New data ties earthquakes to wastewater injection

Chad Devereaux examines bricks that fell from three sides of his in-laws home in Sparks, Okla. on Sunday, Nov. 6, 2011 after two earthquakes hit the area in less than 24 hours.

AP

The more oil and gas companies pump their saltwater waste into the ground, and the faster they do it, the more they have triggered earthquakes in the central United States, a massive new study found.

An unprecedented recent jump in quakes in America's heartland can be traced to the stepped up rate that drilling wastewater is injected deep below the surface, according to a study in Thursday's journal Science that looked at 187,570 injection wells over four decades.

It's not so much the average-sized injection wells, but the supercharged ones that are causing the ground to shake. Wells that pumped more than 12 million gallons of saltwater into the ground per month were far more likely to trigger quakes than those that put lesser amounts per month, the study from the University of Colorado found.

Although Texas, Arkansas, Kansas and other states have seen increases in earthquakes, the biggest jump has been in Oklahoma. From 1974 to 2008, Oklahoma averaged about one magnitude 3 or greater earthquake a year, but in 2013 and 2014, the state averaged more than 100 quakes that size per year, according to another earthquake study published Thursday. Since Jan. 1, the U.S. Geological Survey has logged more than 350 magnitude 3 or higher quakes in Oklahoma.

Studies have linked the increase in quakes to the practice of injecting leftover wastewater into the ground after drilling for oil and gas using newer technologies, such as hydraulic fracturing. Recent studies have linked the damaging 2011 magnitude 5.7 quake that hit Prague, Oklahoma, to a nearby high-rate injection well.

In a Stanford University study that confirmed the link between wastewater injections and quakes, the authors found that in three areas of the state that have seen a lot of seismic activity - Cherokee, Perry and Jones - most of wastewater injected was naturally occurring in the ground and generated using conventional oil extraction techniques, not fracking.

"We know that some of the produced water came from wells that were hydraulically fractured, but in the three areas of most seismicity, over 95 percent of the wastewater disposal is produced water, not hydraulic fracturing flowback water," said Stanford University professor Mark Zoback, an author on the study.

Injecting the brackish wastewater back where it came from, instead of into the Arbuckle formation, a disposal zone that sits directly above the rock layer where earthquake faults lie, could help reduce the chances of future quakes.

"The earthquakes in Oklahoma would have happened eventually," said coauthor Rall Walsh. "But by injecting water into the faults and pressurizing them, we've advanced the clock and made them occur today."

The paper was also published Thursday, in the journal Science Advances.

wastewater-injection.jpg
Large volumes of highly saline water extracted along with oil and gas from some producing formations gets injected into a deep disposal zone, the Arbuckle Formation, which sits directly upon crystalline basement rocks. Rising pore pressure in the Arbuckle Formation can penetrate already-stressed basement faults and trigger earthquakes.
Steven Than/Stanford University

Stretching far beyond the borders of Oklahoma, the new University of Colorado study looked at 18,757 wells that were associated with earthquakes within 9 miles of them and the nearly 170,000 that didn't have any quake links. The wells were located across the central and eastern U.S. Looking for the difference between the two groups, researchers determined that it was how much wastewater was pumped and how fast, said lead author Matthew Weingarten.

Even though quake-associated wells were only 10 percent of those studied, more than 60 percent of the high-rate wells - 12 million gallons or more - were linked to nearby earthquakes, the study found.

And of the 45 wells that pump the most saltwater at the fastest rate, 34 of them - more than three out of four - were linked to nearby quakes, the study found.

Physically, it makes sense because "high-rate injection creates much higher pressure over the relative time scale," said study co-author Shemin Ge, a hydrogeology professor at the University of Colorado.

Possible other factors Weingarten and Ge looked, such as cumulative amounts of saltwater injected or depth, didn't show up as significant in the large database.

The Stanford study, conversely, pointed more toward cumulative amounts of liquid rather than high rates. But study Zoback said both papers can be right because factors might be slightly different in Oklahoma than elsewhere.

Seismologist Susan Hough of the U.S. Geological Survey called the Weingarten study both compelling and hopeful - hopeful because it means that energy drillers can change the way they inject wastewater and thereby lessen the number of earthquakes.