CBS News/ September 3, 2011, 9:46 AM

New plea for public's help in Aruba case

Gary Giordano and, in inset, Robyn Gardner

Gary Giordano and, in inset, Robyn Gardner / AP Photo/Aruba's Police

ORANJESTAD, Aruba -- Authorities in Aruba made a fresh plea to the public late Friday night for any information on Gary Giordano, who is being held in the disappearance of his traveling companion, fellow American tourist Robyn Gardner.

Though he's been detained for a month, reports CBS News correspondent Elaine Quijano, Girodano has yet to be charged with a crime, and has denied any wrongdoing.

He is challenging the ruling of an Aruban judge this week that extended his incarceration in an Aruban jail by 60 days.

His attorney, Michael Lopez, said he plans to appeal the ruling Monday before a three judge panel.

Giordano, 50, a businessman from Gaithersburg, Md., says he was snorkeling on the island with Gardner, 35, of Frederick, Md. early last month when she vanished, apparently having been swept out to sea.

The pair met online.

Giordano reportedly stood to gain $1.5 million in insurance money through a policy he bought specifically for their five-day trip. He apparently tried to cash it in just two days after she went missing.

Police detained Giordano when he tried to leave Aruba after promising to stay and answer questions. He has been jailed ever since.

Authorities believe Gardner is dead, but her body hasn't been found.

On "The Early Show on Saturday Morning," famed defense attorney Rob Black, who isn't involved in this case but whose clients have included William Kennedy Smith and Rush Limbaugh, said prosecutors have their work cut out for them proving Giordano was responsible for Gardner's disappearance and presumed death.

"It's just purely circumstantial evidence at this time," Black, speaking from Miami, told co-anchor Russ Mitchell, "and I say purely -- there obviously are some interesting facts leading up to the disappearance of this young woman. But the problem is, without a body, it is very hard to make a case like this, because how do you prove it's not accidental? So, while he has acted very strangely and there are some unusual circumstances, this is certainly not a slam-dunk case."

To see the entire interview of Black, click on the video below:

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
8 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
formrusmcsgt says:
Aruba has one hell of a police force, eh?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
lilbear925 says:
Once again, the Aruban authorities have let another person disappear from under their noses, and haven't got a clue. How many others have met the same fate, but have never been reported? Have they talked to the Kalpoe brothers, yet?
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
PR_in_Alabama says:
He held her head underwater, she can't scream, she can't go for his face, that is why his legs were all scratched..in other words she was drowned.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
DoctorGlennPHD says:
Is this case really so difficult that the Aruban police have little if any evidence? I think the man is guilty as sin, but without evidence to prove his guilt, then let him go.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Imthaid2 says:
Who cares what happened to that tramp?! She was cheating on her boyfriend and lying about it. She deserves what she got.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
expat31 says:
Isn't it strange that this is the second woman to disappear within the past two or three years under almost identical circumstances. I keep wondering if these women were drugged, transported to the mainland, and then shipped off to a harem in Indonesia or some other Southeast Asian country. This has been known to happen. I find it almost incredible that the authorities can find no trace of either woman on a relatively small island like Aruba.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
andie52 says:
The scratches' on his neck the fact that he tried to skip town and also cash in that insurance policy and no one ever saw them snorkeling nor did they rent any equipment to go snorkeling, told people at the airport that she was taking a later flight, he has plenty to hide.
reply
glennyg replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
EXACTLY! He probably strangled her,hence the scratches or muscled her into the water to drown her.Buried her in sand with his hands,hence sweating.Ignore the bs defense attorney - who needs the body? It might tell investigators zippo at this point anyway.The bastard is going down,he'll never leave his island alive.