportation Safety Board sent a team of 17 people to Seattle, and Mayor Ed Murray said they were taking over the investigation.

There was no immediate word about the cause of the crash, which involved a military-style tour bus that can also be operated on water. Initial reports described the accident as a head-on collision.

Three dozen people were on board the duck boat, as well as the driver, who is certified by the Coast Guard and a licensed commercial driver, company President Brian Tracey said. He said he did not know what happened or caused the crash.

"We will get to the bottom of it," he told The Associated Press. "Our main concern right now is with the families of those hurt and killed."

A group of young people are moved away from a crash scene after a "Ride the Ducks" vehicle and a charter bus were involved in an accident on the Aurora Avenue bridge in Seattle, Washington, Sept. 24, 2015.
A group of young people are moved away from a crash scene after a "Ride the Ducks" vehicle and a charter bus were involved in an accident on the Aurora Avenue bridge in Seattle, Washington, Sept. 24, 2015. Reuters/Jason Redmond

Murray said the company had voluntarily taken the duck boats off city streets for the time being.

Tracey told CBS Seattle affiliate KIRO-TV his vehicles have clean safety records.

"We've passed with flying colors all the time," he told the station. "We go way above what is ever, ever required by the DOT or the Coast Guard, way above it."

Tracey said cameras are on the front and back of the tour vehicles, but it's unclear if video of the crash was recorded and, if it was, whether it survived the crash, KIRO-TV's Jeff Dubois reports.

Tourists on board the duck boat told reporters they were snapping pictures when they say they were thrown from the vehicle.

Lying in his hospital bed, Tim Gesner, 61, of Orlando, Florida, told The Seattle Times he was standing in the back of the duck boat and trying to take a picture with his cellphone after their tour guide pointed out the view. He felt the vehicle start to fish-tail, and the driver said, "Oh, no." Gesner looked forward and had a clear view of the duck boat veering left, directly into the bus.

"Then next thing was it's like you see in the movies," he told The Times. "I was floating in this surreal world, like I was in slow motion bouncing off of things and just feeling the pain shooting everywhere and then my face slamming against the seat in front of me and then it was quiet. I just turned and looked, and that's when I saw the carnage."

Witnesses described hearing a loud screech and then seeing injured people lying on the pavement or wandering around in a daze.

Nurse Jahna Dyer was walking across the bridge when she came upon the scene. Some victims were lying on the road. Others milled about, seemingly in shock and falling down.

Dyer jumped a railing separating the sidewalk from the roadway and helped stabilize an injured man's neck. She said she also helped a woman who had a cut lip and glass in her eye. "She was holding my hand and saying thank you," she said.

John Mundell said he was at the south end of the bridge when the crash occurred. "We could hear the screech and twisted metal. It was surreal," he said. "I felt helpless."

Kuen Shouh Wu says his 18-year-old daughter was on the charter bus, but she was not hurt. He and his daughter, Ming Chao Wu, are from Taiwan, and he is a visiting scholar at the University of Washington. Wu said when he learned of the accident, he came to the school.

"I was scared," he said. "I don't know why it happened."

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.