CBS News/ April 14, 2011, 8:01 AM

LaHood: Air traffic control issues "outrageous"

An air traffic controller in Reno, Nev., was suspended Wednesday after sleeping on the job. It's another disturbing incident in a string of safety lapses involving air traffic controllers, which Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood called "outrageous" and said they would "not stand on my watch."

"We're not going to sit back and wait for somebody to tell us what to do. This is outrageous behavior. It's ridiculous. And that's the reason that I ordered two controllers in every tower," LaHood told CBS' "The Early Show" Thursday, "so that people have the assurance that these towers are safe, and the controllers can guide planes in and out of airports."

"These controllers need to be alert. They need to be awake. They need to be well-trained," he said. "This is a very bad situation, and we've stepped up, and I think taken action quickly, and we're going to continue to investigate these incidents until we get to the bottom of it."

Air traffic chief resigns after series of lapses

The latest incident prompted the resignation of the head of air traffic controllers. Federal Aviation Administration head Randy Babbitt said he accepted the resignation of Air Traffic Organization chief Hank Krakowski Thursday, calling him a "dedicated aviation professional," but citing "unprofessional conduct on the part of a few individuals that have rightly caused the traveling public to question our ability to ensure their safety."

"This conduct must stop immediately. I am committed to maintaining the highest level of public confidence and that begins with strong leadership," Babbitt said in a statement.

Babbitt announced that David Grizzle, the FAA's chief counsel, will assume the role of acting chief operating officer of the agency while the search for a permanent replacement goes forward.

In the Reno incident, the sleeping controller did not respond to the calls from an air ambulance flight, trying to land with an emergency patient. The pilot circled the airport, his calls becoming more urgent and meeting only silence.

"We've got a pretty sick patient, we may just have to land," he said. He did reach the Federal Aviation Administration in California, which told him "landing will be at your own risk." The pilot landed safely.

The FAA has now disclosed seven similar instances of sleeping controllers in just the last three months: Reno, two instances in Lubbock, Tex., one controller caught napping three times in Seattle, plus now-infamous cases in Washington, D.C. -- where two passenger planes landed unassisted -- and Knoxville, Tenn., where a controller was bringing blankets into work to nap on the job.

How many air traffic controllers is too few?
Air traffic controller admits to sleeping on job
Video: FAA suspends sleeping air traffic controller

One or two instances of sleeping in the tower might have been considered mistakes or "bad apple" employees. But seven recent cases is a dangerous pattern, and the FAA says it is taking immediate action, reports CBS News correspondent Wyatt Andrews. It has ordered an additional 27 controllers to work the midnight-8 a.m. shift, doubling up at airports where only one controller worked before.

LaHood stressed that flying is safe and that the new staffing addresses immediate concerns while officials do a thorough review of the situation -- including looking at training and shift timing.

"This is an outrageous situation that will not stand on my watch," he said. "We'll get to the bottom of it, and we'll get corrections."

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
14 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
bobnjersey says:
["This is an outrageous situation that will not stand on my watch," he said. "We'll get to the bottom of it, and we'll get corrections."]
--------------------------------------------------
maybe the ex-homeland security officials now working for the full body scanning manufacturers can sell the transportation dept hundreds of millions in hardware (sleep scanners) to solve the problem. maybe there's even some ex-transportation dept officials that can start working for companies to make a 'sleep interrupter' device ... for a million apiece to make us all safe.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
1ptcrtn1 says:
Reagan fires 11,000 striking air traffic controllers Aug. 5, 1981
Reagan should not have fired the professionally trained controllers
reply
bradkt1 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Get a life! That was 28 years ago. Those striking controllers would all be retired by now. Beside, that has nothing to do either with individual controllers falling asleep on the job or with a stupid decision by FAA management to put only one controller in a tower on the graveyard shift.
bobnjersey replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
[If you strike a national transportation system, you are a terrorist.]
------------------------------------------------
and you are an idiot.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
uffdaron says:
I challenge any one to stay awake all night in a situation where there are huge time gaps of no activity. There has to be a better way...snooze alarms?? rotating phone calls ?? I don't know but I feel sorry for the people on duty... Larger crews is the first step , but 2 can fall to sleep just as easily... The old Military 4 on 4 off may help, maybe 2 on 2 off rotating??

This is too big an issue for Ray LaHood to solve...we need better leadership...he was unaware that this was even going on.. Can't pilots call some emergency frequency where a phone call could reach the tower. obviously radio is not waking these snoozers up...there has to be a radio-phone crossover somewhere. Few people can shut out a phone, pareticularly if they are working and supposed to be awake..
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cbsblogger says:
This is an indication of a structural problem in the FAA and probably due to budgets, under staffing, unreasonable work schedules and a lack of redundancy in what is a critical job.

It would be like having an airplane with only a pilot, or having the airplane maintenance done in Somalia, China or Mexico (OH? they are already doing the latter?).
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
esq777 says:
Thanks Ronald Reagan.
reply
uffdaron replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Ronald Regan is no longer President and in fact he has been dead for quite awhile.

Do you have any idea who is President now??? YES YOU DO!!
linkicon reporticon emailicon
tsigili says:
No one to blame for that but the FAA themselves. Bad policies, will result in problems.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
cabaraoke says:
You are not giving the times when the FFA Traffic Controllers are falling asleep. Statistically, the 3-5 AM time frame is the highest point of the day for on the job injuries. As humans, we are genetically designed to be awake during the day, and sleeping at night. Artificial light is the worst thing for us. The surge in reports on this right now may be a combination of this and seasonal changes to also make people drowsy.

Years ago, the AMA came out with recommendations for night workers, but employers generally ignored them. Day sleepers should have an absolutely dark room to sleep in, that is cool enough that a blanket needs to be use. We must trick the brain into believing it is nighttime.

Several major processes take place at night while we sleep. Our immune system regenerates, while most healing is initiated, the brain is downloading everything we learned during the day, sorting and categorizing it, and the muscles are flushing out lactic acid, replacing it with a store house of oxygen. Sleeping during the day, under the wrong conditions, is not getting this accomplished.

Of note, 4 PM is the #2 peak period of time for injuries. We are supposed to be taking a nap at this time.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
bradkt1 says:
You hear the same mantra that safety wasn't compromised coming out of the FAA so often that their reflexive assurances have lost all credibility with the public.

Safety is compromised when the only air traffic controller on duty at a tower whose job it is to help aircraft move around the airport, take off and land falls asleep and airplanes have to land at night on their own. Safety is compromised when only one air traffic controller is working the graveyard shift at a tower. While each controller is responsibile for his/her own actions, the fault for allowing this situation to escalate to the point that it did clearly lies with FAA management. There has to be more than one person in an air traffic control tower at all times.

I'm not impressed by Secretary Lahood's so-called "outrage." These political hacks from both parties never know what really goes on in their own agencies. The only thing that changes with each new administration is the face of the political appointee at the top of the agency. The identity of the usual suspects never changes. I once heard them famously described as "termites in the foundation of air safety..."

...and that's exactly what they are.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
creeper00 says:
So now we're going to double the number of employees to police each other? At what cost? Wouldn't it just be simpler to start firing the ones who fall asleep? How many of these people are still working the tower?
reply
mask2697 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
they are firing the ones that fall asleep, but there are alot of these people
linkicon reporticon emailicon
clarkalex says:
Love how you hater dingbats can take a non-political article and turn it into something it wasn't meant to be.
reply
See all 14 Comments