Deadly Oakland "Ghost Ship" warehouse inferno started next door, defendant's lawyers claim
OAKLAND — Lawyers for a man who is the subject of an investigation and lawsuit over the infamous Ghost Ship warehouse fire that killed 36 people in Oakland have publicized a report they claim casts doubt on his culpability.
CBS San Francisco reports that the lawyers for Derick Ion Almena, the warehouse master tenant, said Monday that their investigation “should reasonably foreclose any criminal negligence charges against” their client.
The ten-page document titled “Was Ghost Ship fire caused by inadequate Utility Wiring?” seeks to cast doubt on Almena’s responsibility by, in part, suggesting that the fire originated in the warehouse next to the Ghost Ship, not inside the artist enclave itself.
The report, compiled by Almena’s legal team, which includes well-known defense attorney Tony Serra, reads like an expert witness analysis of the fire and runs through technical explanations focused on the building’s PG&E power supply. The report appears to be an effort by his lawyers to expand on earlier allegations that the government was responsible for the fire.
“(T)here appears to be a single feed that goes in to the (neighboring) building to serve multiple customers,” the report says. “It also appears that there is fire affecting more than just the Ghost Ship occupied section.”
The report, illustrated by several photographs and a diagram that purports to show the building’s external PG&E connections, says there is no direct utility connection to the Ghost Ship warehouse and that the connection to the warehouse next door is “undersized.”
Also, some kind of electrical equipment was on a pole secured to the roof of the neighboring warehouse but that equipment “was removed post fire,” according to the report.
“Did the equipment now removed catch fire or was it the point of origin,” the report asks.
A lawyer for the families of two people killed in the Dec. 2 fire dismissed the report as irrelevant.
“Wherever the fire started, and I’m not saying it was next door, the people couldn’t get out and it’s because of (Almena) building this makeshift second floor (and) makeshift stairs,” said attorney Mary Alexander. “They couldn’t find a way out. (There were) no sprinklers, exit signs, light for exits. (There was) only one way out that (the victims) could find and then it’s a maze to get out.”
Also, the music event did not have the proper permits to proceed, Alexander said.
Alexander represents the families of Michela Gregory and Griffin Madden, who filed a wrongful death lawsuit on Dec. 23 against Chor Ng, the owner of the warehouse.
Also named are Almena and his wife, Micah Allison.
At a city council meeting in San Francisco on Monday night, Allison said she was sorry, but also lashed out at what she described as “pretty terrible” treatment by the press and former neighbors, reports the Associated Press.
“The main thing I wanted to say is how sorry I am for what happened on Dec. 2. I wish that more had been done before, because we carry a really heavy weight on our shoulders right now,” Allison said at the meeting.
Referring to media reports about her and her partner, she said: “It’s been pretty terrible what they’ve done to my family.”
The lawyer for the victims’ families said she believes regardless that Almena is culpable.
“In my view he can’t get off the hook,” Alexander said. “It’s beyond a reasonable doubt that he contributed to the deaths of these people.”
The suit also targets that night’s performer, Joel Shanahan, whose stage name is Golden Donna, Jon Hrabko and a business called “100 % Silk,” claiming they, along with Almena and Allison, were organizers of the event, which was attended by at least 100 people.
In addition, two men who leased buildings neighboring the Ghost Ship warehouse, Daniel Lopez and Omar Vega, are also named in the suit, which claims the pair provided electricity to the warehouse and bathroom access to event attendees.
A separate suit was also filed against the City of Oakland and Alameda County.
The Oakland Fire Department is currently working on its own report about the cause of the fire. When it’s completed, that report will be forwarded to the Alameda County district attorney’s office, which will then decide whether criminal charges are warranted.
A spokeswoman with the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, which has been assisting in the investigation, said the fire department’s report is still being compiled.
“We are in the midst of our investigation. Until that is complete, I cannot comment further on our findings, nor opine on the assertions of Mr. Serra and his team,” said district attorney’s spokeswoman Teresa Drenick.
