CBS News/ May 11, 2011, 9:37 AM

Bin Laden widows likely to tell U.S. "nothing"

American officials are still awaiting access to the three widows of Osama bin Laden, who have been in Pakistani custody since the raid that killed the al Qaeda leader.

But what information could the U.S. get from them if they are, in fact, interrogated?

Former CIA Operations officer Charles Faddis told "Early Show" co-anchor Erica Hill Wednesday U.S. officials aren't likely to learn much from the women.

Special Report: The killing of Osama bin Laden

"I wouldn't anticipate what we're going to get out of these ladies. Assuming we get access, it's going to be extremely limited," Faddis said. "It's about compulsion - I'm not talking physical force - but you have to have some mechanism for making a person want to talk, and all of the dynamics are contrary to that."

Hill said, "There's no incentive whatsoever for the women to talk."

Faddis replied, "These are people who have dedicated their lives to bin Laden and to the cause. We just killed bin Laden. I would think they would think fundamentally the best way they could revere and remember him would be to give us absolutely nothing."

However, Faddis added any information the women may have is "pretty limited."

"I would not think they would operationally be involved, and I expect they were probably confined to relatively domestic routines," he said.

Hill said, "Would those domestic routines, even details on daily life inside that compound, the daily routines of Osama bin Laden, could that offer any insight?"

"It could offer insight," Faddis responded. "In this business, you're looking for any scrap of information, so in a perfect world, would we like to know that? Yeah. I don't think the ladies will have key details on plots and threats and frankly, I don't think they'll give us much of anything."

Faddis described the possible setting of a U.S. interrogation of the women, saying, "We're going to a limited period of time in the presence of Pakistani intelligence or security officials. They're going to bring them there. We'll be in front of them for a limited period of time. These women are going to know we don't have them under our control and they're there for a narrow window of time, so they just wait it out."

What about when these women are released? Will they go back to al Qaeda with information?

Faddis said these women are not likely to know sensitive details about the al Qaeda operation.

He said, "Fundamentally I don't think these are individuals who have any keys to the kingdom."

Those Faddis said he'd like to talk to are the couriers at the compound and "other individuals" who he says were "obviously" involved.

"Osama was communicating with the rest of the network via couriers," Faddis said. "So what we really want now is the people to whom those couriers were going from Osama."

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
20 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
ynobasedrum says:
"Hi, we shot your husband and have you and your children and you in custody. Why are you so defiant?"

We help Americans find jobs and prosperity in Asia. For details, visit http://www.pathtoasia.com/jobs1/
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
erasmus111 says:
They may just spill their guts. I can't imagine that they were happy living with Osama bin Laden. Especially after being cooped up for 5 or 6 years in one room. They probably weren't treated well.

Offer them a home in the good old U.S.A. That should do it. : )
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Well_You_Aint_Me says:
OK, make them sit naked in a cold room under alternating bright light and total darkness for 23 hours a day listening to Metallica at maximum volume. Then for the other hour waterboard them.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tigersbay says:
Why cant you lie to them,tell them hes alive get someone to inpersonate him crying down the phone and then get them to open up.Whatever happened to good old truth serum?.If none of that works just torture them and even if they die nobody will care.Its a win win win situation that I bet everyone wants.
reply
erasmus111 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
by tigersbay May 11, 2011 12:38 PM EDT
Why cant you lie to them,tell them hes alive...


Uhhhh, that might be a little difficult, considering they witnessed his death.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mjlewis6 says:
D*ick Cheney as VP during the years we gave billions to Pakistan could employ his "legal water boarding" and get the information out of them as to what they know.

Then, we could "legally" water board D*ick Cheney and see if he planted information and what the circumstances truly were as to the funding to Pakistan for NOT finding bin Ladin so as to facilitate the invasion of Iraq.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
ClarksvilleTN says:
UM DUH!!!!
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
alaskanpoet says:
It would be the height of folly to assume
That women in al Qaeda were in the planning rooms
Hard to speak all covered and kept out of school
Only useful as a bomb carrying tool
A lot of publicity but a dead end
More tension, wasted chips with our Pakistani "friend."
Hell hath no fury than a woman scorned
What about being shot in the leg in a Seals storm?
Maybe I am wrong and good intel may be gleened from a spouse
More likely a podium on how we killed an unarmed husband to rant and grouse
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
abby_del_abbey says:
I think you can rule out any info from them. You killed their source of income whether they actually "loved" him or not. They could also be just fanatical sheep like the rest of bin Laden's followers.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
stupa5 says:
You want these wive to Talk easy...no torture needed just give them 2 choices!
A. 2 week all expenses paid, room Service, Spa Treaments..
at the 4 Seasons in Mauai,
plus a $50000 pre paid Macy's card....
B. or An indefinate stay at Guatamano Hilton... no AC!
reply
Well_You_Aint_Me replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I'd take plan "A", and I am a male.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tomford429 says:
We'll have to wait for them to go on Oprah and tell all.
reply
See all 20 Comments