CBS News/ March 2, 2011, 7:31 AM

"Striking stats" on college football and crime

For the past six months, CBS News and Sports Illustrated have investigated the criminal background of college football players and, as CBS New Chief Investigative Correspondent Armen Keteyian reported on "The Early Show" Wednesday, turned up "some alarming truths" when it comes to the sport and crime.

One case in point -- a 17-year-old girl was alone in her family home last March, out sick from school, when two men broke in.

The girl could be heard on a call to 911 saying, "They're in the house! ... I hear them in the kitchen."

Miami police quickly responded to the scene, and 18-year-old high school student Antwan Darling was arrested at gunpoint and charged with felony burglary.

Video: Crime and college football players' pasts
Video: NCAA President "concerned" over the investigation's findings
Video: High school football player takes wrong turn

Court records reveal that Darling, now a freshman linebacker at the University of Cincinnati, had been arrested twice before, for marijuana possession, to which he pleaded no contest, and on a weapons charge that was later dropped. In the burglary case, Darling completed an intervention program.

Armen Keteyian blog: CBS NEWS/SI: How the marriage worked, and why

The school evidently knew nothing about Darling's record.

Jeff Benedict, co-author of the Sports Illustrated cover story says, "We found that, in many cases, even the coaches don't know the full extent of players' criminal histories."

Sports Illustrated: College Football and Criminal Records
SI: Likely Impact of the Probe

Darling's criminal history was just a small part of a ground-breaking, six-month CBS News-Sports Illustrated investigation focusing on crime and recruiting in big-time college football and, says Keteyian, "What we found was striking."

Through an exhaustive series of background checks, the probe discovered that seven percent of the 2,837 players on the magazine's 2010 top 25 pre-season football rosters had been in trouble with the law. More than 200 players had either been arrested or formally cited by police. Thirty-nine percent of those who'd been arrested had been charged with serious crimes such as assault and battery, domestic violence, burglary, cocaine possession or DUI.

"Another startling number," Keteyian added, was that, "only two schools in our sample did any kind of regular criminal background check on their recruits."

"I think," Richard Lapchick, director of the Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sports told CBS News, "as a general population, these are going to be stunning statistics to try to absorb, and policy changes will hopefully come about as a result."

Asked by "Early Show" co-anchor Chris Wragge what the NCAA might do in the wake of the study, Keteyian responded, "To their credit, Mark Emmert, the new president of the NCAA, has already been alerted to this and has called it 'completely unacceptable.' I would venture to guess there's going to be some changes coming very soon, whether they're by (individual college football) conference or by legislate by the association (the NCAA)."

Tune in to "The CBS Evening News with Katie Couric" for much more on this tonight.

© 2011 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
45 Comments Add a Comment
linkicon reporticon emailicon
npanther says:
When will your investigation on ALL the college sports be published? It would be interesting to know if this is a problem across the board.
reply
epowell63 replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Clayton Christensen in the Harvard Business Review states that two guys in his Rhodes Scholar class of 32 were convicted of felonies. That's 6%. So, that's probably worse than the Top 25 College Football in terms of Jail time for a felony.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
rmichem says:
YOu should look into college programs, dealing with BASKETBALL. The story of a cover up I could tell, you would not believe.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
KSAXT1 says:
Go ahead and report the really striking statistic. How many are black?
reply
olbabee replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Probably 95% at least
sbrittai replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
The cnnsi story on this said that 60% were black while about 50% of the athletes over all are black. Not a particularly significant over representation given the relatively small number of subjects in the study.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Revedev says:
Why don't you investigate wall street CEOs since they caused a he'll of a lot more pain than a bunch of poor kids trying to make something of themselves. Maybe your rich bosses don't want that. Look at Egypt keep picking on poor people and leave rich people alone to steal from Americans.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
sgtnitnoy says:
Not really new because as most everyone know it winning is the ultimate goal, winning games that is.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
mf1369 says:
So, not all football players are choir boys.....what a shock! Ugh! give me a break. Juvenille records are supposed to be sealed, how did cbs get their hands on them in the first place? Also, several of the players mentioned in their story had been through rehabilitation programs. Do we really want to set this standard that we DONT allow rehabilitation when someone makes a mistake? When you do your time, your are supposed to be allowed to continue on with your life. What is cbs suggesting? All kids who make mistakes shouldn't be allowed scholarships to college or to play sports????? This could be their ticket to a new law abiding life or we could set them up to spend their lives in jail b/c we keep knocking them down instead of building them up. Yes, some will squander the chance but many more will not.

To me, this was an irresponsible story with no purpose.
reply
olbabee replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
I'd say the majority will squander the chance. Looks at the pros. Same stuff over & over by high paid gangsters,
linkicon reporticon emailicon
kaylag04 says:
39% of 7% of players in the sample had a history of "serious" crimes. That's approximately 3 one-hundreths of one-percent. While I would support college recruiting policies that include background checks, the overall numbers make this hardly news. In fact, it is a lower rate than the general incarceration rate nationwide (0.75%). Why didn't the headline read, "No Too Many College Football Players Are Criminals!".
reply
WhiskeyHotel replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
Umm, by my math - .39 X .07 = .0273 or 2.73% or about 4 times the nationwide rate. Nice.
sbrittai replies:
linkicon reporticon emailicon
About 6% of men are either in jail/prison, on parole, or probation. I've not been able to find the fraction of US citizens that have ever been convicted of any kind of crime, but 6% currently serving some kind of punishment is comparable to the 7% found in this study. Given sampling uncertainties it isn't clear that the difference is significant.

Interestingly CSPI claims that 5% of college students have been cited for underage drinking while 80% admit to underage drinking. This is much higher than the rate for students measured in this sample. One might conclude that football players are choirboys compared to the general student population. The lack of context in this article is outrageous. I guess I shouldn't expect much more from sportswriters posing as serious journalists.
linkicon reporticon emailicon
saucymugwump says:
CBS News wrote: "Mark Emmert, the new president of the NCAA, has already been alerted to this and has called it 'completely unacceptable.'"

This has been going on for decades. Even when I attended a Big Ten university a long time ago, black football players were often arrested for rape, weapons charges, and beating up smaller men in bars. There was a shooting just outside my dorm one day, in the middle of the day

The only thing Emmert finds unacceptable is that it has been made public.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
random_radar says:
Football is a mock battle because we love war. We want the biggest, meanest people to fight for out team. Who better to do that than the criminal element? Society gets what it deserves in the end.
reply
linkicon reporticon emailicon
dfang24 says:
If a kid makes a mistake and pays the price they should be given a chance to turn their life around. If they are not given that chance they will most likely repeat and cost society in the long run.
reply
See all 45 Comments