personal life during office visits may be wasting patients' valuable time.
Researchers sent a group of actors posing as new patients to primary care
doctors and found a third of doctors made unprompted comments about their own
health, personal life, or political views. The vast majority of those comments
(85%) weren't viewed as useful or relevant to the patient.
While a good bedside manner is important, researchers say that in an era of
ever-shortening office visits doctors should keep the conversation focused on
"We found that physician self-disclosures were often non sequiturs,
unattached to any discussion in the visit, and focused more on the physician's
than the patients' needs," write researcher Susan H. McDaniel, PhD, of the
University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry, and colleagues in the
Archives of Internal Medicine.
"Longer disclosures, both not useful and disruptive, interrupted the
flow of information exchange and expended valuable patient time in the
typically time-pressured primary care visit," they write.
Chatty Doctors Waste Time
In the study, researchers analyzed the transcripts of 113 visits between the
actors posing as new patients and 100 primary care providers.
The results showed doctors talked about themselves in about 34% of the
visits, most often when he or she was taking a medical history or gathering
information about the patient before a physical exam.
Only 10% of these self-disclosures were in response to a patient's question,
and the conversation returned to the patient's topic in only about one in five
"Only three physician self-disclosures (4%) were coded as useful --
providing education, support, explanation or acknowledgement or prompting some
indication from the patient that it had been helpful," write the
In addition, 11% of the personal chitchat was considered disruptive and
detracted in some way from the doctor-patient relationship. These instances
included when the doctor talked about himself or herself for an extended period
of time, inadvertently competed with the patient, requested the patient's
support, or expressed personal or political viewpoints that did not take the
patient's perspective into account.
- What do you consider the
perfect bedside manner ? Talk with others on WebMD's Active Aging Support
By Jennifer Warner
Reviewed by Louise Chang
B)2005-2006 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved